Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Albion Automotive Ltd v Walker & Ors

England and Wales Court of Appeal (Civil Division)
Jun 21, 2002
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal arises from a decision of the Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) dismissing the employer's appeal against an Employment Tribunal ruling. The Employment Tribunal held that 22 employees of Company A, who had been made redundant, were contractually entitled to enhanced redundancy terms beyond the statutory minimum, based on an established custom and practice. The dispute concerns whether such enhanced redundancy terms formed a contractual term by virtue of long-standing application and employer conduct.

The employees were employed at Company A’s site in The City. The site was previously owned by Company B until Company A acquired it in 1995. Between 1990 and 1994, multiple redundancy exercises were carried out at the site, during which enhanced redundancy terms were consistently applied to redundant employees following extensive negotiations with trade unions and approval by the parent company. These terms provided 12 weeks' pay per year of service. Approximately 750 employees benefited from these terms during this period.

After Company A’s acquisition, five employees were made redundant in 1996 but did not receive enhanced terms. In 1999, a redundancy exercise involving the 22 employees commenced; their representative asserted entitlement to the enhanced terms, but Company A contended only statutory redundancy applied. None of the employees had written contracts or statements of terms, and collective agreements did not address redundancy terms as these were not annually negotiated. The Employment Tribunal found that the enhanced terms had become a contractual term by custom and practice and that Company A breached contract by not applying them.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the enhanced redundancy terms had become a contractual term by virtue of custom and practice.
  2. Whether the employer intended to be contractually bound to pay enhanced redundancy terms on future redundancies beyond the specific exercises in which they had been applied.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The employer accepted the factual findings but challenged the legal correctness of the Employment Tribunal and EAT decisions.
  • Argued that to infer contractual intent to pay enhanced redundancy on future occasions, there must be evidence beyond past redundancy exercises demonstrating intention to be contractually bound.
  • Contended that nothing was said or done by the employer to show an intention to be contractually bound to enhanced payments.
  • Highlighted that on one occasion the phrase "currently in operation" referred to a redundancy exercise actually ongoing, undermining the argument that it indicated a standing contractual term.

Appellee's Arguments

  • Asserted there was ample evidence, including contemporaneous employer documentation, consistent only with an agreed formula for enhanced redundancy payments.
  • Pointed to repeated communications referencing terms "currently in operation," implying continuation of enhanced redundancy terms beyond specific exercises.
  • Relied on established legal principles from relevant precedents that factors such as duration, communication, and automatic application support inference of contractual status.
  • Highlighted multiple factors found by the Employment Tribunal supporting contractual intent, including written communication, consistent application, employee reasonable expectation, and absence of negotiation withdrawal.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Duke v Reliant Systems Ltd [1982] ICR 449 Establishment of contractual terms by custom and practice requires that a policy be communicated to employees or followed without exception for a substantial period. The court applied this principle to assess whether the enhanced redundancy terms had been communicated and consistently applied, supporting inference of contractual intent.
Quinn v Calder Industrial Materials Ltd [1996] IRLR 126 Contractual status of a policy depends on all circumstances, including the sufficiency of the period followed and whether the employer intended to be contractually bound. The court used this precedent to evaluate the totality of evidence, including communication and automatic application, to conclude the employer intended to be contractually bound.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined whether the enhanced redundancy terms had become a contractual term by custom and practice. It applied established legal principles requiring evidence of a longstanding, consistently followed policy communicated to employees, and an intention by the employer to be contractually bound.

The Employment Tribunal’s findings that the enhanced redundancy terms were well known, consistently applied over multiple redundancy exercises affecting a substantial portion of the workforce, and documented in writing were accepted. The Tribunal also found that the employer’s communications and conduct supported an inference of contractual intent, including that payments became automatic in later exercises.

The appellant’s argument that there was no explicit intention to be contractually bound on future occasions was rejected. The court agreed with the appellees that the cumulative factors, including the employer’s conduct and contemporaneous documentation, justified the inference that the employer intended to be contractually bound by the enhanced redundancy terms beyond isolated redundancy events.

The court concluded that there was no error of law in the Employment Tribunal’s decision and no basis for interference with its findings of fact and inferences drawn from them.

Holding and Implications

The court DISMISSED the appeal brought by Company A.

The direct effect is that the 22 employees are contractually entitled to the enhanced redundancy terms as determined by the Employment Tribunal. No broader precedent was established beyond affirming the application of established principles regarding contractual terms arising from custom and practice in this factual context.