Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Apollo Ventures Co Ltd v Manchanda & Ors

England and Wales High Court (Commercial Court)
Aug 12, 2020
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The claim arises from allegations involving a company incorporated in Thailand in 2003 ("Company A"), principally owned by two shareholders, Plaintiff and Appellant. The dispute concerns two loans taken out by Company A in 2013, allegedly procured by Defendant without the knowledge or consent of other shareholders or directors, using forged documents. The Plaintiff alleges that the proceeds of these loans were diverted to Defendant, family members, or entities controlled by them, rather than benefiting Company A. The Plaintiff brings claims against Defendant and several other defendants, including allegations of forgery, fraud, conspiracy, breach of fiduciary duties, and claims under Thai law.

Defendants deny liability, asserting that the loans were entered into with the knowledge and consent of Company A's directors and shareholders, and that the loan proceeds were used for the benefit of Company A and its shareholders. Other defendants also deny involvement in any conspiracy or knowing receipt of funds.

A worldwide freezing order ("WFO") was granted in May 2016 by HH Judge Waksman without notice to the Defendants. At a return date in June 2016, the WFO was continued, with no variation in the fortification of the undertaking. Defendants initially sought to appeal but abandoned the application. Applications for security for costs and increased fortification were issued in December 2016. Default judgments entered in December 2016 were later set aside in February 2018. The parties subsequently engaged in procedural steps including amendments to pleadings and agreed extensions for filings. Parallel proceedings in Thailand are ongoing.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the court should order security for costs against the Plaintiff under CPR Part 25 given the Plaintiff's alleged impecuniosity and foreign residence.
  2. Whether the court should increase the amount of fortification of the undertaking in damages given under the existing worldwide freezing order.
  3. Whether the provision of further security or fortification would stifle the Plaintiff's claim.
  4. Whether the application for increased fortification, made several years after the original order, is procedurally appropriate.

Arguments of the Parties

Defendants' Arguments

  • The Plaintiff is a foreign company incorporated in Thailand and is impecunious, making it unlikely that any costs order in Defendants' favour would be recoverable.
  • It would be just to order security for costs based on the Plaintiff's financial position and residence outside the jurisdiction.
  • The Plaintiff's only significant asset, an office building in Bangkok, is fully leveraged and effectively worthless.
  • The Plaintiff’s backers, including shareholders, have limited financial resources and cannot provide funding.
  • The existing ATE insurance policy does not adequately cover the costs sought as security due to exclusions and issues of privity and cancellation rights.
  • The amount of fortification initially ordered was arbitrary and should be increased in light of the financial losses suffered by the Seventh Defendant due to the WFO.

Plaintiff's Arguments

  • Ordering security for costs or increased fortification would stifle the Plaintiff’s claim.
  • The claim is at least arguable and therefore it would be unjust to make such orders.
  • The Plaintiff disputes the valuation evidence regarding its assets and challenges Defendants' evidence.
  • The application for increased fortification should have been made at the return date and is now out of time.
  • The Plaintiff relies on the existence of an ATE insurance policy covering opponents’ costs up to £400,000 to reduce the security amount.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Danilina v Chernhukin [2018] EWHC 2503 (Comm) Burden on claimant to prove that security for costs would stifle the claim; evidence must be full, frank, clear and unequivocal. Applied to assess whether Plaintiff’s claim would be stifled by ordering security; court found insufficient disclosure to conclude stifling on balance of probabilities.
Al-Koronky v Time Life Entertainment Group [2005] EWHC 1688 (QB) Standard for evidence required to show stifling of claim by security for costs. Referenced in Danilina as authority on evidential standard.
Accident Exchange and another v Mclean and others [2018] EWHC 1533 (Comm) Recent authorities confirming evidential burden on claimant regarding stifling argument. Noted as part of the general approach to stifling arguments.
Goldtrail Travel Ltd v Onar Air Tasimacilik AS [2017] UKSC 57 Availability of funding from third parties can negate stifling argument; court should look beyond claimant’s own assets. Applied to consider whether Plaintiff could raise funds from backers or associates; court found evidence unsatisfactory.
The Mito [1987] 2 Lloyd's Rep. 197 Timing and procedural propriety of applications for security or fortification after injunction granted or discharged. Considered but distinguished; court held application for increased fortification was late and not appropriate at this stage.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court began by summarising the legal framework governing security for costs under CPR Part 25, focusing on whether it was just to order security and whether the claimant met the conditions, particularly being a foreign company likely unable to pay costs.

Regarding the Defendants' application for security for costs, the court noted the Plaintiff’s limited financial disclosure: no audited or management accounts, no bank documents, and only limited evidence of income from rental of an office building allegedly fully leveraged. The Plaintiff’s shareholders’ financial positions were also inadequately evidenced, with assertions of limited assets and borrowing capacity.

The court rejected the Plaintiff’s procedural challenge to the Defendants’ evidence and declined to admit further late evidence from the Plaintiff, noting the hearing had been scheduled for some time and the Plaintiff had not sought adjournment.

Applying the principles from Danilina and Goldtrail, the court found that the Plaintiff had not provided full and frank disclosure to satisfy the burden of proving that ordering security would stifle its claim. The court was left with a real possibility that the Plaintiff could not meet a costs order but could not reliably conclude that security would stifle the claim.

The court also considered the Plaintiff’s domicile in Thailand and the difficulty of enforcement but found that since the stifling objection failed, this ground did not preclude ordering security.

On the quantum of security, the court accepted that the existence of an ATE insurance policy might be relevant but found that the policy excluded costs incurred before its start date, had privity issues, and contained cancellation and avoidance rights that limited its effectiveness as security. Without an agreement to overcome these issues, the full amount sought (£500,000) was to be secured.

Regarding the application to increase fortification of the undertaking under the WFO, the court examined the losses claimed by the Seventh Defendant due to the WFO’s effect on financing property transactions. The court considered the Plaintiff’s arguments that the application was late and would stifle the claim.

The court distinguished the precedent in The Mito, noting the injunction had not been discharged and that the Defendants sought to give the Plaintiff an election to continue the freezing order or not. However, the court concluded that the application was late, having been issued in December 2016 but not pursued for several years, and that ordering increased fortification at this stage would not be just.

Finally, the court noted that while it was not satisfied that the initial security for costs order would stifle the claim, requiring a further substantial amount of security and fortification after such delay might well have that effect. The court exercised discretion against ordering increased fortification.

Holding and Implications

The court ORDERED that security for costs in the amount of £500,000 be provided by the Plaintiff to the Defendants.

The court REFUSED the application to increase the fortification of the undertaking under the worldwide freezing order.

This decision means the Plaintiff must provide substantial security for costs to continue the claim, reflecting concerns about its financial position and the risk of non-payment of costs. However, the court declined to increase the fortification after a significant delay, balancing the risk of stifling the claim against the Defendants’ interests. No new precedent was established; the ruling applies established principles on security for costs, stifling arguments, and procedural propriety regarding fortification applications.