- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Sky Ltd & Ors v Skykick UK Ltd & Anor
Factual and Procedural Background
The court had previously delivered a series of judgments in a dispute involving two parties identified as Plaintiff and Defendant concerning trade mark infringement and related issues. The initial judgment was handed down on 6 February 2018 ("the Main Judgment"), where five questions were referred to the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) to resolve certain issues. A second judgment followed on 27 April 2018 ("the Second Judgment"), which included the order for the reference to the CJEU. The CJEU delivered its ruling on 29 January 2020, and a third judgment applying the CJEU's rulings was issued on 29 April 2020 ("the Third Judgment"). The Plaintiff subsequently withdrew part of its infringement claim except for claims based on certain Selected Goods and Services. The current judgment addresses outstanding issues arising from these prior decisions, including infringement relating to a service called Cloud Backup, the appropriate orders, injunctions, costs, and appeals.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Defendant infringed the Plaintiff's trade marks in relation to the Defendant's backup service, Cloud Backup.
- Whether declaratory relief sought by the Defendant is appropriate given the complexity of the case and partial success on the counterclaim.
- Whether an injunction should be granted to restrain the Defendant from further infringing the Plaintiff's trade marks, considering the Plaintiff's partial bad faith and proportionality.
- The applicability and interpretation of relevant European Union law, including the Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS) Agreement, the EU Trade Mark Regulation, the Enforcement Directive, and the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union, in relation to injunctions and trade mark infringement.
- The appropriate allocation of costs between the parties based on their respective successes and failures in the proceedings.
- Whether permission to appeal should be granted on various findings including infringement and partial bad faith.
- Whether a stay of the injunction pending appeal should be granted and under what conditions.
- The scope of confidentiality protection applicable to documents and evidence in the proceedings.
Arguments of the Parties
Defendant's Arguments
- The Defendant contended that the Plaintiff's partial bad faith in applying for the trade marks should result in refusal of an injunction to sanction such conduct and deter third parties from similar behaviour.
- The Defendant argued that an injunction would be disproportionate given the significant business disruption and costs involved in ceasing use of the contested signs, including the necessity of a costly rebrand across all markets.
- The Defendant offered undertakings to minimize confusion and proposed payment of a running royalty as an alternative to an injunction.
- The Defendant sought a publicity order concerning partial invalidity declarations and permission to appeal various findings.
- The Defendant sought a stay of the injunction pending appeal and an implementation period to comply with any injunction.
Plaintiff's Arguments
- The Plaintiff maintained that the Defendant infringed the trade marks not only in relation to email migration services but also backup services, and that this infringement justified an injunction.
- The Plaintiff opposed the Defendant's request for declaratory relief beyond what was necessary to reflect partial success on the counterclaim.
- The Plaintiff argued that partial invalidity of the trade marks does not constitute a "special reason" to refuse an injunction under the relevant Regulation and case law.
- The Plaintiff submitted that the Defendant's difficulties were largely self-inflicted due to failure to conduct proper trade mark searches and ignoring warnings, and that the offered undertakings were vague and insufficient to prevent confusion.
- The Plaintiff opposed the publicity order requested by the Defendant and opposed a stay of the injunction pending appeal except on terms including a cross-undertaking in damages.
