Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Messer UK Ltd. & Anor. v Britvic Soft Drinks Ltd. & Ors

England and Wales Court of Appeal (Civil Division)
Apr 30, 2002
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The litigation concerns contamination discovered in May 1998 at a chemical plant operated by Company A, where carbon dioxide produced contained trace levels of benzene due to a leak allowing natural gas to bypass a purification section. Benzene is a carcinogen, and the contaminated carbon dioxide was supplied by Company A to Company B, which then sold it to various end users, including four respondents: Company C, Company D, Company E, and Company F. These respondents used the carbon dioxide in manufacturing sparkling drinks, which consequently contained traces of benzene, though not at levels posing health risks. Public concern, however, led to withdrawals of unsold products and claims for losses suffered.

The original judgment, delivered by Judge Tomlinson on 9th May 2001, spanned 130 pages. The appeal now relates only to limited parts of that judgment. The initial claims by two respondents (Company C and Company D) against Company B for breach of contractual terms including British Standard 4105 ("BS 4105") and implied terms under the Sale of Goods Act 1979 were abandoned. The remaining issues concern supplies to Company E and Company F, whose claims have been assigned to Company D. The appeal focuses on whether Company D, as assignee, can recover damages from Company B under the contracts with Company E and Company F.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether BS 4105 contains an express contractual term relevant to the presence of benzene in the carbon dioxide supplied.
  2. Whether clauses 11.1 and 11.2 in Company B’s standard contracts validly exclude or limit liability for breach of implied terms of satisfactory quality and fitness for purpose under section 14 of the Sale of Goods Act 1979.
  3. Whether the exclusion clauses satisfy the reasonableness requirement under the Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • BS 4105 concerns only certain scientific characteristics essential to carbon dioxide for industrial food applications and does not include a general undertaking of satisfactory quality or fitness for purpose.
  • Any liability for benzene contamination must be founded on express or implied contractual terms other than BS 4105.
  • Clauses 11.1 and 11.2 limit liability to compliance with BS 4105 and exclude other implied warranties, and such limitations are reasonable under the Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977.

Respondents' Arguments

  • BS 4105 should be understood as setting an appropriate standard including suitability for industrial food applications, implicitly covering contaminants such as benzene.
  • Excluding liability for benzene contamination via clauses 11.1 and 11.2 is unreasonable, particularly as benzene presence was unexpected and could only arise from a manufacturing mishap.
  • The purchasers could not have been expected to test for benzene or other extraneous contaminants, so responsibility should rest with the supplier.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Mitchell (George) (Chesterfield) v. Finney Lock Seeds Ltd. [1983] 2 AC 803 Standard for appellate review of reasonableness decisions under Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977 The court applied the principle that appellate courts should respect the original reasonableness decision unless it was plainly wrong or based on an erroneous principle.
Watford Electronics Ltd. v. Sanderson CFL Ltd. [2001] EWCA Civ 317; [2001] 1 AER 696 Consideration of knowledge and bargaining position regarding exclusion clauses The court considered the buyer’s knowledge of exclusion clauses and negotiations as relevant to reasonableness under the Act.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed the contractual terms and the scope of BS 4105. It held that BS 4105 serves primarily as a specification document identifying categories and permissible impurity levels for carbon dioxide types, rather than containing a general warranty or undertaking of suitability for industrial food applications, especially regarding contaminants not addressed by the standard such as benzene.

The court noted that the description of Type 2 carbon dioxide as "a higher quality grade which is also suitable for industrial food applications" is descriptive and classificatory rather than a contractual warranty. The specific impurity limits set out in BS 4105 relate to health and safety concerns rather than commercial or reputational considerations. The presence of benzene, though not a health hazard at the levels found, rendered the product commercially unsaleable due to public perception, a factor not contemplated by BS 4105.

Regarding the exclusion clauses (11.1 and 11.2), the court applied the reasonableness test under the Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977. It found that these clauses sought to limit liability to compliance with BS 4105 and exclude liability for breaches of implied terms of satisfactory quality and fitness for purpose. The court concluded that such limitations were unreasonable in the circumstances because the presence of benzene was an unforeseen manufacturing mishap, and the buyers could not have been expected to detect such contamination. The risk of such contamination should rest with the supplier, who is better placed to manage it.

The court also considered the parties' bargaining positions, the availability of alternative suppliers, and the extent to which the buyers knew of the exclusion clauses. It found that the exclusion clauses were standard terms incorporated without negotiation and that the buyers were not reasonably able to assess or accept the risk of benzene contamination.

Overall, the court upheld the original judge’s conclusion that BS 4105 did not provide an express warranty relevant to benzene contamination and that the exclusion clauses failed the reasonableness test, thus could not exclude liability for breach of implied terms under section 14 of the Sale of Goods Act 1979.

Holding and Implications

The court DISMISSED the appeal, affirming the original judgment’s conclusions on the key issues.

The direct effect is that Company D, as assignee of Company E and Company F, can recover damages from Company B for breach of implied terms of satisfactory quality and fitness for purpose under the Sale of Goods Act 1979. The exclusion clauses in the contracts are not valid to limit or exclude such liability due to their failure to satisfy the reasonableness requirement under the Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977.

No new legal precedent was established beyond the application of existing principles to the facts of this case.