Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

RK, R (on the application of) v Secretary of State for the Home Department (s.117B(6); "parental relationship" (IJR)

Upper Tribunal (Immigration and Asylum Chamber)
Dec 22, 2015
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The Applicant, a citizen of India born in 1957, challenges three decisions of the Respondent Secretary of State for the Home Department refusing to grant her leave to remain in the United Kingdom outside the Immigration Rules under Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights. The Applicant contends that her removal would breach Article 8 because she has a "parental relationship" with her three grandchildren who live in the UK with their parents, the Applicant's son and daughter-in-law. The daughter-in-law suffers from serious health conditions, including multiple sclerosis and lupus, which affect her ability to care for the children.

The Applicant initially entered the UK as a visitor in 2002 and subsequently applied multiple times for leave to remain as a carer outside the Rules. While discretionary leave was granted for limited periods, later applications were refused, and the Applicant became an overstayer. Following refusals of leave under Article 8, judicial review proceedings were initiated, with permission granted after an oral hearing on the ground that the Respondent had failed to properly consider the grandchildren's best interests under section 55 of the Borders, Citizenship and Immigration Act 2009.

The Applicant later sought to amend her grounds to include a claim that she had a "genuine and subsisting parental relationship" with her grandchildren under section 117B(6) of the Nationality, Immigration and Asylum Act 2002. The Respondent issued supplementary decisions addressing the best interests of the grandchildren and the parental relationship issue. The substantive hearing was adjourned to allow amendment of grounds, and the present judicial review concerns the lawfulness of the Respondent's decisions on these grounds.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Applicant has a "genuine and subsisting parental relationship" with her grandchildren within the meaning of section 117B(6) of the Nationality, Immigration and Asylum Act 2002, such that the public interest does not require her removal.
  2. Whether the Respondent lawfully fulfilled her duty under section 55 of the Borders, Citizenship and Immigration Act 2009 to have regard to the best interests of the grandchildren in deciding the Applicant's leave to remain.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The Applicant argued that it is not necessary to have legal parental responsibility to establish a parental relationship; it depends on the role played in the child's life.
  • She submitted that she had day-to-day responsibility for the grandchildren and had effectively taken on a parental role, supported by evidence of close emotional ties and dependency, especially regarding one grandchild with a history of anxiety and self-harm.
  • She relied on guidance that more than two individuals can be in a parental relationship in exceptional circumstances and contended that she was effectively a third parent involved in the grandchildren's upbringing.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The Respondent relied on guidance indicating that generally only two people can have a parental relationship with a child, typically the biological parents or a step-parent where one biological parent is absent.
  • It was submitted that the Applicant, while playing a supportive and caregiving role, did so as a grandmother and not as a parent, given that both biological parents reside with the children and maintain parental responsibility.
  • The Respondent argued that the Applicant was not a de facto primary carer nor involved in making significant decisions for the grandchildren, and the Applicant's immigration history and overstaying status weighed heavily in favor of removal.
  • Regarding the section 55 duty, the Respondent submitted that the best interests of the children had been carefully considered, including the mental health issues of one grandchild, and that support was available within the UK if needed.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Dube (SS.117A-117D) [2015] UKUT 90 (IAC) Application of Part 5A of the Nationality, Immigration and Asylum Act 2002 as good administration by the Secretary of State. Accepted by both parties and applied by the court to interpret the relevant statutory provisions.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court first considered the statutory framework under section 117B(6) of the Nationality, Immigration and Asylum Act 2002, which provides that removal is not required in the public interest if the person has a genuine and subsisting parental relationship with a qualifying child who cannot reasonably be expected to leave the UK. The statute does not define "genuine and subsisting parental relationship," so the court examined relevant guidance and the facts.

The court noted that the guidance accepts that more than two people may have a parental relationship in exceptional cases, but generally only two individuals – usually the biological parents or a step-parent in certain circumstances – qualify. The court emphasized that a parental relationship involves "stepping into the shoes of a parent," including making parental decisions and fulfilling emotional and physical caregiving roles in place of the biological parent(s).

Applying this to the facts, the court found that although the Applicant provided significant day-to-day care and support to her grandchildren due to the daughter-in-law's health, both biological parents remained present, involved, and responsible for the children. The Applicant did not have parental responsibility nor was she involved in major decisions affecting the children. The court concluded that the Applicant's role was that of a grandmother, not a parent, and thus she did not have a "parental relationship" within the meaning of section 117B(6).

Regarding the duty under section 55 of the Borders, Citizenship and Immigration Act 2009, the court found that the Respondent had thoroughly considered the children's best interests, including mental health concerns of one grandchild, and took into account available support services. The court held that the Respondent's assessment was rational and lawful.

The court also declined to consider a third ground relating to the Respondent's removal decision policy, as the Applicant did not pursue it upon failing on the principal grounds.

Holding and Implications

The claim for judicial review is dismissed.

The court upheld the Respondent's decisions refusing the Applicant leave to remain outside the Immigration Rules. The Applicant was found not to have a "genuine and subsisting parental relationship" with her grandchildren under section 117B(6) of the Nationality, Immigration and Asylum Act 2002, and the Respondent lawfully fulfilled her duty under section 55 of the Borders, Citizenship and Immigration Act 2009 to consider the children's best interests. The decision means the Applicant's removal from the UK is lawful. No new precedent was established beyond the application of existing statutory guidance and principles to the facts of this case.