- The Plaintiff contended that the Defendant's appeal grounds lacked real prospects of success except in relation to partial bad faith.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Case C-316/05 Nokia Corp v Wardell [2006] ECR I-12083 | Interpretation of "special reasons" exception to mandatory injunction under Article 130(1) of the EU Trade Mark Regulation. | The court applied the strict interpretation that injunctions must be granted unless exceptional factual circumstances exist, rejecting partial invalidity as a special reason. |
| Case C-280/15 Nikolajeva v Multi Protect O [EU:C:2016:467] | Clarification that injunction can be refused only in exceptional situations where further infringement is impossible. | Supported the court's view that "special reasons" are limited and must relate to factual impossibility of further infringement. |
| Case C-324/09 L'Oréal SA v eBay International AG [2011] ECR I-6011 | Requirements that injunctions be effective, proportionate, dissuasive, and not create barriers to legitimate trade; balance fundamental rights. | The court used these principles to assess proportionality and fairness in granting an injunction. |
| Lawrence v Fen Tigers Ltd [2014] UKSC 13 | Judicial discretion in awarding damages in lieu of injunctions; discretion should be flexible and fact-sensitive. | Informed the court's consideration of whether damages could substitute for an injunction. |
| Specsavers International Healthcare Ltd v Asda Stores Ltd (No 2) [2012] EWCA Civ 494 | Framework for costs allocation based on who won, lost on circumscribed issues, and exceptionality. | Guided the court's nuanced costs assessment between the parties. |
| F&C Alternative Investments (Holdings) Ltd v Barthelemy [2012] EWCA Civ 843 | No requirement of exceptionality for ordering successful party to pay costs on particular issues. | Supported the court's approach to costs orders without requiring exceptionality. |
| Novartis AG v Hospira UK Ltd [2013] EWCA Civ 583 | Principles for granting stays pending appeal to minimize irremediable prejudice. | Applied in assessing whether to grant a stay of the injunction pending appeal. |
| Samsung Electronics (UK) Ltd v Apple Inc [2012] EWCA Civ 1339 | Jurisdiction for publicity orders concerning declarations of invalidity. | Considered but declined to order publicity given complexity and fairness concerns. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court began by clarifying that the Defendant's use of the contested signs in relation to the backup service ("Cloud Backup") constitutes infringement of the Plaintiff's trade marks, applying prior reasoning on the identity or close similarity of services and the likelihood of confusion. The court rejected the Defendant's request for declaratory relief beyond what was necessary to reflect partial success on the counterclaim, finding it inappropriate given the complexity of the case.
In considering the injunction, the court analyzed the interplay between EU law, including the Trade Mark Regulation, Enforcement Directive, Charter of Fundamental Rights, and relevant CJEU case law. It emphasized that injunctions are generally mandatory unless "special reasons" exist, which must be exceptional and relate to specific factual circumstances. The court rejected the Defendant's argument that the Plaintiff's partial bad faith justified refusal of an injunction, reasoning that partial invalidity of trade marks does not constitute such a special reason under EU law and that the English equitable principle invoked was inapplicable here.
The court further reasoned on proportionality, acknowledging that injunctions normally prevent use of the infringing sign but do not prevent the underlying business. While the Defendant claimed severe business disruption and costs, the court found these consequences largely self-inflicted due to the Defendant's failure to conduct proper trade mark searches, ignoring warnings, and continuing use after judgments. The court was skeptical about the extent of disruption and costs claimed and noted that the Defendant could cease offering services in the EU as an alternative to rebranding.
The court found the Defendant's undertakings to minimize confusion vague and insufficient and was unconvinced that payment of royalties would render an injunction disproportionate. Consequently, the court decided to grant an injunction in a standard form with specific provisions relating to the UK post-Brexit.
Regarding publicity orders, the court declined to make one, citing the complexity of the case and fairness concerns about one-sided publicity. On costs, the court applied established principles considering who won overall and on specific issues, recognizing the Plaintiff as the overall winner but noting the narrower scope of the Plaintiff's successful claims and partial success of the Defendant on counterclaims. Given the complexity and costs disparity, the court ordered each side to bear its own costs.
On permission to appeal, the court granted the Defendant permission to appeal infringement findings related to Cloud Migration and Cloud Backup and granted the Plaintiff permission to appeal the finding of partial bad faith. Other appeals were refused.
On stays pending appeal, the court acknowledged the absence of prior application by the Defendant but granted a stay for three months and contemplated a stay pending appeal conditional on the Defendant paying 2% of gross EU revenues into a joint account to mitigate risk to the Plaintiff.
Finally, the court addressed confidentiality, directing parties to narrow confidentiality claims to truly confidential information before considering permanent orders.
Holding and Implications
The court's final decision was to GRANT AN INJUNCTION restraining the Defendant from infringing the Plaintiff's trade marks, including use of the contested signs in relation to Cloud Backup services, with standard terms and additional provisions applicable post-Brexit.
The court refused to grant declaratory relief beyond what was necessary, declined the Defendant's request for a publicity order, and ordered that each party bear its own costs.
Permission to appeal was granted selectively, allowing appeals on infringement findings concerning Cloud Migration and Cloud Backup by the Defendant and on partial bad faith by the Plaintiff, while other appeals were refused.
A stay of the injunction was granted for three months with a possible stay pending appeal subject to financial safeguards to protect the Plaintiff.
No new precedent was established; rather, the decision applied and clarified the interplay of established principles of EU trade mark law, injunctions, proportionality, and costs allocation within the context of a complex dispute involving partial bad faith and partial invalidity.
Alert