Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

BEST ON CONVENIENCE STORE (a firm) v Revenue & Customs (ncome tax and VAT - COP9 investigation - suppression of business income)

First-tier Tribunal (Tax)
Mar 16, 2022
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The Appellant is a partnership trading as Best on Convenience Store, formed by two partners who were married at the relevant times but later divorced. The partnership operated from premises in Blackpool. Following a Code of Practice 9 (COP9) investigation, HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC) amended the partnership's income tax returns and assessed the partners and the partnership for undeclared income and supplies. Penalties were also charged for deliberate, concealed, and dishonest behaviour.

HMRC issued various notices to the Appellant including VAT assessments under section 73 of the VAT Act 1994 (VATA) for periods from February 2005 to October 2012, penalties under section 60(1) VATA and Schedule 24 of the Finance Act 2007 for certain VAT periods, amendments to income tax returns under section 30B Taxes Management Act 1970 (TMA), and a closure notice under section 28B TMA.

The Notice of Appeal focused solely on the Appellant's VAT liabilities and amendments to partnership income tax returns. The hearing was conducted in a hybrid format due to the COVID-19 pandemic, with the partners attending in person and others via video link. Witness statements and oral evidence were heard, including from the HMRC officer responsible for the assessments.

The Appellant acquired the convenience store in December 2004, refurbished it, and operated in a competitive and declining market area of Blackpool. Increased competition, redevelopment plans, and eventual lease surrender in October 2012 affected the business viability. HMRC opened an enquiry into the partnership's income tax return for 2010/11, which escalated into a COP9 investigation due to suspected irregularities. The partners accepted a Contractual Disclosure Facility (CDF) and made disclosures admitting irregularities but denying fraudulent activity.

HMRC officer evidence revealed substantial understatement of profits and purchases, discrepancies in bank account deposits, and failure to keep adequate records such as till audit rolls. An expert accountant's report, commissioned for confiscation proceedings against one partner for counterfeit tobacco trading, highlighted further discrepancies. HMRC issued formal assessments and amendments after no adequate explanations were provided.

The officer calculated under-declared VAT and income tax by analysing bank statements, supplier records, and applying assumptions about purchase suppression rates. The officer concluded the partners had deliberately understated profits and turnover. Penalties were assessed based on dishonest conduct and deliberate concealment.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Appellant failed to make required VAT returns or keep necessary documents under section 73 VATA.
  2. Whether the VAT amounts assessed were determined to HMRC's best judgment.
  3. Whether the Appellant took action to evade VAT involving dishonesty under section 60 VATA.
  4. The amount of VAT evaded, if any.
  5. Whether the Appellant submitted VAT returns containing inaccuracies amounting to an understatement of tax liability under Schedule 24 FA 2007.
  6. Whether such inaccuracies were deliberate and concealed.
  7. Whether HMRC discovered that the profits declared in the partnership income tax returns were insufficient under section 30B TMA.
  8. Whether any insufficiency was brought about deliberately.
  9. Whether the closure notice under section 28B TMA was issued for the correct amount.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The partners asserted that invoices blowing away when unloading stock was a genuine issue due to the windy location, explaining missing purchase records.
  • They denied deliberately destroying till audit rolls, suggesting they were lost accidentally through carelessness.
  • They contended that the business was struggling financially due to competition and declining profits, denying intentional suppression of purchases or sales.
  • The partners denied acting deliberately or dishonestly and claimed errors arose from lack of complete information, not fraud.
  • They explained delays in communication with HMRC were due to their accountant's illness and one partner’s criminal trial and imprisonment.
  • They criticized HMRC’s calculations, claimed some loans supported the business, and argued that some loans were genuine, though HMRC disputed some of these.
  • They claimed the disclosure schedules submitted were initial negotiation positions rather than final disclosures.

Respondents' Arguments

  • HMRC argued that the partners deliberately understated income and purchases to evade tax, supported by discrepancies between declared figures and supplier information.
  • HMRC contended that the partners’ explanations, including invoices blowing away and loss of audit rolls, were not credible and were deliberate acts to conceal true figures.
  • HMRC maintained that the partners acted dishonestly in submitting incorrect VAT returns and income tax returns.
  • HMRC relied on bank account analyses and expert reports to demonstrate undeclared income and purchases.
  • HMRC disputed the genuineness of some loans claimed by the partners to support the business.
  • HMRC asserted that the partners failed to provide full and truthful disclosures despite the CDF process.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Van Boeckel v Customs and Excise Commissioners [1981] STC 290 Standards for HMRC’s best judgment in making VAT assessments. The court applied the principle that HMRC must act honestly, fairly consider all material, and base assessments on reasonable judgment without doing the taxpayer’s work.
Johnson v Scott (1977) 52 TC 383 Burden of proof and discovery under section 30B TMA. The court held that once HMRC makes a reasonable discovery of insufficient tax, the burden shifts to the taxpayer to disprove the assessment; estimates must be fair.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court found that the HMRC officer made a valid discovery under section 30B TMA that the partnership’s declared profits were insufficient. The court accepted that the Appellant failed to make accurate VAT returns and failed to keep necessary documents to verify those returns under section 73 VATA.

The court rejected the partners’ explanations for missing invoices and audit rolls, finding these losses were deliberate acts to conceal actual purchases and sales. The court did not accept that the disclosure schedules were preliminary negotiation positions, instead finding the partners did not provide a complete disclosure as required under the CDF.

The court noted significant discrepancies between supplier records and declared purchases, which were too large to be inadvertent errors. The court found that the partners knowingly filed incorrect VAT and income tax returns to reduce tax liabilities, acting deliberately and dishonestly.

The court made adjustments to the HMRC officer’s calculations to account for certain loans evidenced at the hearing and to reflect realistic suppression ratios during the final trading period, but otherwise upheld the officer’s assessments as made to his best judgment.

The court found that the partners’ conduct in evading VAT was dishonest for the relevant periods under section 60 VATA and that VAT returns contained deliberate and concealed inaccuracies for later periods under Schedule 24 FA 2007, justifying penalties at the percentages assessed by HMRC.

The court considered the mitigation offered for penalties but found it appropriate and did not reduce penalties further. The court also found that errors in procedure regarding the amendment of a non-existent partnership return fell within section 114 TMA and did not invalidate the assessments.

Holding and Implications

The appeals against VAT assessments and income tax determinations were allowed in part to the extent of the adjustments made to the calculations of VAT liability and income, but otherwise dismissed.

The court directed HMRC to prepare updated calculations reflecting adjustments discussed, to be served on the Tribunal and the Appellant within 30 days. The Appellant will have 14 days to provide submissions on these calculations. The Tribunal will then determine the final amounts of tax and penalties payable.

The Appellant, as a partnership, is jointly and severally liable for the VAT and penalties. Income tax adjustments will be allocated between the partners according to their profit-sharing ratios, with consequential amendments to their individual returns.

The tax and penalties become due for payment with interest following the Tribunal’s final decision. Any arrangements for installment payments are outside the Tribunal’s jurisdiction.

No new legal precedent was established; the decision applies existing tax law principles to the facts of this case.