Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Kirkegaard v Smith

England and Wales High Court (Queen's Bench Division)
Dec 11, 2019
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This case involves a defamation claim brought by the Plaintiff, a data scientist and blogger known for controversial writings, against the Defendant, an individual with whom the Plaintiff has had online disagreements. The dispute arose from four specific publications made by the Defendant: three posts in a comment thread on a blog hosted on a website described as an alternative to mainstream media, and one tweet from the Defendant's Twitter account. The Plaintiff claims these publications impute that he is a paedophile and a child abuser. The Defendant applied under CPR r 3.1(2)(i) for preliminary rulings on the meanings of the words complained of and whether those meanings are defamatory. The issues of meaning and whether the words are fact or opinion were consented to be tried as preliminary issues. The trial was heard on 26 November 2019 before the presiding judge, with both parties represented by counsel.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the words pleaded in the Particulars of Claim bear the meanings pleaded by the Plaintiff.
  2. If so, whether those meanings are defamatory of the Plaintiff.
  3. Whether the words complained of constitute statements of fact or expressions of opinion.
  4. Whether contextual material, including hyperlinked content accompanying the posts, should be taken into account in determining meaning and the fact/opinion distinction.

Arguments of the Parties

Defendant's Arguments

  • The words complained of in the four posts are expressions of opinion, not statements of fact.
  • Post Four asserts that the Plaintiff holds controversial opinions supporting paedophilia based on his own writings and is vindictive in conduct towards the Defendant.
  • Posts One, Two, and Three express the opinion that the Plaintiff is an apologist for paedophilia, supported by his published writings and publicly taken positions, including his views on child rape, animated child pornography, and legal distinctions about paedophilia.
  • The posts were published on a niche blogging platform with a dedicated readership likely to have engaged with the full comment thread and hyperlinked materials, thus understanding the posts within a detailed context and debate.
  • The Defendant invited the court to apply an impressionistic approach to the tweet (Post Four), consistent with established authority on social media posts.

Plaintiff's Arguments

  • The reasonable reader would not have read the hyperlinked articles or the full comment thread before forming a judgment about the posts.
  • The Defendant cannot rely on other defamatory posts to provide context to his publications.
  • The words plainly accuse the Plaintiff of being a paedophile, a stark allegation of fact.
  • The Defendant's characterization of the posts as expressions of opinion is an unwarranted gloss and conceptually difficult.
  • The Defendant failed to set out a basis for his opinion, rendering the statements unrecognizable as comment and instead assertions of fact.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Koutsogiannis v The Random House Group Ltd [2019] EWHC 48 (QB) Guidance on determining the natural and ordinary meaning of words and distinguishing fact from opinion. The court applied the principles to assess the meaning of the words and whether they were statements of fact or opinion.
Brown v Bower Explanation of the "Chase levels" of defamatory meaning and the repetition rule. Used to interpret the levels of defamatory meaning and how repeated allegations by the defendant should be treated.
Greenstein v Campaign Against Antisemitism [2019] EWHC 281 (QB) Importance of context in determining meaning, including the role of hyperlinked material. The court accepted hyperlinked material as part of the context in this case.
Stocker v Stocker [2019] 2 WLR 1033 Emphasis on the court's duty to consider how a reasonable social media user would construe words in context. The court applied this to assess the meaning of the tweet and social media posts in this case.
Yeo v Times Newspapers Ltd [2015] 1 WLR 971 Contextual material via hyperlinks can be considered with evidence. The court admitted evidence relating to hyperlinks to understand the context fully.
Tinkler v Ferguson [2018] EWHC 3563 (QB) Discussion on the concept of inferred opinion and the difficulty in separating opinion from fact. Referenced in analyzing whether the Defendant's statements were opinions or bare assertions of fact.
Burgon v News Group Newspapers [2019] EWHC 195 (QB) Distinction between fact and opinion, requiring opinion to be recognisable and based on stated facts. The court applied this to determine that the meanings found were expressions of opinion.
Zarb-Cousin v Association of British Bookmakers [2018] EWHC 2240 (QB) Caution against rigid rules in fact/opinion assessment; context is critical. Used to support the court's contextual approach in distinguishing fact from opinion.
Monroe v Hopkins [2017] EWHC 433 (QB) Impressionistic approach to interpretation of tweets and social media posts. The court adopted this approach in assessing the tweet (Post Four).
Butt v Secretary of State of the Home Department [2017] EWHC 2619 (QB) Consideration that criticism of a corpus of published work may be regarded as comment. Referenced in relation to the Plaintiff's published writings forming the basis of the Defendant's opinions.
Keays v Guardian Newspapers Ltd [2003] EWHC 1565 (QB) Similar to Butt, on comment relating to published work. Referenced to support the court's view on context and opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court began by setting out well-established legal principles on determining the natural and ordinary meaning of words, emphasizing the importance of reasonableness, avoiding over-literal or overly technical analysis, and considering the publication as a whole including any hyperlinked material. The court noted that the hypothetical reasonable reader is neither naive nor excessively suspicious and that context, including the mode of publication such as social media, is critical.

The court accepted that the hyperlinked material accompanying Posts 1, 2, and 3 formed part of the context, rejecting the Plaintiff's argument that reasonable readers would not have engaged with it. The nature of the website and the comment thread indicated an engaged audience likely to consider the full debate and linked sources.

Applying the principles, the court found that each of the four posts constituted expressions of opinion rather than statements of fact. The court reasoned that:

  • Post Four (tweet) was an impressionistic expression of opinion about the Plaintiff’s writings and anticipated conduct, including severe criticism consistent with Twitter's informal and abusive style.
  • Post Two was a response in an ongoing debate, expressing opinion that the Plaintiff is an apologist for paedophilia, supported by references to a range of publications and hyperlinked material.
  • Post Three was part of a dispute with another user, containing inferred opinions supported by citations of the Plaintiff’s writings and external commentary.
  • Post One clarified earlier remarks in an ongoing argument, expressing opinion that the Plaintiff is an apologist for paedophilia, supported by references to mainstream media portrayals.

The court emphasized that the Defendant’s posts contained explanations and reasoning supporting the opinions expressed, distinguishing them from bare assertions of fact. It also acknowledged the complex and controversial subject matter, which tends to support the conclusion that the posts were opinion-based commentary on the Plaintiff’s published work.

Holding and Implications

The court held that the meanings of the words complained of are expressions of opinion rather than statements of fact. These opinions are defamatory of the Plaintiff at common law.

The court's ruling is therefore that the meanings pleaded by the Defendant are accepted, and the meanings are defamatory opinions.

The decision directly affects the parties by clarifying the nature of the Defendant's statements as opinion-based defamation, which may influence subsequent stages of the litigation such as defences and assessment of serious harm. The opinion does not establish new precedent but applies established legal principles to the context of online publications and social media.