- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
London Borough Of Brent v A & B
Factual and Procedural Background
The local authority issued an application for a care order concerning two children, referred to as Child A (aged 6) and Child B (aged 15 months), on 15 March 2016. The mother of both children is referred to as the Mother. The father of Child A does not have parental responsibility and has had no contact with Child A since infancy. The father of Child B shares parental responsibility. The Mother's partner at the relevant time, referred to as Partner, was caring for Child B when the child sustained serious head and eye injuries on 22 February 2016. Prior to this date, the children had always lived with their Mother and had no prior involvement with Children's Services.
On 22 February 2016, Child B suffered significant injuries including a large acute subdural haemorrhage and extensive retinal haemorrhages, requiring emergency neurosurgery and intensive care. The injuries were discovered shortly after Child B was left in the sole care of Partner while the Mother took Child A to school. Medical experts were instructed to assess the injuries and their cause.
The hearing was initially listed as a final composite hearing, but the Judge decided to give judgment only on the facts and threshold criteria, deferring welfare considerations to a later hearing. The court received extensive medical and lay evidence, including from four independent medical experts and various social workers and family members. The local authority sought findings that the injuries to Child B were inflicted and that the Mother failed to protect the children by leaving them with Partner and by misleading professionals about her relationship with him.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether Child B's injuries were inflicted or accidental in origin.
- Whether the Mother failed to protect Child B by leaving him in the sole care of Partner.
- Whether the threshold criteria under the Children Act 1989, section 31(2) were met, including the risk of significant harm to the children.
- The credibility and reliability of the parties and witnesses, including the significance of lies told to professionals.
- The appropriate application of expert medical evidence in determining causation and risk of harm.
Arguments of the Parties
Local Authority's Arguments
- Child B's injuries were inflicted by Partner during the time he was left alone with the child on 22 February 2016.
- The Mother failed to protect Child B by leaving him with Partner without sufficient guidance or instruction.
- The Mother and Partner colluded to conceal the true nature of their relationship and the extent of Partner's care of the children, including the weekend prior to the injury.
- The children were suffering and likely to suffer significant harm from neglect, emotional harm, and physical harm.
Mother's Arguments
- Accepts that Child B was injured but denies knowledge of how or when the injuries occurred.
- Admits to lying about her relationship with Partner and the extent of his care but struggles to accept that Partner inflicted the injuries.
- Accepts failure to protect the children by allowing Partner into the household quickly and leaving children with him during her absence.
- Expresses need for support and honesty if children are to be returned.
Partner's Arguments
- Denies inflicting the injuries on Child B.
- Claims the injuries resulted from an unwitnessed accidental fall from the bed.
- Admits fault in leaving Child B unattended but denies any violent or abusive behaviour.
- Argues the local authority failed to prove he inflicted the injuries and that there is no evidence of loss of temper or control.
Father of Child B's Arguments
- Suggests both the Mother and Partner could have been untruthful about the cause of Child B's injuries.
Children's Guardian's Position
- Does not take a specific position on whether the injuries were inflicted or accidental.
- Submits that if the injuries were accidental, the fall was foreseeable and avoidable, and Partner neglected to take precautions.
- Submits that the Mother exposed the children to risk by leaving them with Partner for prolonged periods without sufficient guidance.
- Highlights the volatile relationship between Mother and Partner and the risk of emotional harm to the children.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Re JS (A Minor) [2012] EWHC 1370 | Approach to fact-finding hearings in child protection cases. | Adopted as the correct approach for determining facts on the balance of probabilities. |
| Re B [2008] UKHL 35 | Standard of proof: balance of probabilities in care proceedings. | Confirmed the standard of proof applied by the court. |
| Re A (A Child) (Fact Finding Hearing, Speculation) [2011] EWCA Civ 12 | Findings of fact must be based on evidence, not speculation. | Guided the court to rely on evidence and proper inferences. |
| Re T [2004] EWCA Civ 558 | Evaluation of evidence as a whole, not in isolation. | Emphasised the need to consider all evidence contextually. |
| A County Council v KD & L [2005] EWHC 144 | Role of court vs medical experts in weighing evidence. | Court may depart from expert opinion if justified by other evidence. |
| Re S [2009] EWHC 2115 (Fam) | Ensuring experts stay within their expertise and defer appropriately. | Applied in assessing multidisciplinary expert evidence. |
| Re W & Aor. (Non Accidental Injury) [2003] FCR 346 | Importance of assessing credibility and reliability of parents and carers. | Considerable weight placed on witness credibility. |
| R v Lucas [1981] QB 720 | Recognition that witnesses may lie for various reasons; lies do not necessarily discredit all evidence. | Guided caution in assessing credibility given admitted lies. |
