- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
The Queen's Club Ltd v Revenue and Customs (VAT - INPUT TAX : Partial exemption)
Factual and Procedural Background
The Appellant, a well-known members sports club (the Club), provides both exempt sporting services and taxable supplies such as food and drink sales in its bars and restaurants. The Club undertook refurbishment works on parts of its premises, specifically upgrading a caf into a full-service restaurant and connecting bars, aiming to increase usage and revenue. The Club incurred VAT on goods and services related to this refurbishment and claimed a full input tax credit, asserting these costs were wholly attributable to taxable supplies. The Respondent (HM Revenue & Customs) disputed this, contending that the input tax should be apportioned under the Club’s partial exemption method, as the costs related to both taxable and exempt supplies. The dispute concerns the principle of whether the input tax is attributable solely to taxable supplies or to both taxable and exempt supplies. The Tribunal was asked to decide this principle, with the parties agreeing to settle quantum later based on the Tribunal’s ruling.
The Club’s evidence included testimony from its finance director, who was found reliable. The Respondent did not present witness evidence. Both parties submitted documentary bundles. The Club’s premises consist of four adjacent buildings and the refurbishment focused on one building’s first floor, creating a continuous hospitality space. The Club has not waived VAT exemption on this building. The Club’s primary revenue is from membership fees, considered exempt supplies, while sales in bars and restaurants are taxable supplies. The Club does not have a contractual obligation to provide access to bars or restaurants to members, and most members primarily use the Club for sporting activities. There was a lengthy waiting list for membership, and membership fees increased during refurbishment, despite inconvenience to members.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the input tax incurred on refurbishment goods and services is wholly attributable to taxable supplies made by the Club.
- Whether there is a direct and immediate link between the refurbishment input tax and exempt supplies made by the Club, affecting entitlement to input tax credit.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The refurbishment input tax is wholly attributable to taxable supplies, specifically the Club’s bars and restaurant operations.
- The Club is under no contractual obligation to provide access to bars or restaurants, and most members do not use these facilities.
- The primary supply to members is exempt sporting services, and the refurbishment does not have a direct and immediate link with exempt membership supplies.
- The economic use of the refurbishment goods and services is linked solely to taxable supplies, justifying full input tax recovery.
Respondent's Arguments
- The input tax should be apportioned because the refurbishment relates to both taxable and exempt supplies.
- There is a direct and immediate link between refurbishment and exempt supplies, including membership fees and the Club’s hire of bars and restaurant to members.
- The benefit members receive from exclusive access to the refurbished facilities supports a link to exempt supplies.
- The Club may have a contractual obligation to maintain bars and restaurants once offered.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| BLP Group v Customs and Excise Commissioners [1995] STC 424 (C-4/94) | Goods or services must have a direct and immediate link with taxable transactions for input tax deduction. | The Tribunal applied the objective test of direct and immediate link, emphasizing that subjective intention is irrelevant. |
| Midland Bank v Customs and Excise Commissioners (C-98/8) | Input tax deduction requires expenditure to be a cost component of taxable supplies. | The Tribunal held that input tax relates to costs of output taxable transactions and must arise before those transactions. |
| St Helen's School Northwood Limited v HMRC [2006] EWHC 3306 (Ch) | Economic use, not physical use, determines the link between input tax and supplies. | The Tribunal adopted the approach of assessing economic use to determine if input tax relates to exempt supplies. |
| Dial-A-Phone Limited v Commissioners of Customs & Excise [2004] EWCA Civ 603 | A sufficient direct and immediate link with exempt supplies can exist even if the link with taxable supplies is closer. | The Tribunal clarified that the existence of a link to exempt supplies must still be direct and immediate, not diluted by closer links elsewhere. |
| Customs & Excise Commissioners v Southern Primary Housing Association Ltd [2003] EWCA Civ 1662 | Link to exempt supplies is not the same as asking if exempt supplies could have been made but for the input. | The Tribunal distinguished the test as requiring a direct and immediate link, not a hypothetical causation. |
| Bridgnorth Golf Club v Revenue & Customs [2009] UKFTT 126 (TC) | Input tax recovery on refurbishments limited where clubhouse is integral to exempt supplies. | The Tribunal found this precedent distinguishable due to different club structure and contractual obligations. |
| Bedale Golf Club Limited v Revenue & Customs [2015] UKFTT 446 (TC) | Similar to Bridgnorth Golf Club, input tax recovery related to clubhouse refurbishment limited. | Distinguished on facts; the Club’s multiple buildings and discretionary provision of facilities differ materially. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Tribunal began by outlining the statutory framework under the Principal VAT Directive and UK VAT law, emphasizing that input tax is deductible only if goods or services have a direct and immediate link to taxable supplies. The Court referenced established case law clarifying that this link must be determined objectively, focusing on economic use rather than subjective intention or physical use.
The Tribunal rejected the Respondent’s argument that the refurbishment input tax related to exempt supplies, specifically membership fees and the hiring out of bars and restaurants to members. It found no contractual obligation binding the Club to provide access to bars or restaurants, and noted that most members did not use these facilities. The Club’s primary supply was access to sporting facilities, which are exempt supplies, but the refurbishment was not directly linked to these exempt supplies.
The Tribunal also rejected the proposition that the Club’s provision of catering services when hiring out bars and restaurants to members constituted exempt supplies, finding these to be taxable supplies instead.
Considering the evidence, including the Club’s substantial waiting list, unchanged or increased membership fees during refurbishment, and the discretionary nature of social facilities, the Tribunal concluded that the refurbishment did not influence members’ decisions to join or renew membership. Therefore, there was no direct and immediate link between the refurbishment input tax and exempt supplies.
By contrast, the Tribunal found a clear direct and immediate link between the refurbishment input tax and taxable supplies made in the bars and restaurant. It distinguished previous Tribunal decisions involving golf clubs with single clubhouses, noting the different factual matrix here.
Holding and Implications
The Tribunal held that the Appellant is entitled to recover the full amount of input tax incurred on the refurbishment works, as these costs are wholly attributable to taxable supplies.
HOLDING: The appeal is allowed, and full input tax credit is granted.
The parties were directed to agree on the quantum of input tax to be recovered within 56 days, with the Tribunal reserving the right to issue further directions if agreement is not reached. The decision clarifies the application of the direct and immediate link test in the context of sports clubs with multiple buildings and discretionary social facilities, but does not establish new precedent beyond the facts of this case.
Alert