- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Core & Anor v Revenue & Customs (CAPITAL GAINS TAX - relief on disposal of private residence)
Factual and Procedural Background
This appeal concerned whether the principal private residence (PPR) exemption from capital gains tax applied to the appellants' sale of a jointly-held residential property (referred to as "Green Lane") in June 2014. The appellants did not include the gain on the sale of Green Lane in their 2014-15 tax returns. Subsequently, the tax authority issued closure notices and assessments charging capital gains tax and careless inaccuracy penalties on both appellants in respect of the gain. The appellants appealed these decisions.
The appeals were notified to the Tribunal slightly late, but permission for late appeal was granted as the delay was short, linked to confusion over Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR), and the tax authority did not object. The Tribunal directed that the appeals be heard together and decided the matter without a hearing, based on documentary evidence including witness statements and correspondence.
Factually, the appellants were a married couple with children, living in rented accommodation ("Victoria Road") in the same town as Green Lane. They purchased Green Lane in March 2013 but did not move in immediately due to building works carried out by the first appellant, a builder. They extended their lease of Victoria Road twice during 2013 and 2014. In spring 2014, the appellants moved into Green Lane for about 6-8 weeks before moving back to Victoria Road after accepting an offer to sell Green Lane in late May 2014. The appellants also purchased two other properties subsequently.
There was a dispute with neighbours at Green Lane during refurbishment. The timing and acceptance of the offer to buy Green Lane was contested, as was whether the appellants' occupation of Green Lane qualified as their main residence for PPR exemption purposes.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the appellants' occupation of Green Lane in spring 2014 amounted to residence for the purpose of the principal private residence exemption under sections 222 and 223 of the Taxation of Chargeable Gains Act 1992.
- Whether the appellants had accepted an offer to sell Green Lane prior to moving in, which would negate the intention necessary for the PPR exemption.
- Whether the appellants were entitled to relief from capital gains tax on the sale of Green Lane based on the quality, permanence, and continuity of their residence.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellants' Arguments
- The appellants contended that the PPR exemption applied because their intention was to live in Green Lane as a family home and they indeed did so for 6-8 weeks.
- They argued they never intended to sell Green Lane until they accepted the unsolicited offer from the buyer.
- The appellants maintained that their occupation of Green Lane showed sufficient permanence and continuity to qualify as their main residence.
Respondents' Arguments
- The tax authority disputed that the appellants' occupation of Green Lane was of sufficient quality, permanence, or continuity to qualify as their private residence under s222.
- They argued that if the offer to sell Green Lane was accepted before the appellants moved in, then the question of residence was irrelevant as there was no intention to make Green Lane their residence.
- The respondents highlighted the lack of corroborating documentary evidence supporting the appellants' version of events.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Goodwin v Curtis [1998] STC 475 | Clarification that temporary occupation does not necessarily constitute residence; residence requires some degree of permanence, continuity, or expectation of continuity. | The Tribunal applied the principle that whether occupation amounts to residence is a question of fact and degree, requiring evidence of permanence or continuity. It found the appellants' occupation met this standard despite its brevity. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Tribunal first established the factual timeline, finding that the appellants moved into Green Lane in late March or early April 2014 and lived there for approximately 6-8 weeks. The delay in moving in was due to necessary building works carried out by the first appellant. The appellants maintained their lease at Victoria Road during this time for business purposes.
Regarding the offer to purchase Green Lane, the Tribunal found on the balance of probabilities that the buyer made initial offers in early 2014 which the appellants did not accept. The offer was only accepted in late May 2014 after a higher price was offered. The Tribunal rejected the tax authority's argument that acceptance occurred earlier, concluding that the appellants' statement about lease extension discussions referred to a later extension and was consistent with the timeline of events.
Applying the legal test from Goodwin v Curtis, the Tribunal considered whether the appellants' occupation of Green Lane demonstrated sufficient permanence or continuity to constitute residence. The Tribunal found that moving into Green Lane with their children, despite having a continuing lease elsewhere, indicated an expectation of indefinite residence rather than a temporary stop-gap. The existence of an offer to buy at the time of moving in did not negate this expectation, as the appellants had not accepted any offer and would have remained at Victoria Road if they anticipated a short stay.
Consequently, the Tribunal concluded that Green Lane was the appellants' sole residence for the period they lived there, satisfying the requirements of the PPR exemption under sections 222 and 223 of the Taxation of Chargeable Gains Act 1992. Given that the last 18 months of ownership covered the entire period, the full gain was exempt from capital gains tax.
Holding and Implications
The appeal was ALLOWED. The Tribunal reduced the assessments for capital gains tax on the sale of Green Lane to nil and cancelled the related penalties imposed on the appellants.
The direct effect of this decision is that the appellants are not liable for capital gains tax or penalties in respect of the sale of Green Lane. The decision did not establish new precedent but applied established principles to the facts, emphasizing the importance of the quality and intention behind residence for the PPR exemption.
Alert