Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Mr D Fotheringhame v Barclays Services Ltd (England and Wales : Unfair Dismissal)

United Kingdom Employment Tribunal
Mar 9, 2018
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The Plaintiff brought a claim of unfair dismissal against the Defendant, his former employer, following disciplinary proceedings related to the Plaintiff's conduct as Head of Automated Flow Trading within the Defendant’s electronic Foreign Exchange trading business. The Defendant dismissed the Plaintiff for alleged misconduct linked to the use and management of the "Last Look" trading system. The disciplinary process included multiple hearings and an appeal. The Plaintiff contended that he was not dismissed for misconduct but was instead a casualty of a regulatory order issued by the New York State Department for Financial Services (DFS), which required the Defendant to terminate his employment. The Defendant maintained that the dismissal was based on evidence and a fair procedure. The Employment Tribunal heard the case and reserved a remedy hearing for a later date.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Defendant had a reasonable and fair belief that the Plaintiff was guilty of misconduct justifying dismissal.
  2. Whether the Defendant conducted a reasonable investigation and followed a fair procedure in dismissing the Plaintiff.
  3. Whether the dismissal was within the range of reasonable responses for misconduct under employment law.
  4. The extent to which the Plaintiff contributed to the dismissal and whether any reduction in compensation is appropriate.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The Plaintiff argued that he was not dismissed for misconduct but due to pressure from the DFS Order requiring his termination.
  • He maintained that the Defendant did not reasonably believe he was guilty of misconduct.
  • The Plaintiff asserted that he adhered to confidentiality policies and actively trained sales staff about the "Last Look" system.
  • He contended that he had implemented supervisory controls and that many of the alleged failings were either inaccurate or predated his employment.
  • The Plaintiff claimed unfairness in the disciplinary process, including denial of access to relevant documents and inability to be accompanied due to suspension terms.
  • He submitted that the Defendant’s senior management approved his revenue-generating objectives related to "Last Look," negating claims of misconduct.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The Defendant contended that the Plaintiff was dismissed for misconduct related to fostering a non-transparent culture, misuse of "Last Look," failure to implement controls, and inadequate supervision.
  • It asserted that the decision-makers held an honest belief based on reasonable grounds supported by an adequate investigation.
  • The Defendant maintained that the disciplinary and appeal officers acted independently and based their decisions on evidence, not solely on the DFS Order.
  • The Defendant argued the Plaintiff’s conduct breached internal policies, including confidentiality, supervisory responsibilities, and conduct codes.
  • The Defendant justified the dismissal as falling within the range of reasonable responses for serious misconduct.
  • It contended that some document requests by the Plaintiff were overly broad and that relevant disclosures were made as appropriate.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Abernethy v Mott Hay and Anderson [1974] ICR 323 Definition of a reason for dismissal as facts or beliefs causing dismissal Used to establish that the Defendant must show a potentially fair reason for dismissal
W Devis & Sons Ltd v Atkins [1977] AC 931 Approval of the definition of a reason for dismissal Supported the principle that an employer’s belief can constitute a reason for dismissal
British Home Stores Ltd v Burchell [1978] IRLR 379 Tests for fairness of dismissal for misconduct: honest belief, reasonable grounds, reasonable investigation Guided the Tribunal's assessment of whether the Defendant acted fairly in dismissing the Plaintiff
Post Office v Foley [2000] ICR 1283 Affirmation of Burchell test Reinforced the application of the Burchell principles in misconduct dismissals
Iceland Frozen Foods v Jones [1982] IRLR 439 Range of reasonable responses test Applied to determine if the Defendant’s dismissal decision was reasonable
Sainsbury’s Supermarkets v Hitt [2003] IRLR 23 Reasonableness of investigation and dismissal decision Used to evaluate the adequacy of the Defendant’s investigation and dismissal process
A v B [2003] IRLR 405 Impact of delay on fairness of dismissal Considered in assessing procedural fairness related to timing and investigation
Turner v East Midlands Trains Limited [2013] IRLR 107 Expectation of reasonable employer in serious misconduct cases Informed the Tribunal’s approach to the scope of investigation given the gravity of allegations
Morgan v Electrolux Ltd [1991] IRLR 89 Tribunal’s role is not to substitute its own view but to assess employer’s reasonableness Guided the Tribunal in deferring to the Defendant’s reasonable decision-making
London Ambulance Service NHS Trust v Small [2009] IRLR 563 Similar principle on fairness and reasonableness of dismissal Supported the Tribunal’s approach to employer decision evaluation
Ladbroke Racing Limited v Arnott [1983] IRLR 154 Dismissal for breach of company rule must be reasonable Used to assess whether dismissal was a reasonable response to alleged breaches
Donachie v Allied Suppliers Limited EAT 46/80 Unawareness of contractual term can render dismissal unreasonable Considered in evaluating Plaintiff’s knowledge of policies and rules
Bishop v Graham Group plc EAT 800/98 Misconduct must be serious, wilful, and obvious to justify dismissal Applied in assessing whether the Plaintiff’s conduct warranted dismissal
Polkey v AE Dayton Services Limited [1988] Reduction of award where dismissal would have occurred anyway Guided the Tribunal’s decision on compensatory award reduction
Gover v Propertycare Limited [2006] ICR 1073 Polkey principle applies even if dismissal reason is valid but procedure unfair Supported consideration of Polkey reduction despite unfair dismissal finding
Optikinetics Limited v Whooley [1999] ICR 984 Obligation to reduce award where contributory fault found Informed the Tribunal’s approach to contributory fault and award adjustment
Nelson v BBC (No 2) [1980] ICR 110 Criteria for contributory conduct reduction Applied in assessing contributory fault by the Plaintiff

