- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Credit Suisse Securities (Europe) Ltd & Ors v HM Revenue and Customs
Factual and Procedural Background
The claimants, collectively referred to as Credit Suisse, are four members of a financial services group headquartered outside the UK. The claim concerns their payment of a tax known as the bank payroll tax ("BPT"), enacted by Schedule 1 to the Finance Act 2010 ("FA 2010") following the financial crisis. BPT applied to discretionary payments exceeding £25,000 awarded by "taxable companies" during the period from 9 December 2009 to 5 April 2010 (the "chargeable period"). The tax was imposed on banks rather than employees, at a 50% rate, effectively targeting bankers' bonuses.
Credit Suisse paid approximately £239 million in BPT on 31 August 2010. They allege that the imposition of BPT was unlawful as it contravened the State aid rules under Articles 107 and 108 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union ("TFEU"). They seek damages under the Francovich principle to compensate for their loss.
Their case centers on the argument that the limited chargeable period meant that only banks awarding bonuses during that time ("Taxed Banks") were subject to the tax, while banks with different accounting year ends ("Untaxed Banks") largely escaped liability, thereby conferring a selective advantage on the latter. HMRC contends there was no State aid or sufficiently serious breach, and that any claim for damages is precluded by statutory provisions requiring claims to be made to the First-tier Tribunal within a four-year time limit, which has expired.
The parties agreed to a split trial, with this trial addressing liability only. The issues for determination include whether BPT constituted State aid, whether that gives rise to a claim for repayment of tax, whether any breach was sufficiently serious to warrant damages, and whether the claim is precluded by statutory provisions.
HMRC presented two witnesses holding senior roles in the Treasury personal tax team, whose evidence was accepted. Credit Suisse did not provide witness evidence, relying largely on disclosed documentary evidence, including HMRC materials and correspondence with other banks.
BPT was announced on 9 December 2009 as a one-off levy of 50% on discretionary bonuses above £25,000, payable by banks. The tax aimed to encourage banks to adopt more prudent remuneration practices and build capital, with revenue raising as a secondary objective. The tax was designed as a short-term measure targeting the main bonus season before longer-term regulatory reforms took effect. The chargeable period was deliberately limited, with policy reasons explaining the start and end dates.
Legal Issues Presented
- Did HMRC's imposition of BPT on the claimants constitute a State aid measure within the meaning of Article 107(1) TFEU, specifically:
- Did the measure confer an economic advantage to the Untaxed Banks?
- Was the economic advantage granted by the State or through State resources?
- Was the measure selective?
- Was the measure liable to distort competition and affect trade between EU Member States?
- If the measure is considered State aid, does that give rise to a claim for repayment of tax as opposed to recovery from aid beneficiaries?
- Assuming a breach of State aid rules, was that breach sufficiently serious to render HMRC liable for damages under the Francovich principle?
- Is the claim (or any part thereof) precluded by statutory provisions relating to remedies and time limits?
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments (Credit Suisse)
- The limited chargeable period was unjustifiably discriminatory, effectively exempting banks with non-calendar year ends from BPT liability and conferring a selective advantage on them.
- State aid was considered during legislation development but the selectivity issue relating to the chargeable period was overlooked.
- Other banks avoided substantial liability due to their accounting periods, giving them a competitive advantage.
- The tax was unlawful and damages should be awarded under the Boiron principle, including for direct tax paid and consequential losses such as changes in remuneration structure and employee departures.
- The equivalent French tax did not suffer from this issue as it applied for a full year.
Respondent's Arguments (HMRC)
- There was no selective advantage because the measure reflected the nature and objectives of the tax system in place.
- The "normal" tax system includes the limited chargeable period; using a hypothetical indefinite tax period as a reference is impermissible.
- Banks could choose not to award bonuses during the chargeable period and thus were not in comparable situations.
- Credit Suisse failed to provide evidence that an economic advantage was conferred or that competition and trade were affected.
- Even if State aid existed, repayment of tax claims are generally not allowed except in limited circumstances which do not apply here.
