Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Swatch AG v Apple Inc

England and Wales High Court (Chancery Division)
Mar 29, 2021
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This opinion concerns an appeal from a decision of the Hearing Officer, Judge Morris, acting on behalf of the Registrar of Trade Marks, regarding oppositions brought by the Appellee ('Apple') against trade mark applications filed by the Appellant ('Swatch'). The trade mark applications in question were international registrations designating the UK for the signs "SWATCH ONE MORE THING" and "ONE MORE THING," covering goods including watches and consumer electronics. The oppositions were based on grounds under sections 5(4)(a) and 3(6) of the Trade Marks Act 1994, alleging passing off and bad faith respectively.

The phrase "ONE MORE THING" was notably used by Apple in product launches since 1998, popularized by its late founder. Swatch, a Swiss watch manufacturer with a longstanding trade mark dispute with Apple, filed these applications amid ongoing tensions, which Apple alleged were retaliatory or blocking in nature.

The procedural history includes a significant delay between the Hearing Officer’s decision dated 19 October 2017 and the hearing of this appeal, caused by extended applications for extension of time and settlement attempts. Ultimately, no settlement was reached and the appeal proceeded.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the phrase "ONE MORE THING" had acquired distinctiveness sufficient to support opposition under section 5(4)(a) for passing off.
  2. Whether the trade mark applications were made in bad faith under section 3(6) of the Trade Marks Act 1994, specifically whether Swatch intended to use the marks to parody Apple or for other improper purposes.
  3. Whether an intention to parody constitutes bad faith under section 3(6).
  4. The evidential sufficiency and legal correctness of the Hearing Officer’s findings regarding Swatch’s intentions at the time of application.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellee's Arguments

  • Apple contended that the phrase "ONE MORE THING" was associated with its goodwill and that Swatch’s applications infringed that goodwill under passing off principles (section 5(4)(a)).
  • Apple argued the applications were filed in bad faith (section 3(6)), primarily alleging that Swatch intended to block Apple from using the phrase or to retaliate in an ongoing dispute.
  • They maintained that the applications were a form of "blocking" or "dog in the manger" tactic, which is recognized as bad faith in trade mark law.
  • Apple further alleged that Swatch intended to use the marks to parody or troll Apple, thereby acting contrary to acceptable commercial behaviour.
  • Apple relied on third-party online commentary and industry speculation as evidence supporting their bad faith claim.

Appellant's Arguments

  • Swatch did not provide explicit evidence of its intentions behind filing the applications but referenced prior uses of the word "More" and cultural references such as the fictional detective Columbo’s use of the phrase.
  • Swatch challenged the sufficiency of evidence supporting the bad faith claim, emphasizing the requirement that bad faith must be distinctly proved and not based on speculation.
  • They argued that parody or humorous use of a trade mark does not inherently constitute bad faith, invoking principles of freedom of expression under the Human Rights Act.
  • Swatch contended that the Hearing Officer's findings were speculative and lacked a clear evidential basis, particularly regarding the intention to parody.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Red Bull GmbH v Sun Mark Limited [2012] EWHC 1929 (Ch) Bad faith requires distinct proof; presumption of good faith; bad faith includes conduct falling short of acceptable commercial behaviour. The court applied the principles to assess whether Swatch's application was made in bad faith, emphasizing the seriousness of the allegation and the need for cogent evidence.
Chocoladenfabriken Lindt & Sprüngli AG v Franz Hauswirth GmbH [2009] ECR I-4893 (C-529/07) Relevant date for assessing bad faith is the application date; intention at that time is a subjective factor judged objectively. The court considered Swatch's intentions at the application date, including subsequent evidence illuminating that state of mind.
Sky v SkyKick C-371/18, EU:C:2020:45 Defines bad faith as dishonest intention or undermining third parties’ interests contrary to honest practices; emphasizes the context of trade mark law. The court relied on this to analyze the bad faith claim, noting the absence of clear evidence that Swatch intended to undermine Apple dishonestly.
Ian Adam trade mark [2011] RPC 21 Assessment of bad faith must avoid speculation; inferences must be based on proven facts. The court referred to this to caution against speculative conclusions regarding Swatch’s intentions.
Gromax Plasticulture Ltd v Don & Low Nonwovens Ltd [1999] RPC 367 Bad faith includes dealings falling short of standards of acceptable commercial behaviour. Used to frame the standard by which Swatch’s conduct was assessed.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court began by affirming the Hearing Officer’s rejection of the passing off claim under section 5(4)(a), agreeing that the phrase "ONE MORE THING" had not acquired distinctiveness sufficient to function as a trade mark indicative of Apple’s goods or services. The Hearing Officer’s finding that the phrase was a common English expression and not a distinguishing sign was upheld.

Regarding the bad faith opposition under section 3(6), the court undertook a detailed review of the Hearing Officer’s reasoning. It noted that the Hearing Officer had rejected Apple’s primary bad faith argument of a blocking application on procedural grounds, as it was not pleaded, and had instead found bad faith based on an intention to parody Apple.

The court scrutinized the evidential basis for the finding of parodic intent and found it lacking. It emphasized that third-party online comments were speculative and not reliable evidence of Swatch’s intentions. The absence of any direct evidence from Swatch explaining its intentions further undermined the finding. Moreover, the court highlighted that an intention merely to upset or annoy Apple was insufficient to establish bad faith, as annoyance is not an objectively analyzable economic harm.

The court also considered the legal question of whether an intention to parody can constitute bad faith. It recognized that parody is a form of free expression and not inherently dishonest or contrary to acceptable commercial behaviour. The court found the Hearing Officer’s reasoning on this point inconsistent and speculative, particularly given the lack of clarity about the nature of the alleged parody and no concrete examples of how the mark would be used in that manner.

Applying established legal principles from the cited precedents, the court reiterated that bad faith requires a dishonest intention or conduct falling short of acceptable commercial standards, proven on the balance of probabilities with cogent evidence. Mere speculation or alternative explanations consistent with good faith are insufficient.

In conclusion, the court held that the Hearing Officer erred in upholding the bad faith opposition under section 3(6) on the basis of parodic intent, and that no sufficient evidence supported such a finding.

Holding and Implications

The appeal is ALLOWED, and the Hearing Officer’s decision to uphold the opposition under section 3(6) is overturned.

The direct effect of this decision is that Swatch’s trade mark applications for the marks containing "ONE MORE THING" are not refused on the grounds of bad faith. The court did not set any new precedent but clarified the evidential and legal standards applicable to bad faith claims involving alleged parodic intent. The ruling underscores the necessity for clear, cogent evidence when alleging bad faith and the recognition that parody, as a form of expression, does not inherently constitute bad faith in trade mark applications.