- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Burry & Knight Ltd & Anor v Knight
Factual and Procedural Background
The principal issue on appeal concerned section 117(3) of the Companies Act 2006 ("the no-access provision"), which allows a court to order a company not to comply with a request for inspection of its register of members if the request is not for a proper purpose. The appellant, a member of the respondent companies (referred to as Company A and Company B), requested access to their share registers. The Registrar in the Chancery Division found that the appellant's request was made for a mixture of proper and improper purposes and consequently made a no-access order on terms. The Registrar ordered that the respondent companies need not comply with the appellant's request for copies of their registers of members, subject to undertakings to circulate a letter from the appellant concerning share valuation issues, and ordered the appellant to pay the respondents' costs on an indemnity basis.
The appellant appealed against both the no-access order and the indemnity costs order. There was no cross-appeal regarding the Registrar's finding that the purpose of communicating about share valuation was proper.
The respondent companies are family-run holiday park businesses with shares held by members of two families. The appellant, a former director and shareholder, had longstanding complaints about the companies' conduct dating back to the 1980s and 1990s, including allegations of undisclosed payments and improper remuneration. The appellant sought access to the share registers to communicate these concerns to fellow shareholders and to raise issues about share valuation methods.
The Registrar found the appellant's first two stated purposes improper, as they were largely attempts to resurrect stale, unsubstantiated allegations and to pursue a family vendetta, while the third purpose concerning share valuation was proper. The Registrar ordered that the companies circulate a letter from the appellant on the share valuation issue but were not obliged to comply with the appellant’s full request for the registers. The Registrar also ordered that the companies need not comply with similar future requests by the appellant for improper purposes.
Following the Registrar's order, the companies circulated the appellant's letter on share valuation along with their own response. No shareholders responded, and the appellant and his wife did not attend the companies' annual general meeting or vote, despite receiving dividends.
On costs, the Registrar found the appellant's conduct unreasonable and awarded indemnity costs to the respondents. The appellant appealed this costs order, arguing that his conduct did not meet the threshold for indemnity costs, especially after he sought to withdraw his request and offered to settle.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the appellant’s request for access to the share registers was made for a proper purpose under section 117(3) of the Companies Act 2006.
- Whether a no-access order could be made on terms allowing limited communication to shareholders despite mixed proper and improper purposes.
- Whether the Registrar was correct to order indemnity costs against the appellant based on his conduct during the proceedings.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The appellant argued that his purpose in requesting access was proper, relating to shareholder democracy and corporate governance, aiming to communicate concerns about past conduct and share valuation to fellow shareholders.
- He contended that the allegations were still relevant and that access would allow shareholders to decide on appropriate action, including derivative claims or petitions.
- The appellant submitted that his conduct was not unreasonable to justify indemnity costs, especially given his efforts to withdraw from litigation and settle on terms where each party bore its own costs.
Respondents' Arguments
- The respondents contended that the appellant’s request was primarily to pursue a personal vendetta and harass shareholders with stale and unsubstantiated allegations.
- They argued that the appellant had already obtained the information he sought and that his request was therefore improper and an abuse of process.
- The respondents supported the Registrar’s decision to award indemnity costs, citing the appellant’s unreasonable conduct and refusal to accept reasonable settlement offers.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Davies v Gas Light and Coke Co [1909] 1 Ch 248 | Shareholder's right to access share register was traditionally absolute and not dependent on purpose. | Referenced to illustrate the change in law under the Companies Act 2006, where access can now be restricted for improper purposes. |
| Pelling v Family Need Fathers Limited [2002] BCLC 645 | Permitted court to make orders enabling communication with shareholders while protecting confidentiality of register details. | Applied to allow a no-access order on terms permitting the appellant to communicate with shareholders via the companies, balancing proper and improper purposes. |
| Excelsior Commercial & Industrial Holdings Ltd v Salisbury Hamer Aspden & Johnston [2002] EWCA Civ 879 | Principles for awarding indemnity costs where conduct is highly unreasonable or improper. | Referenced in assessing whether the appellant’s conduct justified indemnity costs, with the court ultimately deciding it did not. |
| Re Smith Fawcett & Co Limited [1942] Ch 304 | Considerations on making findings of fact on documents alone without cross-examination. | Used to discuss whether the Registrar was justified in making findings on purpose without cross-examination, concluding it was appropriate in this case. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court began by considering the statutory framework under the Companies Act 2006, particularly section 117(3), which requires the court to prohibit access to a company's register if the request is not for a proper purpose. The court recognized that "proper purpose" is to be interpreted in its ordinary, natural meaning and generally relates to a member's interests and shareholder rights.
The appellant’s request contained multiple purposes: two were found improper (seeking to resurrect stale allegations and pursue a family vendetta) and one was proper (raising concerns about share valuation). The court agreed with the Registrar’s assessment that the improper purposes predominated, as the allegations were unsubstantiated, stale, and unlikely to benefit the company or shareholders. The appellant’s failure to produce evidence or explain delays reinforced the inference of an improper purpose aimed at mischief and harassment.
The court acknowledged that the Registrar was entitled to draw adverse inferences from the appellant’s failure to substantiate his claims and that findings on purpose could be made on documents alone in clear cases without cross-examination. The court emphasized that the right of access is presumed but can be denied where improper purpose is established on the balance of probabilities.
Regarding mixed purposes, the court held that if any purpose is improper, the no-access order must be made. However, the court endorsed the approach in Pelling, allowing the court to make an order permitting communication with shareholders on proper purposes while restricting access to the register itself, effectively "policing" the use of information.
On costs, the court found that although the appellant’s conduct was robust, his efforts to withdraw and settle meant that his conduct did not reach the high threshold of unreasonableness required for indemnity costs. The respondents’ pursuit of a greater costs recovery than the appellant had offered was a factor in this conclusion.
Holding and Implications
The court DISMISSED the appeal against the no-access order under section 117(3) of the Companies Act 2006, affirming that the appellant’s purpose in seeking to circulate shareholders with details of past irregularities was not a proper purpose, either because it had no value to shareholders or was intended to harass them.
The court ALLOWED the appeal against the order for indemnity costs, holding that the appellant’s conduct after deciding to withdraw his request was not sufficiently unreasonable to justify indemnity costs.
The direct effect is that the no-access order on terms permitting limited communication about share valuation remains in place, protecting the companies from improper use of their registers. No new precedent was set beyond clarifying the application of section 117(3) and endorsing the continuing utility of orders akin to Pelling in cases of mixed purposes.
Alert