- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Birmingham City Council v Afsar & Ors
Factual and Procedural Background
This case concerns protests conducted outside a primary school ("the School") against aspects of its teaching, specifically relating to sexual behaviour, sexuality, and gender. The protests began around 18 March 2019 and involved parents, relatives, and other individuals, many of whom are of the Muslim faith advocating conservative community values. The local council ("the Council") applied for injunctions to restrain aspects of the protest, citing escalation and impact on the School community.
The Council sought and obtained without notice interim injunctions on 31 May 2019 from a judge sitting in London. These injunctions imposed an exclusion zone around the School, prohibited conduct causing harassment or distress, restricted approaching staff or witnesses, and limited social media use targeting School staff. The injunctions were served on named defendants on 3 June 2019 and included a category of "Persons Unknown" to cover other protestors. On 4 June 2019, the Council obtained an extension of the exclusion zone without notice.
The present judgment arises from a pre-trial hearing on 10 June 2019, where the Court considered applications by the first to third defendants to discharge the injunctions due to alleged failures in full and frank disclosure, and the Council's application to continue the injunctions pending trial. The Court discharged the original injunctions for procedural failings but granted new interim injunctions to remain in place until trial, scheduled before the end of July 2019.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the existing injunctions should be discharged due to failures in full and frank disclosure and procedural irregularities.
- Whether any interim injunctions should be granted pending trial and on what terms.
- What directions are necessary to ensure the case is resolved swiftly, fairly, and expeditiously.
- Whether and what injunction should be granted against "Persons Unknown" protestors.
Arguments of the Parties
Claimant's Arguments
- The Council argued for continuation of injunctions on the basis that the protests had escalated and caused serious nuisance, harassment, and distress to the School community.
- The Council justified the original without-notice application by asserting that giving notice would lead to escalation of disruptive conduct and further abuse of staff, citing past protestor behaviour when warned.
- The Council maintained that the injunctions were not bans on protest or expression but were limited to regulating where and how protests could be conducted to prevent anti-social behaviour.
- The Council relied on statutory powers under the Local Government Act 1972, the Anti-Social Behaviour, Crime and Policing Act 2014, the Highways Act 1980, and the Localism Act 2011.
- The Council contended that the threshold under section 12(2) of the Human Rights Act 1998 (HRA) for without-notice applications was met due to compelling reasons related to the risk of escalation.
- It was submitted that the injunctions were proportionate, just, and an appropriate exercise of the Court's discretion.
Defendants' Arguments
- The defendants contended that the injunctions interfered unjustifiably with their fundamental rights to protest, freedom of expression, religious freedom, and association.
- They argued that the Council overstated the conduct and its impact, noting police statements indicating no unlawful behaviour and that the protests were largely peaceful and lawful.
- The defendants alleged material non-disclosure by the Council, including failure to disclose relevant facts and legal thresholds, and failure to provide notes of hearings and judgments.
- They emphasized that freedom of expression includes the right to express views that may be offensive to some, and that the Court must not inhibit lawful protest.
- The defendants challenged the procedural propriety of the without-notice applications and the failure to comply with the duty of full and frank disclosure.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Bloomsbury Publishing Group v News Group Newspapers Ltd [2003] EWHC 1205 (Ch) | Legitimacy of claims and injunctions against "Persons Unknown". | Confirmed legitimacy of claims against Persons Unknown in protest contexts. |
| Cameron v Liverpool Victoria Insurance Co Ltd [2019] UKSC 6 | Limits of jurisdiction and practice regarding injunctions against unknown defendants. | Informed the Court's approach to Persons Unknown injunctions. |
| Boyd v Ineos Upstream Ltd [2019] EWCA Civ 515 | Application of injunctions to protest activities and engagement of s12 HRA. | Guided the Court's assessment of Persons Unknown injunction scope. |
| Moat Housing Group South Ltd v Harris [2005] EWCA Civ 287 | Requirement of notice and fairness in injunction applications, especially those affecting freedom of expression. | Emphasized the strict approach to without-notice applications and need for compelling reasons. |
| ND v KP [2011] EWHC 457 (Fam) | Criticism of without-notice applications without adherence to procedural requirements. | Supported the Court's insistence on compliance with procedural rules in without-notice applications. |
| O'Farrell v O'Farrell [2012] EWHC 123 (QB) | Duty of full and frank disclosure for without-notice injunctions. | Reinforced the importance of full disclosure in interim injunction applications. |
| Bristol City Council v News Group Newspapers Ltd [2012] EWHC 3748 (Fam) | Application of duty of disclosure and procedural fairness in injunctions affecting expression. | Supported the Court's scrutiny of procedural compliance. |
| YXB v TNO [2015] EWHC 826 (QB) | Summary of principles governing full and frank disclosure in without-notice applications. | Provided framework for assessing non-disclosure and its consequences. |
