Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Shanghai Hongtou Network Technology Co Ltd v Jagex Ltd

England and Wales High Court (Chancery Division)
Jul 21, 2020
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This opinion concerns an application for fortification of a cross-undertaking in damages given on 12th June 2020 when the Plaintiff, a Chinese registered company, was granted an injunction against the first Defendant, an English company ("Jagex"), restraining it from registering any transfer of its shares in favour of the second and third Defendants (collectively "Platinum"). Platinum claims to have acquired the entire share capital of Jagex from the Plaintiff through a Share Purchase Agreement and supplemental agreements, which the Plaintiff disputes. The injunction was granted until trial or further order, with a cross-undertaking in damages given by the Plaintiff and its two parent entities, both Chinese companies, to protect those who might suffer loss due to the injunction, namely Platinum.

Platinum now seeks an order to fortify the cross-undertaking in damages, arguing it faces a real risk of significant losses if prevented from selling its Jagex shares. The entities providing the undertaking have no assets within the jurisdiction, and enforcing any order against them would be difficult or impossible. The application was heard with counsel representing both parties, and no objection was raised regarding the absence of a return date for the injunction.

Jagex is an English company operating a successful online game, with substantial revenues and profits. Platinum asserts completion of the share purchase on 17th April 2020 for a total price of approximately $530 million, of which just over $5 million has been paid, with the balance due later. The Plaintiff challenges the validity of the sale and supplemental agreements, citing changes in control of the Plaintiff and creditor actions in China. The injunction was made against Jagex alone, while Platinum does not contest jurisdiction, and a former director challenges jurisdiction but this is not relevant to the fortification application.

Platinum intends to sell its shareholding in Jagex shortly, having negotiated with an unidentified private equity purchaser who made a non-binding offer valuing the company at approximately $630 million. The injunction prevents completion of this sale. Platinum is concerned that if forced to wait until after trial, the value of Jagex will decline due to changing market conditions, and it will lose the opportunity to realize value at the current favourable time, partially influenced by increased interest in online gaming during the COVID-19 pandemic lockdowns. Alternative losses include a delayed initial public offering (IPO) and the inability to receive dividends, all of which Platinum seeks to recover through fortification of the cross-undertaking.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the court can make an informed and realistic estimate of the likely loss to Platinum from the injunction preventing the sale or IPO of Jagex shares.
  2. Whether Platinum has demonstrated a sufficient risk of loss to justify fortification of the cross-undertaking in damages.
  3. Whether the injunction is causally linked to the alleged losses, such that fortification is appropriate.
  4. The appropriate amount and form of fortification to be ordered.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments (Platinum)

  • Platinum claims a real risk of significant losses if prevented from selling Jagex shares now, including loss of sale value, inability to conduct an IPO, and loss of dividends.
  • Valuation calculations estimate potential losses up to approximately $209 million based on a reduced enterprise value after 18 months delay, adjusted to about $165 million considering the need to pay the balance of the purchase price.
  • The injunction prevents realization of value during a particularly favourable market influenced by COVID-19 lockdowns.
  • Enforcement of any damages award against the entities providing the cross-undertaking would be difficult due to their Chinese registration and lack of assets in the jurisdiction.
  • Fortification should be ordered to protect against these losses, proposed in alternative sums ranging from $5 million to $209 million.

Respondents' Arguments (Plaintiff and Related Entities)

  • Argued that the power of attorney associated with the share purchase prevents Platinum from selling the shares without consent, so the injunction is not the cause of any inability to sell.
  • Submitted that the underlying dispute over share ownership, not the injunction, prevents sale or IPO, thus negating causation for loss.
  • Criticized the valuation assumptions, including the 8% rate of return on available funds, as unsubstantiated and above prevailing interest rates.
  • Pointed to company projections indicating dividends would be retained rather than distributed, undermining claims of dividend-related loss.
  • Contended that retention of profits within Jagex would allow deployment of funds similarly to Platinum's intended use, making the claimed loss unrealistic.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Phoenix Group Foundation v Cochrane [2018] EWHC 2179 (Comm) Three requirements for fortification of cross-undertaking in damages: (1) intelligent and realistic estimate of loss, (2) sufficient risk of loss (good arguable case), (3) causal link between injunction and loss. The court applied these criteria to assess Platinum's claim, finding all three requirements met but requiring careful evaluation of the strength of arguments and amount of loss.
Sinclair Investment Holdings SA v Cushnie [2004] EWHC 218 (Ch) Where precise valuation is difficult, the court may make an appropriate estimate of loss risk based on available evidence, not requiring scientific precision. The court used this principle to justify making a reasoned estimate of potential losses despite uncertainties and commercial complexities.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court began by acknowledging the established principles for fortification of cross-undertakings in damages, emphasizing the need for an informed and realistic estimate of loss, a sufficient risk of loss demonstrated by a good arguable case, and a causal connection between the injunction and the loss.

The court found that enforcement risks were significant, given the Chinese registration and lack of assets of the entities providing the undertaking, and the difficulty of enforcing English judgments in China, particularly against a state-owned entity.

Regarding financial loss, the court scrutinized the detailed valuation calculations prepared by Platinum's representative. While the court accepted there was a real risk of loss due to delay in sale or IPO, it expressed scepticism about specific assumptions, especially the 2% profit reduction attributed to the injunction based on alleged player loss and employee morale effects. The court found these rationales insufficiently supported.

The court also considered the power of attorney argument but concluded that it would not prevent onward sale if the balance of purchase price was paid, which could be arranged as part of the transaction.

The submission that the underlying ownership dispute, not the injunction, prevented sale was rejected as inconsistent with the fact that the injunction was sought precisely to prevent sale, indicating an arguable causal link.

The court accepted that while some valuation assumptions were optimistic, Platinum would lose the opportunity to deploy funds at a reasonable return during the delay, justifying recognition of loss.

Dividend-related loss was regarded as plausible, though not conclusively demonstrated, with the court preferring a cautious approach.

Overall, the court balanced the need to avoid fanciful predictions with recognition of the commercial realities and uncertainties, concluding that a reasonable estimate of loss could be made to justify fortification.

Holding and Implications

The court ordered fortification of the cross-undertaking in damages in the sum of $35 million, representing approximately 7% of the private equity valuation of Jagex, as an appropriate and proportionate amount of protection for Platinum against potential losses arising from the injunction.

The fortification is to be provided by secured cash deposit, bank guarantee, or other suitable mechanism within 28 days, with extensions possible upon proper evidence of difficulty. Failure to provide fortification will result in the injunction lapsing.

This decision directly protects the Defendant (Platinum) by securing compensation for potential losses caused by the injunction but does not establish new precedent beyond applying established principles to the facts. The court emphasized the importance of balancing risks and uncertainties in commercial valuation when ordering fortification.