- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Robertson v Forth Road Bridge Joint Board
Factual and Procedural Background
The case concerns claims by two employees, referred to as the Pursuers, who alleged they suffered nervous shock (psychiatric illness) as a result of witnessing a fatal accident involving a fellow employee, the Deceased. The accident occurred during a joint task of removing a metal sheet obstructing a bridge carriageway. The Pursuers were present at the time: one was driving the vehicle from which the Deceased was thrown by a sudden gust of wind, and the other witnessed the accident from a nearby van. The Deceased died after being thrown from the vehicle. The Pursuers sought damages for psychiatric injury caused by witnessing the accident.
The Lord Ordinary initially held that no duty of care arose towards the Pursuers in respect of psychiatric injury caused by witnessing the accident and dismissed their claims. The Pursuers appealed this decision. The appeals were heard together, and this opinion addresses both actions collectively.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the employer owed a duty of care to the Pursuers, as employees witnessing the accident to a fellow employee, to avoid causing them psychiatric injury.
- Whether the Pursuers fall within the class of persons to whom a duty of care for psychiatric injury arising from nervous shock is owed, given their relationship to the Deceased and their presence at the accident.
- Whether the employment relationship and joint engagement in the task of removing the obstruction suffices to establish proximity and foreseeability for recovery of damages for psychiatric injury.
- Whether the Pursuers’ psychiatric illnesses were caused by the accident and whether they were directly involved in causing the accident or merely witnesses.
Arguments of the Parties
Pursuers' Arguments
- The Pursuers contended that as employees engaged in the same task as the Deceased at the time of the accident, they were within the ambit of the employer’s duty of care.
- They argued that the duty owed to employees for physical injury should extend to psychiatric injury caused by witnessing an accident during joint employment activities.
- The Pursuers likened their position to that of rescuers, who are recognized as within the duty of care even without risk to their own safety or close familial ties.
- They submitted that the Lord Ordinary erred by requiring proof of close ties of love and affection as a prerequisite for recovery for psychiatric injury.
Defenders' Arguments
- The Defenders argued that the duty of care for psychiatric injury is distinct and limited by policy considerations, requiring close ties of love and affection or direct involvement in causing the injury.
- They submitted that the Pursuers were merely witnesses and not participants in the accident, thus falling outside recognized classes entitled to recover for psychiatric harm.
- The employment relationship alone does not extend the class of persons owed a duty of care for psychiatric injury caused indirectly by injury to another employee.
- The Defenders emphasized that the Pursuers failed to demonstrate their psychiatric illness was caused by witnessing the accident or by participation in it, or that the accident was so horrific as to cause foreseeable psychiatric injury to a person of ordinary fortitude.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| McLoughlin v O'Brian | Recognition of claims for psychiatric illness caused by witnessing injury; limits based on class of persons, proximity, and means of shock. | Confirmed that psychiatric injury is a legitimate claim but emphasized the need for limitations such as close relationship or direct involvement. |
| Bourhill v Young | Duty of care includes injury by shock; driver entitled to assume ordinary fortitude of bystanders. | Applied to restrict claims by bystanders without close ties or direct involvement, emphasizing normal fortitude assumption. |
| Alcock v Chief Constable of South Yorkshire Police | Requirement of proximity and close ties for duty of care in psychiatric injury cases; reasonable foreseeability as guide. | Held Pursuers not within recognized class owing to lack of close emotional ties or participation; employer-employee relationship insufficient alone. |
| Donoghue v Stevenson | Duty of care owed to persons closely and directly affected by defendant's acts; test of reasonable foreseeability. | Applied to determine if employer should have reasonably foreseen injury to Pursuers; proximity was not established for psychiatric injury claims. |
| Chadwick v British Railways Board | Rescuers may recover for psychiatric injury even without risk to self or close familial ties. | Distinguished from Pursuers who were mere witnesses, not rescuers or participants. |
| Yates v South Kirkby etc Collieries Ltd | Nervous shock causing incapacity to work recognized as personal injury under Workmen's Compensation Act. | Not considered directly applicable to common law duty of care for psychiatric injury in employment context. |
| Dooley v Cammell Laird & Co and Mersey Insulation Co Ltd | Duty of care recognized where plaintiff involuntarily caused injury to another and suffered psychiatric illness. | Used to illustrate that participation or perceived responsibility is essential for duty of care in psychiatric injury claims at work. |
| Mount Isa Mines Ltd v Pusey | Employer-employee relationship and nervous shock; case involved rescuer-type circumstances. | Dicta suggesting employer-employee relationship alone may suffice not relied upon; case distinguished. |
| McFarlane v EE Caledonia Ltd | Claim by bystander or witness to a horrific event refused absent close ties or participation. | Supported refusal of claims by employees who were mere witnesses without close ties or participation. |
| Attia v British Gas plc | Claim for nervous shock due to witnessing property damage recognized to proceed to trial. | Not considered significant for current case; no comment in leading authority. |
| Dillon v British Railways Board | Claims by employees who involuntarily caused injury to others recognized for psychiatric illness. | Distinguished from Pursuers who did not cause or think they caused the accident. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court acknowledged that claims for psychiatric illness caused by witnessing injury are legitimate but subject to important limitations. The key elements are the class of persons entitled to claim, proximity to the accident, and the means by which the shock is caused.
The Pursuers were unquestionably present and witnessed the accident, satisfying proximity in time and place. However, the court found they were mere witnesses and not participants or rescuers. They did not cause, nor believe they caused, the accident. Their relationship with the Deceased, though collegial, lacked the close emotional ties (love and affection) recognized in precedent as necessary to extend the duty of care for psychiatric injury.
The court considered the employer-employee relationship but concluded that this alone does not extend the class of persons to whom a duty of care for psychiatric injury is owed beyond recognized categories. The law assumes employees possess normal fortitude to withstand witnessing accidents to colleagues.
Authorities cited by the Pursuers, including early workers' compensation cases, did not establish a common law duty of care for psychiatric injury in this context. Cases involving rescuers or those who involuntarily caused injury to others were distinguished as involving a different category of claimants.
The court also noted the policy concerns of unlimited liability if claims by mere witnesses within employment were allowed. The absence of evidence linking the Pursuers’ psychiatric illness causally to participation or a belief of responsibility for the accident further undermined their claim.
Accordingly, the court upheld the Lord Ordinary's decision that the Defenders did not owe a duty of care to the Pursuers for psychiatric injury arising solely from witnessing the accident.
Holding and Implications
The court REFUSED the reclaiming motions and upheld the interlocutors of the Lord Ordinary, dismissing the Pursuers' claims for damages for psychiatric illness caused by witnessing the fatal accident.
The direct effect is that the employer is not liable for psychiatric injury to employees who are mere witnesses to accidents involving fellow employees absent close emotional ties, participation in causing the accident, or rescuer status. No new precedent was established; rather, existing principles limiting recovery for psychiatric injury claims were reaffirmed and applied strictly to the facts of this case.
Alert