Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

FF v CB

High Court of Ireland
Jul 14, 2015
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This case concerns an application for the return of a child, referred to as LF, to the jurisdiction of the United States pursuant to Article 12 of the Hague Convention on the Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction 1980 (the “Convention”). The Applicant alleges that the child was wrongfully removed to Ireland in breach of his custody rights and the orders of the courts of the State of New York, County of Nassau. The Respondent accepts that the child was habitually resident in the United States at the time of the alleged wrongful removal and that the Applicant had rights of supervised access, but disputes that the Applicant was exercising custody rights at the time of removal around 10th October 2011.

The Respondent raises defences including alleged acquiescence and consent by the Applicant, claims of grave risk or intolerable situation if the child were returned, the child’s objection to return, and that the child is well settled in Ireland.

The matter was heard over two days before the High Court on affidavit evidence only. The Applicant initially sought interim access to the child during a visit to Ireland but later withdrew the motion and did not attend the hearing. Both parties filed extensive affidavits. The child was born in New York in 2008 and will be sixteen years old in 2024. The parties are the parents of the child and were divorced, with custody and access orders made by the Family Court of New York.

Custody was granted to the Respondent with supervised access to the Applicant. Subsequent orders modified access arrangements, including supervised and unsupervised visits contingent on compliance with treatment programs. The Respondent alleges that the Applicant’s access was intermittent and ceased following his incarceration. The parties’ divorce was finalized in 2012, with the custody and access orders continuing. In 2013, sole custody was granted to the Applicant by the New York Family Court.

The Respondent claims the Applicant acquiesced or consented to the child’s relocation to Ireland and that the child is well settled there, attending school with special needs support and having established family and community ties. The Applicant denies unequivocal consent to relocation and disputes the extent of his acquiescence.

The Court appointed a clinical psychologist to interview the child and report on his maturity, views on return, and any objections to returning to New York.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the removal of the child from the United States to Ireland was wrongful within the meaning of Article 3 of the Hague Convention.
  2. Whether the Applicant was exercising custody rights at the time of removal.
  3. Whether the Respondent can establish defences under Article 13 of the Convention, including consent, acquiescence, grave risk, or the child’s objection to return.
  4. Whether the child is well settled in the new environment under Article 12 of the Convention.
  5. Whether the child’s views should be taken into account in deciding the application for return.

Arguments of the Parties

Applicant's Arguments

  • The child was wrongfully removed in breach of his custody rights and New York court orders.
  • The Applicant had rights of supervised access and was exercising custody rights at the time of removal.
  • The Applicant did not acquiesce or consent unequivocally to removal of the child to Ireland.
  • The Applicant made efforts to locate the Respondent and child following removal.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The Applicant acquiesced or consented to the child’s removal to Ireland.
  • Return of the child would expose the child to grave risk or place him in an intolerable situation.
  • The child objects to return to the United States.
  • The child is well settled in Ireland with established educational, familial, and community ties.
  • The Applicant was not exercising custody rights at the time of removal.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
W v. W [1993] 2 FLR Custody rights exercised must be construed broadly to include maintaining the stance of a custodial parent, not just day-to-day care. The Court accepted this broad interpretation to find that the Applicant was exercising custody rights at the time of removal.
Friedrich v. Friedrich (1996) 78 F.3d 1060 “Exercise” of custody rights includes any regular contact by a parent with de jure custody rights; non-exercise arises only from unequivocal abandonment or neglect. The Court applied this liberal construction to find the Applicant was exercising custody rights on the balance of probabilities.
Coventry City Council v. (M) S (Unreported, High Court, McMenamin J., 2010) Court rights of custody vest once seised of the application; the court exercises custody rights pending determination of welfare issues. The Court held that the New York Family Court had custody rights as it was seised of custody proceedings and orders at the time of removal.
G.T. v. K.A.O [2007] 3 I.R. 567 Rights of custody vest in courts once proceedings are initiated and served, continuing until determination. Supported the principle that the court itself holds custody rights during ongoing proceedings, relevant to wrongful removal.
R (S) v R (MM) (Unreported Supreme Court, Denham J, 2006) Principles on consent defence under Article 13(a): burden of proof, standard of proof, nature of consent (real, positive, unequivocal), and inference from conduct. The Court adopted these principles to assess whether the Applicant consented or acquiesced to removal; found no unequivocal consent.
Re S (a child) [2012] UKSC 10 Assessment of grave risk under Article 13(b) including the sufficiency of protective measures and the subjective nature of anxieties. The Court referenced this case in evaluating the grave risk defence and concluded protective measures would not suffice to alleviate risk.
N(M). v. N(R) (Unreported, High Court, 2008) Child’s views should be heard when mature enough; weight to those views is a separate issue. The Court relied on this to justify the child interview and to accord significant weight to the child’s expressed objections.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by considering whether the removal of the child was wrongful under Article 3 of the Hague Convention. It accepted the broad interpretation of “exercise” of custody rights, as established in W v. W and Friedrich v. Friedrich, concluding that the Applicant was exercising custody rights at the time of removal on the balance of probabilities.

The Court further found that the Family Court of New York was seised of custody proceedings and therefore held and exercised custody rights over the child at the time, reinforcing the wrongful removal finding.

The Court then examined the Respondent’s defences under Article 13(a) regarding consent and acquiescence. Applying the principles from R (S) v R (MM), the Court found that although the Applicant consented to some travel to Ireland, there was no unequivocal consent to relocation with the child. The Applicant’s inconsistent conduct, including refusal to sign relinquishment documents, supported this conclusion. The Court found no acquiescence either, noting mixed signals but ultimately that the Applicant did not consent or acquiesce to the removal.

Regarding the child’s objection under Article 13, the Court ordered a psychological assessment and interview. The report by the clinical psychologist revealed the child’s strong objection to returning to the United States, citing emotional trauma, fear of the Applicant, and a desire to remain with the Respondent in Ireland. The child was found to be mature enough to form his own views, which were consistent and independently formed.

The Court also considered whether the child was “well settled” in Ireland under Article 12, finding ample evidence that the child had established significant ties, including schooling with special needs support, family connections, and community involvement.

On the defence of grave risk under Article 13(b), the Court placed great weight on the psychologist’s report, which highlighted the child’s complex needs and the risk of psychological harm or intolerable situation if returned. The Court noted that usual protective measures would not sufficiently mitigate this grave risk given the child’s particular circumstances.

Accordingly, the Court concluded that the child’s return would expose him to grave risk and place him in an intolerable situation, and that the child’s settled status and objection to return weighed heavily against ordering return.

Holding and Implications

The Court’s final decision was to REFUSE THE ORDER for the return of the child to the United States pursuant to Article 12 of the Hague Convention.

This refusal was based on the findings that the removal was wrongful but that the Respondent successfully established the defences of grave risk and the child’s objection to return, alongside the child being well settled in Ireland. The decision means that the child will remain in Ireland and that the Applicant’s request for return under the Convention is denied.

No new legal precedent was established by this decision; rather, the Court applied existing principles and jurisprudence to the facts of the case, emphasizing the paramount importance of the child’s welfare and voice in Hague Convention proceedings.