Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Sherry v The Minister for Education and Skills & Ors (Approved)

High Court of Ireland
Mar 2, 2021
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The outbreak of the Covid-19 virus led to the cancellation of the 2020 Leaving Certificate examination, affecting over 62,000 students. The traditional exam could not proceed due to public health concerns, prompting the Government to devise an alternative grading system known as "calculated grades." This system aimed to estimate the grades students would have achieved had the exam taken place normally. The Minister for Education and Skills was responsible for implementing this system.

The calculated grades system involved two phases: a school phase where teachers estimated marks and ranked students, and a departmental phase which applied a statistical "standardisation model" to these estimates. The model originally incorporated School Historical Data (SHD) and National Historical Data (NHD) to ensure statistical accuracy and comparability with previous years' results.

However, following political and public controversy, particularly relating to the use of SHD and its parallels with issues encountered in the UK, the Government decided on 1 September 2020 to remove SHD from the standardisation model and to minimize the impact of NHD by not applying a "mapping tool." This resulted in significant "grade inflation" and alleged downgrading of students from their estimated marks.

The applicant, a student at a high-performing school, claimed to have been unfairly downgraded as a result of these decisions and initiated judicial review proceedings challenging the lawfulness of the removal of SHD and the non-application of the mapping tool. Due to the commonality of the issue, this case was selected as a test case among approximately 70 similar proceedings.

The hearing spanned from 8 December 2020 to 2 February 2021, during which extensive evidence and submissions were presented concerning the evolution of the standardisation model, the rationale for the decisions taken, and their impact on the applicant and his school.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the decisions to remove School Historical Data (SHD) and not to apply the "mapping tool" to National Historical Data (NHD) in the standardisation model were arbitrary, unfair, unreasonable, irrational, unlawful, and in breach of the applicant’s legitimate expectations.
  2. Whether these decisions constituted an exercise of executive power and were justiciable by the courts.
  3. The applicability and scope of the doctrine of legitimate expectation in the context of the calculated grades system.
  4. Whether the applicant suffered unfairness as a result of the impugned decisions.
  5. The balance between individual legitimate expectations and the public interest in the administration of the calculated grades system.

Arguments of the Parties

Applicant's Arguments

  • The system for awarding calculated grades lacked a legislative basis and was voluntary, so executive power was not properly engaged.
  • The removal of SHD and non-application of the mapping tool breached explicit commitments made to students, including the applicant.
  • The applicant was unfairly downgraded from his teachers’ estimated marks, which he contended were a fair prediction of his performance.
  • The public controversy that influenced the decisions was based on misunderstandings and did not justify the changes.
  • The applicant relied on the doctrine of legitimate expectation, asserting that he had a reasonable expectation the original system, including SHD and mapping tool, would be used.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The calculated grades system was implemented as an exercise of executive power under Article 28.2 of the Constitution.
  • The decisions to remove SHD and not apply the mapping tool were policy decisions, not subject to judicial review due to the separation of powers.
  • Public acceptance of the grading system was paramount, and the changes were necessary to maintain confidence and fairness in the system.
  • The applicant did not establish any constitutional or statutory rights infringed, nor any "clear disregard" by the respondents of their constitutional duties.
  • Statistical evidence indicated that the removal of SHD did not cause unfairness to the applicant or his school.
  • The doctrine of legitimate expectation is qualified by public interest, which justified the changes in this case.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
State (C) v. Minister for Justice [1967] I.R. 106 Distinction between statutory power and executive power under the Constitution. The Court found this case not directly applicable as it concerned statutory power, unlike the present administrative context.
Gutrani v. Minister for Justice [1993] 2 I.R. 427 Binding nature of informal schemes and the applicability of judicial review. The Court distinguished this case as it involved a binding scheme, unlike the voluntary calculated grades system.
The Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs v. Quark Fishing Ltd [2002] EWCA Civ. 1409 Judicial review of statutory decisions and limits on executive power. Not applicable as the present case involved non-statutory administrative decisions.
Barlow v. Minister for Agriculture [2017] 2 I.R. 440 Definition and scope of executive power in Irish law. The Court held the decisions were an exercise of executive power.
T.D. v. Minister for Education [2001] 4 I.R. 259 Limits of judicial review in policy decisions; distinction between policy and legality. The Court applied this principle to hold that policy decisions on calculated grades were not justiciable.
Moore v. Minister for Arts, Heritage and the Gaeltacht [2018] 3 I.R. 265 Judicial competence and separation of powers in reviewing executive policy decisions. Supported the conclusion that the Court lacks competence to review policy decisions on calculated grades.
Garda Representative Association v. Minister for Public Expenditure and Reform [2016] IECA 18 Judicial review of executive policy decisions and the role of democratic accountability. Reinforced the non-justiciability of policy decisions affecting public administration.
Glencar Exploration Plc v. Mayo County Council (No. 2) [2002] 1 I.R. 84 Elements and conditions of legitimate expectation in administrative law. Used to analyze the applicant’s claim of legitimate expectation and the public interest qualification.
Curran v. Minister for Education [2009] 4 I.R. 300 Change of policy may defeat a claim of legitimate expectation where public interest outweighs. The Court applied this to conclude public interest justified changes to the grading system.
R. v. North and East Devon Health Authority; ex parte Coughlan [2001] Q.B. 213 Legitimate expectation doctrine and its public law foundations. Referenced in relation to the nature of legitimate expectation and public interest balancing.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court recognized that the calculated grades system was an unprecedented administrative response to the cancellation of the 2020 Leaving Certificate due to the pandemic. The Minister was tasked with creating a system that was both statistically accurate and publicly acceptable, a balance that proved difficult.

Initially, the standardisation model incorporated School Historical Data (SHD) and National Historical Data (NHD), including a "mapping tool," to align 2020 results with historical performance. However, public and political controversy, especially following similar issues in the UK, centered on the use of SHD, which was criticized as perpetuating inequality and "school profiling."

Given these concerns, the Minister and Government decided to remove SHD and not to apply the mapping tool to NHD, resulting in grade inflation but preserving public confidence in the system. The Court found that these decisions were exercises of executive power and constituted policy decisions, which are generally not subject to judicial review due to the separation of powers and the courts' lack of competence in policy matters.

Regarding the applicant's claim of legitimate expectation, the Court acknowledged that representations were made that SHD and the mapping tool would be used. However, the applicant failed to demonstrate material unfairness or detriment from the changes, as the applicant's school estimates were significantly inflated, and the removal of SHD had minimal effect on his actual grades.

Expert evidence indicated that while inclusion of SHD might have improved statistical accuracy, it would have perpetuated inequality and was not acceptable to the public. The Court also emphasized that public interest considerations and democratic accountability justified the policy changes.

Ultimately, the Court concluded that the decisions to remove SHD and not apply the mapping tool were lawful, not arbitrary or irrational, and did not breach the applicant's legitimate expectations.

Holding and Implications

The Court dismissed the applicant's challenge and upheld the decisions of the Minister and Government.

The ruling confirms that executive policy decisions made in response to extraordinary circumstances, particularly those balancing statistical accuracy against public acceptance, are not subject to judicial review. The decision underscores the constitutional principle of separation of powers, limiting courts from interfering with political and policy judgments. The applicant’s failure to establish unfairness or breach of legitimate expectation means no remedy was granted. No new precedent altering the scope of judicial review or legitimate expectation doctrine was set. The judgment serves as a reference point for similar challenges concerning administrative adaptations to crises.