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Tribunal carefully examined the evidence, including witness testimonies, documentary evidence, emails, and disciplinary records. The Tribunal considered the Defendant’s internal policies, the Plaintiff’s role and responsibilities, and the regulatory context, including the DFS Order. It applied established legal tests for unfair dismissal, notably the Burchell test, to assess whether the Defendant had an honest belief in the Plaintiff’s misconduct based on reasonable grounds and a fair investigation.

The Tribunal found contradictions and procedural unfairness in how the Defendant handled disclosure of relevant documents, notably the failure to provide the Plaintiff with key evidence such as the subpoena response spreadsheet and documents related to the implementation of "Last Look" symmetry. These failures undermined the Plaintiff’s ability to properly defend himself and rendered the disciplinary process unfair.

The Tribunal distinguished between the Plaintiff’s confidentiality obligations regarding two different "Last Look" systems (BARX and BATS). It concluded that the Plaintiff had reasonable grounds to maintain confidentiality about certain aspects, particularly BATS Last Look, and that the Defendant lacked reasonable grounds to find misconduct related to BARX Last Look transparency.

Regarding allegations of indiscriminate application of Last Look and failure to implement controls, the Tribunal accepted the Plaintiff’s evidence that senior management had approved revenue-generating objectives related to Last Look and that the Plaintiff had implemented supervisory controls. The Tribunal found that the Defendant’s decision to dismiss was outside the band of reasonable responses, particularly given the lack of evidence of unfair client treatment and the Plaintiff’s partial responsibility for controls.

The Tribunal also found the Defendant’s disciplinary officers conducted their decision-making independently and on the evidence before them, despite the existence of the DFS Order. However, the procedural unfairness and substantive deficiencies in the Defendant’s case rendered the dismissal unfair.

Finally, the Tribunal found that the Plaintiff contributed to his dismissal to a limited extent (20%) due to some supervisory failings related to risk management, warranting a reduction in compensation.

Holding and Implications

The Employment Tribunal held that the Defendant unfairly dismissed the Plaintiff.

The Tribunal ordered a 20% reduction in the Plaintiff’s basic and compensatory awards to reflect contributory fault relating to supervisory failings. The Tribunal did not accept that the dismissal was justified solely by the DFS Order or that the Plaintiff’s conduct met the threshold for gross misconduct warranting dismissal. The decision underscores the importance of procedural fairness, reasonable disclosure, and evidential sufficiency in disciplinary dismissals, especially where regulatory and reputational risks are involved. No new legal precedent was established; the ruling applied established principles of unfair dismissal law to the facts.