- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Copleston & Anor, Re (RESTRICTIVE COVENANT - MODIFICATION - whether restrictions obsolete)
Factual and Procedural Background
The applicants, owners of a semi-detached dwelling known as Gorsebrook in Tunbridge Wells, sought to develop a detached dwelling on adjacent garden land. They obtained planning permission on appeal in 2016, followed by subsequent variations and approvals. However, their development was restricted by a restrictive covenant from 1960 that limited building on the land to certain outbuildings and prohibited business use, confining the land to private garden use.
The applicants applied to the Tribunal under section 84(1)(a) and (aa) of the Law of Property Act 1925 to discharge or modify these restrictions on grounds that the restrictions were obsolete or impeded reasonable use of the land. Three objections were initially lodged, two of which were withdrawn, leaving two objectors representing properties benefiting from the covenant. The Tribunal conducted an accompanied site inspection and heard evidence from the parties and an expert witness.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the restrictive covenant is obsolete due to changes in the character of the property or neighbourhood under section 84(1)(a) of the Law of Property Act 1925.
- Whether the continued existence of the restriction impedes reasonable user of the land and whether it secures practical benefits of substantial value to the persons entitled to the benefit under section 84(1)(aa) and (1A).
- Whether the practical benefits secured by the covenant should be assessed by reference to the benefited land only or by reference to all land in common ownership occupied together with the benefited land.
Arguments of the Parties
Applicants' Arguments
- The character of the neighbourhood has substantially changed since 1960, with increased residential density and modern developments, rendering the restrictions obsolete.
- The restrictions impede a reasonable use of the land, namely the construction of a modest detached dwelling permitted by planning permission.
- The restrictions no longer secure any practical benefit to the objectors, as the changes to the neighbourhood have affected the benefited land more than the proposed development would.
- The practical benefits should be assessed by reference only to the benefited land, not to other land held in common ownership.
Objectors' Arguments
- The neighbourhood should be narrowly defined to include only a cluster of Victorian buildings at the lower end of Chilston Lane, whose character remains distinct and unchanged.
- The restrictions are not obsolete and remain important to preserve the character and amenity of the benefited land and neighbourhood.
- The proposed development is not a reasonable use as it was initially refused planning permission and opposed by local residents.
- The practical benefits secured by the restrictions extend beyond the benefited land to the entire property owned and occupied by the objectors, including the house and garden.
- The proposed development would cause substantial loss of amenity through overlooking, loss of privacy, harm to the character of the conservation area, and create traffic and parking hazards.
- The applicants failed to engage with the objectors and have acted unreasonably.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Truman, Hanbury, Buxton and Co Limited's Application [1956] 1 QB 261 | Definition of obsolescence of restrictive covenants under ground (a): a restriction is obsolete if it cannot achieve its original purpose. | The court applied this principle to determine whether changes in the neighbourhood rendered the covenant obsolete, ultimately finding the restrictions were not obsolete. |
| Gilbert v Spoor [1983] Ch 27 | Interpretation of "practical benefits" secured by a restrictive covenant, particularly in the context of building schemes. | The court distinguished the present case from Gilbert, noting the absence of a building scheme, and limited the practical benefits to those secured to the benefited land and not to other land in common ownership. |
| Dobbin v Redpath [2007] EWCA Civ 570 | Application of section 84(1) in building scheme context and the broad consideration of adverse effects on objectors. | The court referenced this case to emphasize the distinction between building schemes and non-building scheme covenants in assessing practical benefits. |
| Re: Stanborough's Application [2012] UKUT 21 (LC) | Whether practical benefits secured by a covenant extend beyond the benefited land to other land held in common ownership. | The court relied on this decision to support the principle that in absence of a building scheme, practical benefits are limited to the benefited land only. |
| Re: Lamble's Application [2018] UKUT 175 (LC) | Recognition that practical benefits may extend beyond the benefited land to a wider area, depending on facts. | The court acknowledged this broader approach but distinguished it from the present case where the Tribunal preferred a narrower interpretation. |
| Re: Cole's Application [2018] UKUT 368 (LC) | Consideration of whether practical benefits secured by a covenant extend to the objector's house and garden beyond the benefited land. | The court noted the concession that practical benefits may extend beyond benefited land, but the present Tribunal preferred the narrower Stanborough approach. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Tribunal first addressed ground (a) regarding obsolescence. It defined the neighbourhood as all properties accessed via Chilston Lane, rejecting the objectors’ narrower definition. Although acknowledging increased residential density and some modern developments, the Tribunal found the essential residential character remained unchanged. The restrictions continued to protect the amenity of the benefited land, particularly Little Chilston, by preventing closer residential development. Therefore, the restrictions were not obsolete.
Regarding ground (aa), the Tribunal accepted that the proposed use—a single dwelling with extant planning permission—was a reasonable use impeded by the restrictions. The critical issue was whether the restrictions secured practical benefits of substantial value to the objectors.
The Tribunal considered whether to assess practical benefits solely by reference to the benefited land or to the wider property held in common ownership. It reviewed prior decisions, notably Stanborough, Lamble, and Cole, and legal commentary. Despite concessions in Lamble and Cole favoring a broader approach, the Tribunal found Stanborough’s narrower approach more appropriate absent a building scheme.
However, the Tribunal distinguished the present case because the objectors’ property (The Old Bothy) was a single integrated entity, with the benefited land forming a substantial part of it, and had been so occupied since acquisition. The Tribunal concluded it was appropriate to consider practical benefits secured to the whole property, including the house and garden.
On the facts, the Tribunal found that the restrictions secured substantial practical benefits to the objectors by protecting their outlook, privacy, peace, and quiet, which would be adversely affected by the proposed elevated development. The potential loss and degradation of screening vegetation and disruption from construction further reinforced the practical benefits secured by the restrictions.
For the other objector, whose flat lay entirely within the benefited land but was unlikely to be materially affected by the development, the Tribunal found no substantial practical benefits would be lost.
Consequently, the Tribunal was not satisfied that the applicants had established either ground (a) or (aa) to justify discharge or modification of the restrictions.
Holding and Implications
The Tribunal REFUSED the application to discharge or modify the restrictive covenant.
The direct effect is that the applicants remain bound by the restrictive covenant, preventing the proposed development. No new precedent was established beyond the application of existing principles to the facts, particularly regarding the scope of practical benefits under section 84(1A) in the absence of a building scheme.
Alert