- Any claim for damages is precluded by statutory provisions and time limits.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Francovich and Bonifaci v Italy (Joined Cases C-6/90 and C-9/90) [1991] ECR I-5357 | Establishes principle allowing damages claims for breaches of EU law by Member States where certain conditions are met. | Applied to assess whether HMRC's breach of State aid rules was sufficiently serious to warrant damages. |
| Commission v World Duty Free Group (C-20 P & C-21/15 P) [2017] 2 CMLR 22 | Defines selectivity in State aid law, focusing on whether a measure confers a selective advantage. | Used to analyze whether BPT's limited period conferred a selective advantage contrary to the ordinary tax system. |
| Commission and Spain v Government of Gibraltar and United Kingdom (C-106/09 P & C-107/09 P) [2012] 1 CMLR 44 | Clarifies that State aid assessment depends on effects of the measure, not regulatory technique, and importance of reference system. | Guided the court in evaluating whether BPT's structure and effects created selectivity. |
| Poland v Commission (T-836/16 and T-624/17) ECLI:EU:T:2019:338 | Emphasizes identifying the "normal" tax regime and assessing selectivity in light of the regime's objectives. | Supported the court's rejection of a hypothetical reference system inconsistent with actual tax structure. |
| GIL Insurance Ltd v Commissioners of Customs and Excise (C-308/01) [2004] 2 CMLR 483 | Considers justification of differential tax rates by the nature and general scheme of the tax system. | Applied to assess whether differences in BPT treatment were justified by its nature and objectives. |
| Cloburn Quarry Co Ltd v HMRC [2013] CSOH 203; [2014] STC 1073 | Discusses the Boiron exception regarding asymmetric taxation and when a tax charge itself constitutes unlawful State aid. | Used to analyze whether BPT’s asymmetric application constituted unlawful State aid and if repayment claims were appropriate. |
| H. J. Banks & Co. Limited v The Coal Authority and Secretary of State for Trade and Industry (C-390/98) [2001] 3 CMLR 51 | Establishes that taxpayers cannot withhold tax on basis that exemptions to others constitute State aid. | Applied to reject claim for repayment of tax paid where only others were exempted. |
| R. (on the application of Negassi) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2013] EWCA Civ 151; [2013] 2 CMLR 45 | Sets out multi-factorial test for "sufficiently serious" breach under Francovich principle. | Guided court’s assessment of whether breach of State aid rules by HMRC was sufficiently serious to warrant damages. |
| Transalpine Leitung in Österreich GmbH v Finanzlandesdirektion für Tirol (Case C-368/04) [2007] CMLR 19 | Emphasizes national courts' duty to ensure aid is not extended and their role in compensation claims. | Mentioned in context of possible claims for damages related to unlawful State aid. |
| Centre d'Exportation du Livre Francais (CELF) v Societe Internationale de Diffusion et d'Edition (SIDE) (C-199/06) [2008] 2 CMLR 20 | Recognizes national courts may uphold compensation claims for damage caused by unlawful State aid. | Referenced regarding the possibility of damages claims for breach of State aid rules. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court began by identifying the ordinary or "normal" tax system as the necessary reference point for assessing selectivity under Article 107(1) TFEU. Credit Suisse proposed the normal system as the tax regime without BPT, but the court found that using a hypothetical indefinite BPT system as a reference was impermissible and inconsistent with case law. The court recognized that the limited chargeable period was a deliberate, inherent feature of BPT, designed as a short-term measure targeting the main bonus season in 2009-10, with regulatory reforms expected to follow.
Accordingly, the court held that Taxed Banks (those paying bonuses during the chargeable period) and Untaxed Banks (those with different accounting periods paying bonuses outside that period) were not in a comparable factual and legal situation in light of BPT’s objectives. The differentiation in treatment flowed from the nature and general structure of the tax system and was therefore justified.
Credit Suisse failed to adduce evidence to show that any Untaxed Bank obtained an economic advantage or that competition and trade between Member States were affected. The court declined to draw inferences on these matters given the lack of direct evidence.
On the claim for repayment of tax, the court reaffirmed the general principle that taxpayers cannot recover tax paid simply because others were exempted, except in the limited circumstances described in Boiron involving deliberate asymmetric taxation designed to confer an advantage. The court found no such deliberate design in BPT.
Regarding the Francovich damages claim, the court applied a multi-factorial test considering the importance of the breached principle, clarity of the rule, excusability of error, intention, and other factors. It found the breach, if any, was not sufficiently serious to warrant damages, noting the novelty of the argument, lack of deliberate intention to infringe, and that the government took legal advice and acted proportionately.
The court also acknowledged statutory provisions precluding claims for damages or repayment outside the prescribed procedures and time limits but did not decide on that issue due to the outcome on liability.
Holding and Implications
The court's final decision is in favour of HMRC, dismissing Credit Suisse's claim.
The imposition of BPT on Credit Suisse did not constitute unlawful State aid under Article 107(1) TFEU because the differentiation between banks with calendar year ends and those with other year ends was justified by the nature and objectives of the tax regime. Consequently, Credit Suisse could not recover the tax paid nor claim damages under the Francovich principle.
No broader precedent was established beyond the application of existing State aid principles to the facts of a limited-period tax measure. The decision confirms the importance of identifying the normal tax system in selectivity assessments and supports the principle that short-term tax measures designed to achieve legitimate policy objectives may not constitute unlawful State aid even if they impact different groups differently due to timing.
Alert