Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Amey Highways Ltd West Sussex County Council

England and Wales High Court (Technology & Construction Court)
Jul 30, 2018
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The Plaintiff initiated proceedings against the Defendant alleging failures in the Defendant's procurement of a Highways Term Service Contract spanning 2018 to 2028 (the Contract), governed by the Public Contract Regulations 2015 (the 2015 Regulations). The Defendant awarded the Contract to a third party, with the Plaintiff's tender score narrowly trailing the successful bidder by 0.03 points. The Plaintiff contends that its score was incorrectly assessed and that it should have been awarded the Contract.

The Plaintiff's claims are divided into two main categories: (i) the Instruction Claims, alleging unlawful instructions from the Defendant concerning the structuring of staff costs that adversely affected the Plaintiff's price scoring; and (ii) the Manifest Error Claims, alleging manifest errors in the scoring of two evaluation criteria that should have resulted in a higher score for the Plaintiff.

The Defendant's Defence included a time-bar argument against the Instruction Claims but otherwise denied their substance, while pleading substantive defences to the Manifest Error Claims. Subsequent procedural steps included applications by both parties for strike out or summary judgment on various claims, and an application by the Defendant to amend its Defence to substantively address the Instruction Claims.

The court structured its consideration of issues in the following order: whether the Instruction Claims were time-barred or subject to summary judgment; whether summary judgment or strike out was appropriate for the Manifest Error Claims; and whether the Defendant should be permitted to amend its Defence.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Instruction Claims are time-barred under Regulation 92 of the Public Contract Regulations 2015, and if so, whether the court should grant an extension of time.
  2. Whether summary judgment should be entered in favour of the Plaintiff on the Instruction Claims due to the Defendant's lack of reasonable prospects of success.
  3. Whether the Manifest Error Claims should be struck out or subject to summary judgment on the basis that they disclose no reasonable grounds or that the Plaintiff has no reasonable prospects of success.
  4. Whether the Defendant should be granted permission to amend its Defence to include substantive defences to the Instruction Claims.

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiff's Arguments

  • The Defendant's instructions on 19 January and 2 February 2018 were unlawful, improperly requiring reallocation of staff costs in a manner inconsistent with the tender documents, which adversely affected the Plaintiff's pricing score.
  • The Plaintiff was entitled to exclude certain staff costs from the Local Office Management Overhead (LMO) section on the basis that these were subcontractor costs or funded by third party sales, as permitted by the tender instructions.
  • The Plaintiff contends that its tender would have been the most competitive absent the Defendant's instructions.
  • The Manifest Error Claims assert that the Defendant irrationally and erroneously scored the Plaintiff’s proposals on Winter Service and Drainage Cleansing, failing to properly consider contractualised Savings Cards and clarifications provided by the Plaintiff.
  • The Plaintiff requested extensions of time for the Instruction Claims, relying on a standstill agreement and asserting that the claims were not time-barred.

Defendant's Arguments

  • The Instruction Claims are time-barred as the Plaintiff knew or ought to have known the grounds for these claims more than 30 days before proceedings were issued.
  • The Defendant initially pleaded only a bare denial of the Instruction Claims’ substance but later sought permission to amend its Defence to plead substantive defences.
  • The Defendant applied to strike out the Manifest Error Claims on the basis that the Plaintiff had no realistic prospect of success, arguing that the tender documents did not prohibit the Defendant from taking account of weaknesses in the Savings Cards.
  • The Defendant contended that the relevant date for time running on the 4.25 full-time equivalent (FTE) staff cost claim was the earlier instruction of 19 January 2018, not 2 February 2018 as submitted by the Plaintiff.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Jobsin.co.uk v Department of Health [2002] 1 CMLR 44 Establishing when grounds for starting proceedings arise; the date when a right of action first arises. Used to explain the two-part enquiry for timing claims: when grounds arise and when knowledge is acquired.
Amarylis Limited v HM Treasury [2009] EWHC 962 (TCC) Grounds for bringing proceedings arise when a specific and irrevocable act occurs. Referenced regarding the timing of claims under procurement regulations.
SITA v GMWDA [2011] 2 CMLR 32 Knowledge required to start time running is knowledge of facts indicating an infringement, not absolute proof. Applied to confirm the knowledge-based test for starting time limits.
Matrix-SCM Limited v LB Newham [2011] EWHC 2414 Strict approach to extension of time limits; factors relevant to good reason for extension. Guided the court's discretion on whether to extend time for bringing claims.
Law Society of England and Wales v LSC [2010] 2555 (Admin) Relevant considerations in extending time include importance of issues, strength of claim, knowledge, and prejudice. Summarized to inform the court's exercise of discretion on time extension.
SITA (first instance) [2010] EWHC 680 Ch Assessment of claim strength in the context of time-bar discretion. Referenced regarding the limited weight that claim strength should have in time extension decisions.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analysed the timing of the Instruction Claims under Regulation 92 of the Public Contract Regulations 2015, which requires proceedings to be issued within 30 days of when the claimant knew or ought to have known the grounds for the claim, subject to a possible extension of up to three months for good reason.

Regarding the claim involving the 4 FTE staff costs, time began to run on 19 January 2018 and expired on 19 February 2018. No good reason was advanced for the Plaintiff's failure to issue proceedings within this period. However, the court exercised discretion to extend time for this claim due to the Defendant's late application to amend its Defence to plead substantive defences, the absence of prejudice to the Defendant, and the practical reality that the claim would have been litigated alongside other claims. Permission was granted for the Defendant to amend its Defence accordingly.

For the claim concerning the 4.25 FTE staff costs, the court preferred the Plaintiff's interpretation that time began to run on 2 February 2018, the date of the Defendant's clearer instruction regarding the inclusion of these costs without a percentage reduction. The existence of a standstill agreement covering the period after 2 March 2018 justified extending time to 15 March 2018, when proceedings were issued.

The court rejected the Defendant's submission that the Manifest Error Claims had no reasonable prospect of success. The claims alleged that the Defendant's scoring was irrational and erroneous due to misinterpretation of contractualised Savings Cards and failure to consider clarifications. Determining these issues required factual analysis beyond the scope of strike out or summary judgment at this stage.

Overall, the court exercised restraint in assessing claim strength at this preliminary stage, emphasizing that neither the Plaintiff's claims nor the Defendant's proposed defences appeared fanciful or insubstantial on the available material.

Holding and Implications

The court granted extensions of time for the Plaintiff's Instruction Claims, allowing the claims to proceed despite initial time-bar arguments.

The court permitted the Defendant to amend its Defence to plead substantive defences to the Instruction Claims, enabling a fuller contest on the merits.

The court rejected the Defendant's application to strike out or obtain summary judgment on the Manifest Error Claims, allowing these claims to proceed to substantive consideration.

No summary judgment or strike out orders were made on the Instruction Claims, reflecting the court's view that these matters required fuller factual and legal examination.

The decision directly affects the parties by allowing the Plaintiff's claims to continue and the Defendant to defend substantively, but it does not establish new legal precedent beyond applying established principles on time limits and procedural discretion in procurement challenges.