- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Jamous v Mercouris
Factual and Procedural Background
This appeal concerns the requirement for the appointment of a litigation friend to act on behalf of the First Claimant under CPR Rule 21.6 due to questions about his capacity to conduct proceedings. The First Claimant is an adult in his late 20s who has been assessed as lacking capacity within the meaning of the Mental Capacity Act 2005. The litigation friend application was made by Mrs Jamous, who is the mother of the First Claimant and has acted as the driving force behind the litigation.
The proceedings arise from a personal injury claim against the Defendant, involving allegations of professional negligence and deceit related to the First Claimant’s claim against Westminster City Council. The litigation history is complex and lengthy, involving multiple orders for disclosure, witness statements, and medical evidence, many of which the Claimants failed to comply with, resulting in the striking out of the Second Claimant’s claim (Mrs Jamous' own claim).
The court has made several orders requiring compliance with procedural steps, including the filing of a certificate of capacity for the First Claimant. The First Claimant’s claim was struck out by Master Davison for failure to provide such a certificate, but an appeal was brought, which is the subject of this judgment. The Defendant has objected to Mrs Jamous acting as litigation friend, citing her conduct and suitability concerns.
Throughout the proceedings, Mrs Jamous has made numerous applications, some certified as totally without merit by various judges, and has frequently failed to comply with court orders or procedural requirements. There have also been multiple contested hearings and applications involving various High Court judges, with disputes over procedural compliance, disclosure, and the conduct of the litigation.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the First Claimant lacks capacity within the meaning of the Mental Capacity Act 2005, thereby qualifying as a protected party requiring a litigation friend.
- Whether Mrs Jamous satisfies the conditions set out in CPR Rule 21.4(3) to act as litigation friend, including the ability to fairly and competently conduct proceedings on behalf of the First Claimant, having no interest adverse to him, and undertaking to pay any costs ordered against him.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- Mrs Jamous applied to be appointed as litigation friend, asserting the First Claimant lacks capacity and trusts no one else due to prior negative experiences with his former solicitor.
- She relies on a Power of Attorney, a certificate as to capacity, and prior court orders to support her application.
- Mrs Jamous contends she has no interest adverse to the First Claimant and undertakes any costs payable in relation to the proceedings.
- She explains past failures to comply with court orders by personal circumstances, including caring for her son and recently deceased elderly mother, and asserts improved understanding of court procedures.
- She emphasizes that the First Claimant trusts only her to act as litigation friend.
Defendant's Arguments
- The Defendant disputes that Mrs Jamous has no interest adverse to the First Claimant, citing her prior conduct and the nature of the claims.
- The Defendant challenges Mrs Jamous’s ability to fairly and competently conduct proceedings on behalf of the First Claimant, referencing a previous court order prohibiting her from acting as litigation friend due to concerns about her conduct and interest adverse to the protected party.
- The Defendant submits that Mrs Jamous’s undertaking as to costs is worthless given her financial position.
- The Defendant highlights Mrs Jamous’s repeated failures to comply with court orders, numerous applications certified as totally without merit, and her conduct of the litigation, which has been detrimental to the proceedings.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Masterman-Lister v Brutton & Co [2003] 1 WLR 1511; [2002] EWCA Civ 1889 | Purpose of litigation rules on capacity: to protect parties at a disadvantage and prevent harassment by others | The court cited the principle that litigation rules on capacity protect parties and ensure fair conduct, supporting the requirement for a litigation friend for protected parties. |
| RP v Nottingham City Council [2008] EWCA Civ 462 | Duties of litigation friend: beneficence and competence in conducting litigation | The court referred to the dual obligations of a litigation friend to act for the benefit of the protected party and to conduct proceedings competently, as relevant to assessing Mrs Jamous's suitability. |
| Re E (Mental Health Patient) 1984 I WLR 20 | Definition and assessment of capacity under the Mental Capacity Act 2005 | The court applied the legal standard for capacity, requiring assessment on the balance of probabilities and considering medical evidence. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court first considered whether the First Claimant lacks capacity within the meaning of the Mental Capacity Act 2005. The medical evidence, primarily from Dr Khalaf, indicated that the First Claimant suffers from complex post-traumatic stress disorder, secondary depression and anxiety, and paranoid ideation, resulting in impaired concentration, emotional arousal, and inability to use or weigh information to make decisions in conducting proceedings. On the balance of probabilities, the court concluded that the First Claimant lacks capacity and is therefore a protected party requiring a litigation friend.
The court then assessed whether Mrs Jamous meets the conditions in CPR Rule 21.4(3) to act as litigation friend. This includes the ability to fairly and competently conduct proceedings on behalf of the protected party, having no interest adverse to him, and undertaking to pay any costs ordered against him.
The court reviewed Mrs Jamous's extensive history of conduct in the litigation, which included numerous failures to comply with court orders, applications certified as totally without merit, appearances before judges without notice to the Defendant, and disputes over disclosure and procedural compliance. The court noted a prior order from 2008 prohibiting Mrs Jamous from acting as litigation friend due to concerns about her ability to fairly and competently conduct proceedings and her adverse interest.
Although Mrs Jamous asserted changed circumstances and support from a legal executive associate, the court found that her past conduct, ongoing procedural non-compliance, and the risk of further detrimental impact on the litigation and costs order consequences outweighed these factors. The court also considered the First Claimant's trust in his mother but concluded that this was insufficient to outweigh the serious concerns about her suitability.
The court further noted that the First Claimant's claim benefits from Qualified One Way Costs Shifting (QOCS), but costs orders have been made against the Claimants, which could reduce any damages recovered. Mrs Jamous’s undertaking as to costs was considered of little value given her financial position.
In conclusion, the court held that Mrs Jamous cannot fairly and competently conduct the proceedings on behalf of the First Claimant and that appointing her as litigation friend would not be in the First Claimant’s best interests or protect the interests of the Defendant.
Holding and Implications
The court REFUSED the application by Mrs Jamous to be appointed as litigation friend for the First Claimant.
The direct effect of this decision is that the First Claimant remains without a litigation friend, which affects the ability to continue the appeal and any further steps in the proceedings until a suitable litigation friend is appointed. The court’s decision is grounded in the necessity to ensure competent representation for protected parties and to safeguard the interests of all parties in litigation. No new precedent was established, but the ruling underscores the importance of compliance with CPR rules regarding capacity and litigation friends, and the court’s scrutiny of the suitability of proposed litigation friends, especially where there is a history of procedural non-compliance and adverse interests.
Alert