- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Besley v John
Factual and Procedural Background
This appeal arises from an order made by His Honour Judge Moseley QC in the Merthyr Tydfil County Court concerning competing rights over an area of common land known as Vaynor Common, covering approximately 3,700 acres. The Respondent, the freehold owner of a golf course on part of the common, had extended the course in 1994, increasing mown areas by 14 acres. The Appellant owns adjacent farms and holds registered grazing rights on the common under the Commons Registration Act 1965, specifically for sheep grazing. The dispute centers on the extent and exercise of these grazing rights, particularly regarding the use of vehicles on the common and the right to bring additional feed onto the land. The Appellant also counterclaimed that the golf course expansion interfered with his grazing rights. The County Court made a declaration limiting the Appellant's rights to bring feed onto the land and restricting vehicle use to cases of necessity, which the Appellant appealed.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Appellant's right to graze sheep on the common includes a right to bring additional feed onto the land.
- Whether the Appellant has a right to use motor vehicles on the common for general shepherding purposes beyond cases of necessity.
- Whether the golf course's expansion and mowing of additional common land unreasonably interfered with the Appellant's grazing rights.
- The appropriate scope and limitations of the Appellant's rights of common in light of modern practices and the interests of the landowner.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The Appellant claimed ancillary rights to use motor vehicles on the common to bring feed and attend to the welfare of livestock, necessary for the reasonable enjoyment of his grazing rights.
- He contended that the right to drive vehicles for general shepherding was part of the right to graze and that the judge erred in limiting vehicle use to cases of necessity such as removal of sick or injured animals.
- The Appellant argued that the golf course's expansion and increased mowing interfered with his grazing rights by reducing available pasture.
Respondent's Arguments
- The golf club asserted that the Appellant has no right to bring additional feed onto the land, and vehicle use is restricted except in cases of necessity related to animal welfare.
- The Respondent contended that any right to use the common must be exercised reasonably and not interfere with their enjoyment of the land.
- They argued that the expansion and mowing of the golf course did not materially interfere with the Appellant's grazing rights.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Earl of Antrim v Dobbs | Test for ancillary rights: whether the right or use is reasonably necessary for the enjoyment of the primary right. | Applied to determine if ancillary rights such as vehicle use for feeding sheep are reasonably necessary incidents of the right to graze. Held that bringing additional feed was not reasonably necessary. |
| Dand v Kingscote and McDouell v Kenneth | Principle that rights reserved or granted are not confined to methods or appliances in use at the time of grant. | Supported the view that the mode of exercising rights may adapt to modern circumstances, relevant to vehicle use for shepherding. |
| White v Taylor [1969] 1 Ch 160 | Recognition that rights to graze include incidental rights necessary for proper care and management of sheep, but vehicle use is only permitted when necessary, not merely convenient. | Guided the court's analysis on the scope of vehicle use for shepherding, emphasizing necessity over convenience. |
| B & Q v Liverpool & Lancashire Properties Ltd [2001] 1 EGLR 93 | Consideration of rights of way and impact of changes in servient tenement on mode of exercise of rights. | Distinguished as irrelevant because the case concerned rights of way, not grazing rights, and the "hefting" restriction was a choice of the Appellant. |
| Celsteel Ltd v Alton House Holdings Ltd [1985] 1 WLR 204 | Related to rights of way and their exercise. | Referenced in context of B & Q but not applied to the facts of the present case. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court carefully examined the nature and extent of the Appellant's rights under the Commons Registration Act 1965, focusing on the right to graze sheep as the right to eat the grass growing on the common and nothing more. Drawing on the precedent in Earl of Antrim v Dobbs, the court applied the test of reasonable necessity to ancillary rights, concluding that the right to bring additional feed onto the common land was not a necessary incident of the right to graze and thus not included.
Regarding the use of vehicles for shepherding, the court recognized that attending to the welfare of sheep is an incident of the right to graze. It accepted that the mode of exercising this right can evolve with time and locality, as supported by the Antrim case, and that vehicle use may be reasonable in modern circumstances. However, vehicle use must be exercised reasonably and only when necessary, not merely for convenience. The court found the judge's original restriction too narrow and invited further submissions to define reasonable vehicle use that balances the Appellant's welfare rights with the landowner's interests.
On the counterclaim that the golf course expansion interfered with grazing rights, the court upheld the judge's findings that the mowing of greens, tees, and fairways constituted a very small proportion of the common and did not materially diminish grazing availability. Photographic evidence of sheep grazing on mown areas supported this conclusion. The court rejected the argument that the "hefted" area should alter the scope of rights against the landowner.
Finally, the court emphasized the importance of a clear, agreed order delineating the rights and limitations to avoid further disputes, proposing that the parties submit such an order for approval.
Holding and Implications
The appeal was allowed in part.
The court upheld the limitation that the Appellant has no right to bring additional feed onto the common land. However, it allowed the appeal to the extent that the Appellant's right to use vehicles for general shepherding purposes should not be confined strictly to cases of necessity like removal of sick animals but may extend to reasonable use in attending to sheep welfare, subject to reasonable restrictions to protect the landowner's interests and prevent damage.
The counterclaim that the golf course expansion unreasonably interfered with grazing rights was dismissed, affirming that the mowing and use of the land by the golf course did not materially reduce the Appellant's grazing rights.
The court directed the parties to negotiate and submit a clear order defining the scope and limits of vehicle use on the common to minimize future litigation. The Appellant was ordered to pay two-thirds of the Respondent's costs in both the Court of Appeal and the lower court. Permission to appeal was refused beyond the allowed extent.
No new precedent was established; the decision clarifies the application of existing principles to rights of common grazing and ancillary vehicle use in a modern context.
Alert