Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Miss R Patel v Leicester City Council (England and Wales : Race Discrimination)

United Kingdom Employment Tribunal
Mar 15, 2021
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The Claimant was employed by Company A as a Resilience Officer from 1 July 1988 until 10 December 2019, the agreed effective date of termination. The Claimant initiated early conciliation on 4 March 2020, with a certificate issued on 2 April 2020 naming Company A as the prospective Respondent. On 1 May 2020, the Claimant submitted a claim form to the Employment Tribunal, but incorrectly named the Respondent as "Leicestershire City Council" instead of Company A. Due to this discrepancy, the claim was rejected on 11 May 2020 during vetting by an Employment Judge. The Claimant applied for reconsideration on 21 May 2020, arguing the error was minor and rejecting the claim was not in the interests of justice. The Employment Judge subsequently accepted the claim as properly presented on 21 May 2020, although this rendered the claim one day late for unfair dismissal purposes. The Respondent raised the issue of timeliness at a Preliminary Hearing on 24 August 2020. The Claimant then applied for reconsideration of the 11 May rejection decision, which is the subject of this opinion.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Claimant's application for reconsideration of the 11 May 2020 decision to reject the claim should be granted.
  2. If the claim is out of time, whether it was reasonably practicable for the Claimant to present the claim within the time limit.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The Claimant asserted that the error in naming the Respondent was a minor typographical mistake.
  • The Claimant argued it was not in the interests of justice to reject the claim on this basis.
  • The Claimant's solicitors submitted legal arguments supporting reconsideration, although these were not detailed in the opinion.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The Respondent identified that the claim, although accepted, was presented out of time, particularly relevant to the unfair dismissal claim.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Mist v Derby Community Health Services NHS Trust [UKEAT/0170/15] Determining whether discrepancies in naming parties constitute a "minor error" under Rule 12(2A). The court found the present typographical error less significant than in Mist, categorising it as a minor error not justifying rejection of the claim.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court initially rejected the claim due to the incorrect naming of the Respondent on the claim form, as no entity named "Leicestershire City Council" exists. However, the court recognized that the two local authorities, Company A and another local authority, are distinct entities, and the error was a typographical addition of the word "shire". The court concluded that the Respondent was not prejudiced or taken by surprise by the error since the address for service corresponded to Company A.

After hearing submissions from both parties, the court determined that the initial rejection was erroneous. The typographical mistake fell within the scope of a "minor error" under Rule 12(2A) of the Employment Tribunals Rules of Procedure 2013, and rejecting the claim would cause the Claimant undue hardship by potentially barring an unfair dismissal claim. The court referred to the precedent in Mist v Derby Community Health Services NHS Trust to support this reasoning.

The court clarified that Rule 13(1)(a), governing reconsideration of rejected claims, was the appropriate procedural mechanism rather than Rule 70. The court also exercised its general power under Rule 5 to extend time to consider the application. Consequently, the decision to reject the claim was revoked, and the claim was deemed accepted as of 1 May 2020, rendering it in time. The court did not need to address whether an extension of time was justified on "not reasonably practicable" grounds for the unfair dismissal complaint.

Holding and Implications

The court's final decision is that the 11 May 2020 rejection of the claim is REVOKED and the claim is accepted as having been presented on 1 May 2020, thus in time.

This decision enables the Claimant to pursue the unfair dismissal claim on its merits. No broader precedent was established beyond the application of existing rules concerning minor errors in claim form particulars and reconsideration procedures.