- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Walker Trustees v. Lord Advocate and Others
Factual and Procedural Background
The case concerns the ancient Scottish heritable office known as the Usher of the White Rod. Before the Treaty of Union of 1707, the holder of this office was entitled to charge fixed fees to every person upon whom the Sovereign of Scotland conferred an honour or dignity. From 1766 until 1904, successive holders also demanded and received the same fees from recipients of honours of the United Kingdom, even though those honours were granted under the Great Seal of the United Kingdom rather than under the Great Seal of Scotland.
The Respondents, a body of trustees incorporated by a private Act of Parliament in 1877 and now proprietors of the office, brought an action in the Court of Session to establish their right to these charges. The defenders consisted of several recent recipients of United Kingdom honours resident in Scotland and the Lord Advocate, representing the Crown. The Second Division of the Court of Session upheld the Respondents’ claim. The Lord Advocate and the other defenders (collectively, the Appellants) appealed to the House of Lords. The present opinion records the judgment of the House of Lords delivered on 7 July 1910.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether Article 20 of the Treaty of Union, preserving “heritable offices … as rights of property… in the same manner as they are now enjoyed,” entitles the Usher of the White Rod to charge fees on honours and dignities of the United Kingdom created after 1707, or limits the right to fees on purely Scottish honours that existed before the Union.
- Whether a uniform practice of paying the fees from 1766 to 1904 can influence or modify the interpretation of Article 20 and the earlier Scottish charters when those instruments are otherwise clear and unambiguous.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellants’ Arguments
- Article 20 is explicit: it merely preserves the rights attached to the office as they existed at the Union; it does not enlarge them to cover honours of the United Kingdom created thereafter.
- The relevant seventeenth-century Scottish charters refer only to honours conferred by the Sovereign of Scotland and therefore cannot extend to United Kingdom honours.
- Customary payments made after 1766 cannot override or modify unambiguous statutory language; longstanding usage is irrelevant against “plain statutory law.”
Respondents’ Arguments
- The sweeping language in the pre-Union charters—especially references to fees payable by “all Scotsmen within His Majesty’s dominions”—is broad enough to include fees on United Kingdom honours.
- The uninterrupted practice of charging such fees for more than 150 years shows a contemporaneous and continuous exposition that should guide the court’s interpretation.
- Because the office is a heritable property, Article 20 should be construed so as to preserve all emoluments historically enjoyed, including those flowing from United Kingdom honours.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court’s Reasoning and Analysis
Judge Atkinson, delivering the principal opinion, undertook a detailed examination of the seventeenth-century Scottish charters (notably those of 1647 and 1674) and the Acts of the Scottish Parliament that ratified them. He concluded:
- The documents dealt exclusively with honours that the monarch could confer qua Sovereign of Scotland. They neither mention the Great Seals of England or Ireland nor rely on legislation outside Scotland.
- At the time of the Union, the Usher’s rights were limited to (a) fees from any Scotsman receiving a Scottish honour anywhere within the monarch’s dominions, and (b) fees from any Englishman who received a Scottish honour while physically in Scotland.
- Article 20 of the Treaty of Union preserved those rights “as property” but did not enlarge them. The absence of any power to create new Scottish peerages after 1707 merely rendered the office less profitable; it did not transform United Kingdom honours into Scottish honours.
- The language of Article 20 and the earlier charters is “plain and unambiguous.” Usage—even if established for 150 years—cannot prevail against a clear statutory provision.
- Honours of the United Kingdom created after 1707 are “wholly different” from Scottish honours and therefore fall outside the fee-earning scope of the office.
Judges Halsbury, Kinnear, and Gorell each expressly concurred with Judge Atkinson’s analysis without adding separate reasons.
Holding and Implications
The House of Lords REVERSED the judgment of the Second Division and allowed the appeal with costs.
Directly, the decision bars the Respondents from recovering fees from recipients of post-Union United Kingdom honours; only fees linked to pre-Union Scottish honours survive. The ruling confirms that clear statutory language in the Treaty of Union cannot be expanded by long usage, but it sets no broader precedent beyond the immediate context of this unique heritable office.
Alert