- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
FAI General Insurance Company Ltd. v Godfrey Merrett Robertson Ltd & Ors
Factual and Procedural Background
This appeal arises from a decision of Mr Justice Walker refusing applications made by the Appellant, Company A, to inspect and/or take copies of various documents referred to in open court and taken as read during a trial to which Company A was not a party. Company A is a defendant in separate proceedings brought by Company B, seeking recovery under contracts of reinsurance entered into in the early 1990s, which Company A seeks to avoid on grounds of misrepresentation and non-disclosure.
The trial before Walker J concerned avoidance of reinsurance contracts by the plaintiffs, an Australian reinsurer, against another reinsured party. The same chain of brokers was involved in both the present trial and the separate litigation involving Company A and Company B. The trial involved claims by a head broker (the effective plaintiff) against sub-brokers who did not appear. Prior to and during the trial, Company A sought access to trial documents, including skeleton arguments, trial bundles, reading lists, and witness lists, but these requests were refused.
Company A's solicitors made repeated requests for these documents, citing procedural rules and the principle that the implied undertaking on discovery ceases once a document is referred to at trial. After no compliance, Company A issued a summons to inspect these materials. Walker J rejected the application, finding that Company A's true motive was to obtain documents for use in other litigation rather than for public interest or understanding of the trial.
Company A supplemented their application during the hearing for inspection of witness statements ordered to stand as evidence in chief, which was allowed. On appeal, Company A limited their request to specific categories of documents: certain witness-related documents, written opening skeleton arguments, and documents referred to therein or on the judge’s reading list.
Company B opposed the application, arguing it was an attempt by a non-party to circumvent discovery rules and sought parity of access if any order was made. The court treated Company B effectively as a party to the appeal.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether a non-party to litigation is entitled to inspect and copy documents referred to or read by the trial judge during proceedings to which they are not a party, particularly written opening submissions and skeleton arguments.
- The scope and application of Order 38 Rule 2A relating to inspection of witness statements and whether it extends to documents referred to in those statements.
- The extent of the principle of open justice and public access to court materials, including the effect of documents being "in the public domain" by reference in open court.
- The exercise of the court’s inherent jurisdiction to regulate its procedures to grant or refuse access to such documents.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- Relied on the principle of open justice and the public’s right to see and hear court proceedings, citing Scott v Scott and the recent decision in Hodgson v Imperial Tobacco Limited.
- Contended that refusal based on Company A’s commercial interests was improper, as many non-parties attend trials with legitimate but varied interests.
- Argued that modern case management practices, including written openings and skeleton arguments, limit public ability to follow trials unless access to such documents is granted.
- Submitted that documents read or referred to in court enter the public domain and are released from inter partes confidentiality under Order 24 rule 14A, entitling public access.
- Maintained that access to written openings and skeleton arguments is necessary for meaningful public understanding of trials.
Respondent's Arguments
- Asserted that the application was a deliberate attempt by a third party to circumvent discovery rules and the implied undertaking restricting use of disclosed documents.
- Submitted that if Company A were granted access, Company B should be granted equal access to the same materials.
- Contended that the application was procedurally defective and late, being made after judgment.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Scott v Scott [1913] AC 417 | Principle of open justice and public access to court proceedings. | Supported the principle that publicity is essential to judicial accountability and public confidence. |
| Hodgson v Imperial Tobacco Limited [1998] 1 WLR 1056 | Extension of open justice principles to pre-trial hearings and written submissions. | Referenced as recent authority supporting public access to court processes beyond oral hearings. |
| Home Office v Harman [1983] AC 280 | Definition of documents entering the public domain by being read or referred to in court. | Clarified that such documents lose inter partes confidentiality but do not automatically become public records accessible to all. |
| Donald v Hastings [1992] Ch 394 | Limits on public access to court files; distinction between public records and court files. | Confirmed that court files are maintained for proper conduct of proceedings and access by non-parties is restricted. |
| Robson v Hastings [1992] Ch 394 | Inspection and publication of documents filed in court and the need for leave to access non-public documents. | Emphasized that filing does not make documents generally available without leave. |
| Attorney-General v Leveller (1979) AC 440 | Open justice as safeguard against judicial arbitrariness and to maintain public confidence. | Supported the importance of publicity for judicial accountability. |
| Order 38 Rule 2A (Civil Procedure Rules) | Procedures for inspection of witness statements ordered to stand as evidence in chief. | Interpreted as allowing inspection only of witness statements themselves, not documents referred to therein. |
| Order 24 Rule 14A | Implied undertaking on discovery ceases when document is referred to at trial. | Confirmed that confidentiality is lost upon reference in court but does not create a general right of access to documents. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court examined the scope of Order 38 Rule 2A and found it strictly limits inspection rights to witness statements ordered to stand as evidence in chief, excluding documents referred to within those statements. The plain language and context of the rule do not empower the court to grant access to such documents to non-parties.
Regarding written openings and skeleton arguments, the court acknowledged the strong public interest in open justice and the tradition that court proceedings be accessible. It noted that modern case management practices, such as written openings and skeleton arguments read privately by judges, can limit public understanding if access to these documents is denied.
The court distinguished between documents forming part of the public record and those merely lodged with the court for administrative convenience, such as trial bundles and skeleton arguments. It emphasized that while documents referred to in open court lose inter partes confidentiality, this does not automatically grant the public a right of access to copies.
Applying the principle of open justice, the court held that members of the public who apply for written openings or skeleton arguments used in lieu of oral submissions are prima facie entitled to access, regardless of their underlying motive, provided it is legitimate. The court found the judge erred in denying access to these documents based on Company A's commercial interest.
However, the court upheld the refusal to grant access to documents referred to in those written submissions or on the judge’s reading list, as no sufficient grounds for such access were shown.
The court also addressed procedural objections, concluding that the timing and manner of Company A's application should not prejudice their rights, given the court’s invitation to apply later and the dismissal being on merits rather than procedure.
Finally, the court granted Company B equal access to the same written submissions and skeleton arguments, given their effective party status in the appeal.
Holding and Implications
The court ALLOWED THE APPEAL to the extent of ordering that Company A and Company B are entitled to inspect and make copies of the written opening submissions or skeleton arguments to which reference was made by the trial judge.
The court refused to extend access to documents referred to in those written submissions or included in the judge’s reading list. The decision clarifies the limited scope of public access to court documents lodged for trial use and confirms the court’s inherent jurisdiction to ensure the principle of open justice applies to written submissions used in lieu of oral openings.
No new precedent was set regarding access to documents beyond written openings and skeleton arguments, and the ruling primarily affects the parties involved by granting them access to certain materials to aid public understanding of the trial.
Alert