Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Horsley v Revenue & Customs (PROCEDURE : Hearings in private)

First-tier Tribunal (Tax)
Jan 8, 2019
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The Appellant was subject to a tax investigation by the Respondents, who alleged undeclared disposal of properties other than the Appellant's main home. HMRC issued an information notice in June 2011, which the Appellant failed to comply with, resulting in penalties imposed in September and November 2011. Subsequently, HMRC issued tax assessments for the years 2002-03 to 2006-07, alleging undeclared business activity and capital gains tax liabilities.

The Appellant requested reductions in the assessments in August 2013, citing personal difficulties including depression and dyscalculia, and commenced appeal proceedings in September 2013, applying for permission to appeal out of time. The Tribunal directed a stay of the appeal pending clarification of appealable decisions, which was extended multiple times. The Tribunal ultimately struck out the appeal in November 2014 due to failure to comply with directions, allowing a 28-day period for reinstatement.

The Appellant was made bankrupt by High Court order in June 2015. Nearly three years later, in August 2017, the Appellant applied to reinstate the appeal. HMRC objected on grounds of delay and lack of standing due to bankruptcy. The Tribunal held a hearing in September 2018 to consider the reinstatement application and the effect of the bankruptcy on the Appellant's standing to pursue the appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Appellant has standing to pursue the appeal following the bankruptcy order made against her.
  2. Whether the late application to reinstate the appeal should be granted.

Arguments of the Parties

Respondents' Arguments

  • The appeal rights vested in the trustee in bankruptcy upon the Appellant's bankruptcy under section 283 of the Insolvency Act 1986.
  • The Appellant lacks personal interest and legal standing to pursue the appeal.
  • The appeal was brought out of time and the Appellant had ample opportunity to challenge the assessments before bankruptcy.
  • The trustee in bankruptcy is the proper party to pursue any appeal.

Appellant's Arguments

  • The bankruptcy petition was initially adjourned and only finalized in June 2015, with discharge in June 2016.
  • The bankruptcy is ongoing with unresolved matters involving the trustee, including allegations of conflict of interest.
  • The Appellant has made efforts to pursue the appeal and disputes the Respondents' position on the standing.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Heath v Tang [1993] 1 WLR 1421 Appeal rights vest in the trustee in bankruptcy; bankrupt lacks standing to appeal adverse judgments relating to property in the estate. Applied to hold that the Appellant's appeal rights vested in the trustee and that the Appellant lacked standing to pursue the appeal.
Ahajot (Count Artsrunik) v Waller (Inspector of Taxes) [2004] STC (SCD) 151 Confirmed that post-bankruptcy, the right of appeal against tax assessments vests in the trustee in bankruptcy. Relied upon to support the Respondents' contention that the Appellant lacks standing.
Re Hurren (A Bankrupt) [1983] 1 W.L.R. 183 Property and claims vest in the trustee in bankruptcy; bankrupt has no standing to pursue claims related to the estate. Referenced to reinforce the principle that the trustee holds appeal rights.
Pathania v Adedeji [2014] EWCA Civ 681 Commencing or pursuing a claim without title constitutes abuse of process; actions vested in trustee can be regularised by joinder or assignment. Considered by the Tribunal to explain possible procedural regularisation but not altering the standing issue here.
Arnold v Williams [2008] EWHC 218 (Ch); [2008] B.P.I.R. 247 Held that discharged bankrupt retains appeal rights for tax due at date of bankruptcy, contrary to other authorities. Not followed by the Tribunal, which found the reasoning less persuasive than Heath and Artsrunik.
R. (on the application of Singh) v Revenue and Customs Commissioners [2010] UKUT 174; [2010] BPIR 933 Supported that bankrupt has no standing; appeal rights rest with trustee who controls whether appeal proceeds. Used to support the Tribunal’s conclusion on standing and the role of the trustee.
Count Artsrunik v Waller [2005] B.P.I.R. 82 Confirmed that appeal rights for pre-bankruptcy tax assessments vest in trustee; bankrupt has no personal interest. Followed by the Tribunal as authoritative on the issue of standing.
Ali v Revenue and Customs Commissioners [2015] UKFTT 464 (TC); [2015] B.P.I.R. 1348 Applied the principles from Count Artsrunik regarding standing post-bankruptcy. Referenced as consistent with the Tribunal’s approach.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Tribunal examined the effect of the Appellant's bankruptcy on her standing to pursue the appeal. Under section 283(1)(a) of the Insolvency Act 1986, all property and rights, including rights of appeal relating to tax assessments issued prior to bankruptcy, vest in the trustee in bankruptcy. The Tribunal relied heavily on the authorities of Heath v Tang and Ahajot v Waller, which establish that the bankrupt individual loses personal standing to pursue claims or appeals concerning estate property once bankruptcy is declared.

The Tribunal considered the Appellant's arguments and the timing of the bankruptcy petition and discharge but found that these did not affect the fundamental legal principle that appeal rights had vested in the trustee. The Appellant’s personal discharge from bankruptcy did not restore standing to pursue the appeal personally.

The Tribunal noted that while procedural mechanisms exist to regularise actions commenced by a bankrupt without trustee involvement, such as joinder or assignment, these had not been pursued here. Furthermore, the appeal and reinstatement application were both out of time, and the trustee had not taken any steps to continue the appeal over a period of more than three years.

Given these factors, the Tribunal exercised its discretion to refuse the Appellant's application to reinstate the appeal. The Tribunal also declined to notify the trustee directly, reasoning that the trustee would have been aware of the assessments and appeal given the bankruptcy proceedings and the delay in seeking reinstatement.

The Tribunal acknowledged the Appellant's personal circumstances and other claims but held these irrelevant to the question of standing and therefore did not consider them in its decision.

Holding and Implications

The Tribunal refused the Appellant's application to reinstate the appeal.

The direct consequence is that the appeal remains struck out and the Appellant cannot personally pursue the appeal against the tax assessments and penalties issued prior to her bankruptcy. The appeal rights are vested in the trustee in bankruptcy, who has not sought to continue the appeal. No new precedent was established by this decision; it reaffirms established legal principles regarding the effect of bankruptcy on appeal rights and standing in tax matters.