- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Secretariat Consulting PTE Ltd & Ors v A Company
Factual and Procedural Background
The respondent, a developer of a large petrochemical plant project, engaged a project manager ("the third party") responsible for engineering, procurement, and construction management services. The respondent entered into two sub-contracts for parts of the project, which led to disputes with the sub-contractor. Arbitration 1 concerned claims by the sub-contractor against the respondent for delay and disruption allegedly caused by late release of construction drawings.
In March 2019, the respondent engaged Secretariat Consulting Pte Ltd ("SCL"), part of the Secretariat group providing litigation support and expert services, to assist in Arbitration 1. A Confidentiality Agreement and conflict checks covering the entire Secretariat group were completed. SCL undertook extensive arbitration support and expert witness services under a contract including an express clause regarding conflicts of interest.
In August 2019, the third party commenced Arbitration 2 against the respondent. In October 2019, Secretariat International UK Ltd ("SIUL"), another Secretariat entity, was approached by the third party to provide expert services in Arbitration 2. SIUL ran a conflict check across the Secretariat group, revealing SCL’s engagement by the respondent. Despite the respondent’s solicitors’ objection to SIUL’s involvement due to conflict concerns, SIUL proceeded to act for the third party without further reference to the respondent.
The respondent sought an interim injunction against SCL, SIUL, and Secretariat Advisors LLC ("SAL"), another group entity, alleging breach of fiduciary duty and breach of confidence. The injunction was granted focusing on fiduciary duty. The respondent also pleaded a contractual duty to avoid conflicts of interest, which became central on appeal.
Legal Issues Presented
- Did SCL owe a fiduciary duty of loyalty to the respondent?
- If not, did SCL owe a contractual duty to the respondent to avoid conflicts of interest?
- If so, was that duty also owed to the respondent by other Secretariat entities?
- If so, was there a conflict of interest due to SCL's engagement in Arbitration 1 and SIUL's engagement in Arbitration 2?
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The appellants contended that an expert’s overriding duty to the court negated any fiduciary duty of loyalty to the client.
- They argued that the conflict of interest clause in SCL’s retainer was not as extensive as claimed and did not bind other Secretariat entities.
- They maintained that the engagement of SIUL in a separate arbitration and in a different discipline (quantum vs delay) did not constitute a conflict of interest.
- They suggested that any undertaking by SCL should not be construed as binding the entire Secretariat group, warning against "piercing the corporate veil".
Appellee's Arguments
- The respondent argued that SCL owed a fiduciary duty of loyalty or, alternatively, a contractual duty to avoid conflicts of interest.
- They contended that the conflict check and confidentiality agreement covered the entire Secretariat group, binding all entities.
- The respondent submitted there was a clear conflict of interest due to overlapping parties, project, subject matter, and opposing roles in related arbitrations.
- They emphasized the commercial and practical reality that the Secretariat group operates as a single global firm, making it unrealistic to treat entities as separate for conflict purposes.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Jones v Kaney [2011] UKSC 13 | Expert witnesses owe a paramount duty to the court which does not conflict with duties to the client; abolition of expert immunity. | Supported the view that an expert’s duty to the court coexists with a duty of loyalty to the client; no inherent conflict. |
| Prince Jefri Bolkiah v KPMG [1999] 2 AC 222 | Protection of confidential information and disqualification based on fiduciary position. | Distinguished as concerning former client conflicts; reinforced fiduciary loyalty principles. |
| Akai Holdings Limited v RSM Robson Rhodes LLP [2007] EWHC 1641 (Ch) | Contractual provisions preventing conflicts of interest and double employment. | Interpreted contractual duty to avoid conflicts as prohibiting accepting instructions from clients with adverse interests. |
| Marks and Spencer Group PLC v Freshfields [2004] EWCA Civ 741 | Conflict of interest can arise even with unrelated transactions due to fiduciary duties. | Supported finding of conflict of interest binding the firm beyond individual partners. |
| Sweeney v The Voluntary Health Insurance Board [2020] IECA 150 | Conflict of interest and fiduciary considerations in expert engagements. | Considered but did not find fiduciary duty; recognized conflict of interest in simultaneous expert retainers. |
| Harmony Shipping v Saudi Europe Line Ltd [1979] 1 WLR 1380 | No property in expert evidence; expert can be subpoenaed by any party. | Noted as authority of limited utility due to peculiar facts and absence of contract. |
| Beumer Group UK Limited v Vinci Construction UK Limited [2016] EWHC 2283 (TCC) | Risk of bias and conflict in simultaneous adjudications. | Illustrated concerns about conflicting roles in related disputes, analogous to present case. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court acknowledged the novelty of the issues but focused on the terms of the relevant retainer and the factual matrix. It recognized that while experts owe a paramount duty to the tribunal, this does not negate a duty of loyalty or a contractual obligation to avoid conflicts of interest. The court found no necessity to establish a freestanding fiduciary duty, preferring to decide on contractual terms.
The conflict check conducted across the entire Secretariat group and the confidentiality agreement supported the conclusion that the contractual duty to avoid conflicts extended beyond SCL to all Secretariat entities, including SIUL and SAL. The court emphasized the commercial reality and marketing of the Secretariat group as a single global firm, with shared management, financial interests, and common branding, making it unrealistic to treat entities as independent for conflict purposes.
The court identified a clear conflict of interest arising from the overlapping parties, subject matter, and roles in the two arbitrations. SCL was advising and providing expert evidence for the respondent in Arbitration 1, while SIUL was advising the third party against the respondent in Arbitration 2. The court rejected attempts to distinguish between different expert roles or separate legal entities as insufficient to avoid the conflict.
The court also rejected the appellants' argument that the conflict was not "strict" or "true," affirming that the conflict was real and significant. It held that the contractual conflict clause was clear and binding throughout the engagement, and the breach of this duty warranted the injunction granted below.
Holding and Implications
The court DISMISSED THE APPEAL, upholding the injunction against the Secretariat entities acting for opposing parties in related arbitrations involving overlapping subject matter.
The holding confirms that litigation support and expert service providers may owe a contractual duty to avoid conflicts of interest extending across related entities within a corporate group, particularly where the group presents itself as a unified global firm. The decision underscores the importance of clear contractual terms and conflict checks in expert engagements, especially in complex multi-party arbitrations.
No new broad fiduciary duty was imposed on experts; rather, the court resolved the dispute on contractual grounds, emphasizing that the duty to avoid conflicts is consistent with the expert’s overriding duty to the tribunal. The ruling does not preclude groups from limiting conflict checks and undertakings to individual entities, but this must be made explicit to clients.
Alert