| Memory Corp v Sidhu (No 2) [2001] 1 WLR 1443 (CA) | High duty of full, fair, and accurate disclosure owed by applicants and advocates. | Supported the Court's expectations of legal teams in disclosure obligations. |
| Cream Holdings Ltd v Banerjee [2005] 1 AC 253 | Interpretation of "likely" success threshold under s12(3) HRA for injunctions affecting freedom of expression. | Clarified the threshold the claimant must meet for interim injunctions restricting expression. |
| ABC v Telegraph Media Group Ltd [2018] EWCA Civ 2329 | Application of s12(3) HRA threshold and balancing of rights in injunctions. | Supported the Court's approach to assessing likelihood of success. |
| Doncaster Metropolitan Borough Council v BBC [2010] EWHC 53 (QB) | Requirement to identify s12(3) HRA threshold in without-notice injunction applications. | Highlighted the necessity to address statutory thresholds in applications. |
| Dar al Arkan Real Estate Development Co v Al Refai [2012] EWHC 3539 (Comm) | Emphasized importance of statutory thresholds and procedural compliance in injunctions. | Reinforced procedural standards required by the Court. |
| RST v UVW [2009] EWHC 24 (QB) | Compelling reasons for without-notice applications often arise in blackmail or freezing orders. | Distinguished the present case from blackmail cases, finding no compelling reason for secrecy. |
| Lachaux v Independent Print Ltd [2019] UKSC 27 | Definition of "publication" in defamation and related torts. | Supported broad interpretation of "publication" under s12(3) HRA to include protest communications. |
| Aitken v DPP [2015] EWHC 1079 (Admin) | Scope of publication torts and communication law. | Supported the Court's interpretation of freedom of expression protections. |
| LJY v Persons Unknown [2017] EWHC 3230 | Higher threshold for interim injunctions protecting reputation (defamation rule). | Noted as a relevant consideration though not decisive here. |
| Chief Constable of Bedfordshire v Golding [2015] EWHC 1875 (QB) | Freedom of expression includes right to express offensive or objectionable views. | Supported defendants' argument on the scope of lawful expression. |
| Thames Cleaning and Support Services Ltd v United Voices of the World [2016] EWHC 1310 (QB) | Test for injunctions in protest cases: likelihood of unlawful conduct and framing of injunctions. | Applied as framework to assess appropriateness of interim injunctions. |
| G & G v Wikimedia [2010] EMLR 14 | Duty of counsel and solicitors to ensure accurate notes of without-notice hearings. | Supported criticism of failure to provide hearing notes and judgments. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court carefully examined the procedural history, statutory framework, and human rights implications of the case. The Council’s application for injunctions engaged multiple fundamental rights, including freedom of expression, religious freedom, and the right to protest, balanced against rights to education and protection from harassment.
The Court emphasized the high duty of full and frank disclosure required in without-notice injunction applications, especially where freedom of expression is engaged, citing relevant procedural rules and Practice Guidance. It found that the Council failed to comply with this duty by providing an insufficient and confused justification for proceeding without notice, omitting critical legal thresholds such as the requirement under s 12(3) HRA to demonstrate likelihood of success at trial, and failing to provide notes of hearings and judgments to the defendants.
The Court rejected the Council’s argument that urgency justified the without-notice procedure, noting that the application was made during half-term when the School community was largely absent, and that notice could have been given without risk of significant escalation. The Court distinguished the case from those warranting without-notice applications, such as blackmail or freezing orders, where secrecy is essential.
Substantively, the Court accepted that the Council was likely to succeed at trial in showing that certain protest conduct caused unlawful harassment and distress and that injunctions limited to regulating the manner and location of protests were justified and proportionate. However, the Court modified the injunctions to clarify their scope, removing overly broad or vague prohibitions such as bans on offensive comments or general harassment.
Regarding Persons Unknown, the Court acknowledged the legitimacy of injunctions against unknown protestors but required the category to be narrowly and clearly defined to avoid an overbroad order against the entire public. The Court proposed limiting Persons Unknown to those seeking to express opinions about the School’s teaching.
Holding and Implications
The Court DISCHARGED the original without-notice injunctions granted on 31 May 2019 due to serious failures in the Council’s duty of full and frank disclosure and procedural non-compliance, including the absence of justification for proceeding without notice and failure to identify the statutory threshold under s 12(3) HRA.
Simultaneously, the Court GRANTED FRESH INTERIM INJUNCTIONS to remain in place pending trial, with costs awarded against the Council. These injunctions were more narrowly tailored to balance the competing rights involved, restricting protest conduct that amounted to harassment or anti-social behaviour without prohibiting lawful expression of views.
The Court also clarified the approach to injunctions against Persons Unknown, requiring a defined and limited class to prevent overly broad orders and to ensure fairness.
The decision underscores the critical importance of strict adherence to procedural rules, especially the duty of full and frank disclosure, and the statutory protections for freedom of expression in injunction proceedings. While the Council’s concerns about protest conduct were accepted as likely justifying restraint, the Court reinforced that such restraint must be imposed fairly, transparently, and with proper legal foundation.
Alert