- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Henry Boot Construction Ltd v. Alstom Combined Cycles Ltd (formerly GEC Alsthom Combined Cycles Ltd)
Factual and Procedural Background
The Plaintiff, Company A, appealed by leave granted under section 1 of the Arbitration Act 1979 against an arbitrator's award in an arbitration with the Defendant, Company B. The arbitration arose from civil engineering works undertaken by Company A for Company B, who was constructing a combined cycle gas turbine power station for a third party at a site in The City, The State. The contract incorporated the ICE Conditions of Contract, 6th edition, with immaterial amendments. The contract included a price of 250,880 for certain temporary works.
The arbitrator determined that the price of 250,880 was mistakenly arrived at and therefore it was unreasonable to use this figure as a basis to value increases in temporary works under clauses 55 and 51 of the ICE Conditions, which required valuation under clause 52(1)(b). Consequently, the arbitrator made a valuation not based on the disputed price.
Company A contended that it was incorrect not to make a valuation under clause 52(1)(b) based on a rate or price, even if it contained or was based on a mistake, or that it was not feasible to value based on the contractor’s information, considering clauses 11(3)(b) and 55(2). Company B argued that the arbitrator's decision was justifiable also under the Civil Engineering Standard Method of Measurement (CESMM), clauses 56 and 57, and clause 52(2) of the ICE Conditions.
The appeal was allowed. The award was remitted to the arbitrator for reconsideration. Company B was ordered to pay Company A’s costs. A certificate was granted pursuant to section 1(7)(b) of the Arbitration Act 1979 for the legal question raised by Company A's appeal, and leave to appeal was given in respect of this question.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether it was correct not to make a valuation under clause 52(1)(b) of the ICE Conditions based on a rate or price that was mistakenly arrived at.
- Whether it was reasonable or feasible to use a rate or price containing or based upon a mistake for valuation purposes under the contract.
- Whether the price of 250,880 constituted a "price in the Bill of Quantities" for the purposes of clause 52(1)(b) and related contractual provisions.
- Whether the arbitrator’s valuation approach was consistent with the Civil Engineering Standard Method of Measurement and relevant contract clauses.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The arbitrator was wrong not to make a valuation under clause 52(1)(b) based on the rate or price, even if it contained a mistake.
- It was not reasonable to refuse to use the rate or price on grounds that it contained or was based on a mistake or that the contractor’s information was insufficient.
- The contract and its clauses, including 11(3)(b) and 55(2), supported valuation based on the rate or price.
Respondent's Arguments
- The arbitrator’s decision was justifiable under the Civil Engineering Standard Method of Measurement (second edition, 1985), particularly clauses 56 and 57.
- The price of 250,880 was not a "price in the Bill of Quantities" as defined in the contract and thus was not appropriate for valuation under clause 52(1)(b).
- Even if treated as part of the Bill of Quantities, the price was not suitable as a basis for valuation because CESMM could not be applied.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court analysed the contract documents, including the ICE Conditions of Contract 6th edition and the Civil Engineering Standard Method of Measurement (CESMM), to determine the proper application of valuation rules for variations.
The court found that the sum of 250,880 was a "price" inserted into the contract as part of the Bill of Quantities, modified by post-tender exchanges of correspondence, and thus formed part of the contract's scope and valuation framework.
The court accepted the arbitrator's finding that the price was mistakenly calculated and concluded that it was unreasonable to extend the ambit of this flawed price to value other works by extracting rates or modifying it. The court agreed with the arbitrator that neither Rule 1 (valuation by rates/prices for similar work) nor Rule 2 (modified valuation where work is different) under clause 52(1)(b) applied given the mistake in the original price.
The court emphasised that the contract contemplates valuation based on contract rates or prices unless it is not reasonable or feasible to do so, and that mistakes in rates or prices generally bind the parties once the contract is made.
Further, the court noted that the CESMM and contract clauses provide mechanisms for the Engineer or arbitrator to establish new rates ("star rates") when necessary, but the lack of detailed information in this case hindered such an exercise.
Ultimately, the court concluded that the arbitrator was entitled to make a valuation pursuant to clause 52(1)(b) on the basis of the price of 250,880 for the temporary works, despite the original mistake, by remitting the award for reconsideration accordingly.
Holding and Implications
The court's holding was that the appeal should be allowed and the award remitted to the arbitrator with directions to make a valuation pursuant to clause 52(1)(b) of the ICE Conditions based on the price of 250,880 for the additional and temporary sheet piling works.
DISPOSED OF
This decision requires the arbitrator to reassess the valuation using the contract price despite the mistake, ensuring the valuation aligns with contractual principles and the agreed terms. No new legal precedent was established; the ruling applies the contract terms and established valuation principles to the facts of this case.
Alert