| Re R (Care Proceedings: Causation) [2011] EWHC 1715 | Consideration of unknown causation in disputed injury cases. | Applied to weigh causation evidence and burden of proof. |
| R v Henderson and Others [2010] EWCA Crim 1219 | Caution against assuming cause of injury is always identifiable. | Reminded court to avoid assumptions about causation. |
| North Yorkshire County Council v SA [2003] 2FLR 849 | Definition of pool of possible perpetrators and standard of proof for identification. | Applied in assessing likelihood of Partner as perpetrator. |
| Re S (A Child) [2014] 1 FLR 1421 | Clarification of threshold criteria focusing on objective standard of care, not intent. | Used to frame threshold findings for significant harm. |
| Re B (Care: Expert Witnesses) [1996] 1 FLR 667 | Court can depart from expert opinion with sound reasons. | Supported court's evaluation of conflicting expert evidence. |
| Re B (Threshold Criteria: Fabricated Illness) [2004] 2 FIR 200 | Importance of considering all evidence, medical and non-medical, in forming a clear picture. | Guided holistic assessment of evidence. |
| R v Cannings [2004] EWCA Crim 1 | Guidelines for evaluating medical evidence in disputed causation cases. | Informed cautious approach to medical certainty. |
| Re W (Children) [2009] EWCA Civ 59 | Unusual causation hypotheses must not be dismissed solely because they are unlikely. | Supported consideration of rare but possible causes. |
| Re M [2012] EWCA Civ 1580 | Warning against reversal of burden of proof in care proceedings. | Ensured proper burden of proof application. |
| Re BR (Proof of Facts) [2015] EWFC 41 | Significance of absence of explanation by carers in injury causation. | Considered in weighing credibility and causation. |
| Lancashire v R [2013] EWHC 3064 (Fam) | Assessment of credibility beyond demeanour; importance of contemporaneous records. | Applied in evaluating witness reliability and character evidence. |
| Re CB & JB (Care proceedings: Guidelines) [1998] 2 FLR 211 | Propensity evidence must be treated with great care; character admissible only for credit. | Guided treatment of character evidence. |
| Re A (A Child) [2015] EWFC 11 | Framework for establishing threshold criteria in care proceedings. | Used to structure threshold analysis. |
| Re J [2015] EWCA Civ 222 | Further guidance on threshold criteria application. | Supported threshold criteria assessment. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court engaged in a detailed evaluation of the extensive medical and lay evidence, emphasizing that medical evidence alone was not determinative. The Judge noted the agreement among medical experts as to the nature and timing of Child B's injuries but acknowledged their disagreement on causation, particularly whether the injuries resulted from shaking, impact, or an accidental fall.
The court considered expert opinions on the significance of retinal haemorrhages and retinal folds, noting that while these findings strongly suggested a shaking-type injury, they were not pathognomonic and rare exceptions exist. The Judge gave weight to the possibility that the injuries could have resulted from an accidental fall from the bed, recognizing this as an unlikely but possible cause.
The court also carefully assessed the credibility and reliability of the Mother and Partner, acknowledging numerous lies and attempts to conceal facts, especially concerning their relationship and the care arrangements prior to the injury. Despite these deceptions, the court found Partner's account of the injury event credible and accepted that he did not inflict the injury intentionally.
The court applied established legal principles governing fact-finding in care proceedings, including the burden and standard of proof, the need to consider all evidence in context, and the importance of assessing witness credibility without prejudice. The Judge was mindful to avoid reversing the burden of proof or relying solely on probabilities, instead basing findings on the totality of evidence.
In relation to threshold criteria, the court found that the children were suffering and likely to suffer significant harm due to neglect, emotional harm, and physical harm, primarily resulting from the Mother's failure to protect them by allowing Partner into the household quickly, leaving them with him without sufficient guidance, and by leaving them unattended for extended periods.
Holding and Implications
The court made the following findings on the balance of probabilities:
- Child B's injuries were the result of an unwitnessed accident, most likely a fall from the bed, and were not inflicted by Partner.
- Partner should not have left Child B unattended on the bed; the accident could have been avoided by taking sensible precautions.
- At the relevant date, both children were suffering and likely to suffer significant harm due to neglect, emotional harm, and physical harm.
- The Mother failed to protect the children by allowing Partner into the household too quickly, leaving them alone with him without sufficient guidance, and by misleading professionals about her relationship with Partner and care arrangements.
- The Mother's volatile behaviour and poor relationship choices place the children at ongoing risk of significant harm unless addressed.
The direct effect of this decision is that the court recognizes the injuries as accidental rather than inflicted by Partner, but holds the Mother responsible for failing to protect the children adequately. No new legal precedent was established; the decision is fact-specific and emphasizes careful evaluation of all evidence, including medical expert opinions and witness credibility, in child protection cases.
Alert