- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
REGINA v Herrington
Factual and Procedural Background
On 1st March 2017, His Honour Judge Batty QC sentenced the Appellant to 12 months' imprisonment and imposed a restraining order under section 5 of the Protection from Harassment Act 1997, restraining him from contacting the Appellee for three years. The Appellant appealed the restraining order only, with all other orders, including the prison sentence, remaining unaffected.
The Appellant and the Appellee had cohabited for several years and had a three-year-old child. The Appellant has a lengthy criminal record with 36 convictions for 97 offences, including violence, arson, and possession of weapons, as well as multiple breaches of court orders.
On 24th November 2015, the Appellant was sentenced to 11 months' imprisonment for assault occasioning actual bodily harm and criminal damage against the Appellee, with an additional suspended sentence running consecutively. Prior to his release in early February 2017, the Appellee obtained a non-molestation order from the County Court for her protection, which lapsed after she did not seek its renewal.
Hours after his release on 6th February 2017, the Appellant committed three offences: assaulting the Appellee, assaulting a bystander (the bus station manager), and breaching the non-molestation order. He was subsequently arrested and returned to prison.
At sentencing, the judge considered a probation service email assessing the Appellant as high risk to the Appellee, staff, public, and children, noting the Appellant's unwillingness to engage with probation and the absence of a current non-molestation order. The judge imposed a three-year restraining order prohibiting contact between the Appellant and the Appellee except through probation intervention.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the restraining order under section 5 of the Protection from Harassment Act 1997 was lawfully imposed despite the Appellee's expressed wish to continue the relationship with the Appellant.
- Whether the criminal court has jurisdiction to impose a restraining order to protect a victim who freely chooses to maintain a relationship with a violent partner.
- The appropriateness of the restraining order in light of risks to the child and probation service staff, and the proper forum for addressing those risks.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The judge erred in law by imposing the restraining order without proper regard to the Appellee's wishes.
- The relevant authorities, including R v Picken and R v Brown, establish that a restraining order should not be imposed if the victim, who has capacity and is not coerced, wishes to continue the relationship.
Prosecution's Position
- The prosecution noted that usually the complainant must instigate a restraining order, but the Appellee refused to make a statement and supported the Appellant in court.
- Despite this, the judge proceeded to impose the restraining order based on risk assessments.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| R v Picken [2006] EWCA Crim 2194 | Limits on restraining orders where the victim wishes to continue the relationship | Referenced to support that restraining orders should not override the autonomy of an adult victim wishing to maintain contact |
| R v Brown [2012] EWCA Crim 1152 | Restraining orders should not be imposed when the victim is a competent adult who chooses to maintain the relationship | Quoted to emphasize that the victim’s free will precludes the imposition of a restraining order |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court acknowledged the serious risk posed by the Appellant to the Appellee, the child, probation staff, and the public. However, it emphasized the legal principle that an adult victim with capacity has the right to decide whether to maintain a relationship, even if it is with a violent partner. The court held that the criminal jurisdiction cannot be used to override this autonomy by imposing a restraining order against the victim's wishes.
Regarding the child, the court recognized the potential need for protection but determined that the criminal court is not the appropriate forum to make decisions about child welfare and parental communication. Such matters require a family court with the capacity to consider expert evidence and balance the child's best interests.
Concerning the probation service’s safety concerns, the court noted that specific protective orders could be sought by probation through appropriate legal channels but that these cannot be achieved indirectly by separating the Appellant and the Appellee.
The court also noted that the restraining order was made without the complainant’s instigation and was based on the judge’s concerns informed by a probation report. Nonetheless, the legal principles and the Appellee’s wishes rendered the order inappropriate.
Holding and Implications
The appeal was allowed in part, and the restraining order was QUASHED. All other orders, including the prison sentence, remain in force.
The decision confirms that criminal courts cannot impose restraining orders to prevent an adult victim from maintaining a relationship with a violent partner if the victim has capacity and freely chooses to do so. Protection of children and staff must be pursued through appropriate family or civil court proceedings. No new precedent was established beyond affirming existing legal principles limiting the scope of restraining orders in such contexts.
Alert