Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Sheeran & Ors v Chokri & Ors

England and Wales High Court (Chancery Division)
Apr 6, 2022
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The claimants are the writers of a popular song released in early 2017, which achieved significant commercial success worldwide. The defendants are writers of an earlier song, released in 2015, and a music management company holding rights assigned from one of the defendants. The dispute concerns an eight-bar post-chorus section of the claimants' song, referred to as the "OI Phrase," which the defendants allege was copied from a similar section, the "OW Hook," in their song.

The claimants commenced proceedings seeking declarations that they had not infringed copyright in the defendants' song. This was in response to the defendants' notification to a collecting society, which resulted in suspension of payments to the claimants for public performance and broadcast royalties. The defendants counterclaimed, alleging copyright infringement.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the claimants copied a substantial part of the defendants' copyrighted musical work.
  2. Whether the claimants had access to the defendants' work, either consciously or subconsciously.
  3. Whether the elements alleged to be copied represent the original expression of the defendants' authors.
  4. Whether the court should grant the declaratory relief sought by the claimants.

Arguments of the Parties

Defendants' Arguments

  • The "OI Phrase" in the claimants' song was copied, either consciously or subconsciously, from the defendants' "OW Hook."
  • There is sufficient similarity between the works and clear evidence of access to shift the evidential burden to the claimants.
  • Mr Sheeran had a propensity to copy or reference other artists, supported by similar fact evidence from other songs.
  • The claimants failed to explain adequately the creation of the disputed phrase.
  • There are three "fingerprints" of the defendants' work within the claimants' song.
  • Even if copying is not established, the claimants are not entitled to the declaration on discretionary grounds.

Claimants' Arguments

  • The disputed phrase was created independently, with a natural evolution during songwriting and production sessions.
  • There are significant differences between the disputed phrases, and the similarities are based on common, generic musical elements.
  • There is no credible evidence that the claimants had access to the defendants' song.
  • The elements alleged to be copied are not protectable as original expression.
  • The claimants deny any deliberate or subconscious copying.
  • The defendants' similar fact evidence is either irrelevant or does not support the copying claim.
  • The claimants seek a declaration that they did not infringe copyright, justified both commercially and reputationally.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Newspaper Licensing Agency Ltd v Meltwater Holding BV [2011] EWCA Civ 890 Qualitative assessment of copying substantial part of a work; applying intellectual creation test. Used to establish that copying must involve taking the expression that confers originality.
Infopaq International A/S v Danske Dagblades Forening [2009] ECDR 16 Definition of substantial part and originality in copyright. Applied in assessing which elements of the work are protectable.
Mitchell v BBC [2011] EWPCC 42 Clarification on the burden of proof and subconscious copying; qualitative test of originality. Referenced to explain evidential burdens and factual determination of subconscious copying.
Designers Guild v Russell Williams [2000] 1 WLR 2416 Approach to comparing works for infringement; visual/auditory comparison; disregarding commonplace elements. Guided the court’s approach to comparing musical works and identifying protectable elements.
Francis Day & Hunter v Bron [1963] 1 Ch 587 Establishing proof of familiarity for subconscious copying; causal link between works. Applied to evaluate the possibility and requirements for subconscious copying.
Baigent v Random House [2007] EWCA Civ 247 Proof of access required to shift evidential burden in copying cases. Considered in discussing the evidential burden regarding access to the original work.
Mood Music Publishing Co v De Wolfe Ltd [1970] 1 Ch 119 Admissibility of similar fact evidence to show propensity to copy. Referenced regarding the use of other alleged copying instances as supporting evidence.
Hayes v Phonogram Ltd [2003] ECDR 11 Orchestration and musical expression as protectable elements in musical works. Used to support the protectability of the combination of musical features in the disputed work.
Financial Services Authority v Rourke [2002] CP Rep 14 Discretionary nature of declaratory relief and factors to consider. Applied to weigh whether to grant the declaratory relief sought by the claimants.
Nokia Corp v InterDigital Technology Corp [2006] EWCA Civ 1618 Requirement of a real commercial reason for granting declaratory relief. Considered in the court’s exercise of discretion regarding the declarations sought.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court undertook a detailed comparison of the disputed musical phrases, identifying both similarities and significant differences, including rhythm, mood, melodic nuances, and harmonic structure. It emphasized the commonplace nature of many shared elements, such as the use of the rising minor pentatonic scale and vocal chants, which are generic in popular music.

The court considered expert evidence but stressed that the ultimate determination of copying is a factual matter for the court itself. It found compelling evidence that the disputed phrase evolved naturally during songwriting and production sessions rather than being copied.

The court examined the defendants' claims of access, finding the evidence speculative and insufficient to establish that the claimant had heard the defendants' work. Efforts to publicize the defendants' song were limited in scope and did not credibly reach the claimants.

Similar fact evidence of the claimant's alleged propensity to copy was largely rejected as irrelevant or insufficient to support the copying claim. The court found the claimant's explanations and recollections credible and consistent with honest efforts to assist the court.

The court dismissed the defendants' assertions of "fingerprints" in the claimant’s work, explaining alternative explanations for the alleged markers. It concluded that the defendants failed to prove deliberate or subconscious copying.

On originality, the court accepted that the defendants' work contained original elements but found that the disputed elements in question were generic musical building blocks, not conferring originality sufficient to support infringement.

Regarding declaratory relief, the court applied established principles, considering the commercial stakes and the claimants' reputational interests, and rejected the defendants' objections based on procedural or disclosure issues.

Holding and Implications

The court held that the claimants did not infringe the defendants' copyright in the musical work at issue.

The court granted the claimants' request for a declaration of non-infringement, dismissing the defendants' counterclaim. The decision was based on a thorough factual and legal analysis, emphasizing the lack of sufficient evidence of copying, the generic nature of the musical elements involved, and the speculative nature of alleged access.

No new legal precedent was established; the ruling applied settled principles of copyright law to the facts. The direct effect is that the claimants are free to exploit their song without liability for infringement in respect of the disputed phrase, and the defendants' claim is dismissed.