Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Chappell & Co Ltd v Nestle Co Ltd

United Kingdom House of Lords
Jun 18, 1959
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

Company D owned, and Company A exclusively licensed, the copyright in the musical work “Rockin’ Shoes.” Company C manufactured low-cost cellulose acetate records of the work and sold them to Company B, a confectionery manufacturer. Company B ran a nationwide promotion: any member of the public could obtain the record by sending a postal order for 1 s 6 d together with three chocolate wrappers from 6 d bars of Company B’s chocolate. Company C served a statutory notice under section 8 of the Copyright Act 1956 stating that the “ordinary retail selling price” of each record was 1 s 6 d. Company A contended that the notice was invalid and sued for copyright infringement. Judge Upjohn (first instance) granted an injunction in favour of Company A. The Court of Appeal (Judge Jenkins and Judge Ormerod, Judge Romer dissenting) reversed that decision. Company A appealed to the House of Lords, where the matter was treated as the final determination of the action.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Company B’s promotional distribution of records, requiring both cash and three chocolate wrappers, constituted a “sale by retail” covered by section 8 of the Copyright Act 1956.
  2. Whether, in that context, 1 s 6 d represented the “ordinary retail selling price” on which the statutory royalty should be calculated.
  3. Whether Company C’s notice under the Copyright Royalty System (Records) Regulations 1957 was valid and sufficient to trigger the statutory licence defence.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants’ Arguments

  • The transaction was not the type of retail sale contemplated by section 8 because part of the consideration consisted of three chocolate wrappers, which had promotional value for Company B.
  • Because the wrappers formed part of the consideration and were incapable of monetary valuation, there was no ascertainable “ordinary retail selling price,” rendering the statutory notice defective.
  • Consequently, the Respondents could not rely on section 8 and their manufacture and distribution of the records infringed copyright.

Respondents’ Arguments

  • The wrappers were valueless and merely a qualification to purchase; the true price was the 1 s 6 d paid in cash, making the transaction an ordinary retail sale.
  • The notice accurately stated that price and therefore complied with section 8 and the Regulations; royalties calculated on 1 s 6 d satisfied the Act.
  • All statutory conditions having been met, no infringement occurred.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Law Lords divided sharply:

  • Majority (Judge Reid, Judge Tucker, Judge Somervell).
    • Held that the wrappers formed part of the consideration for each record; consumers had to acquire (and often purchase) chocolate solely to obtain the wrappers, conferring a direct promotional benefit on Company B.
    • Because the consideration was partly non-monetary, there was no single, ascertainable “ordinary retail selling price.”
    • The statutory notice, which referred only to 1 s 6 d, failed to disclose the whole consideration and was therefore invalid; condition (d) of section 8 was unmet, and protection under the section was unavailable.
  • Minority (Judge Simonds, Judge Keith).
    • Took the view that the wrappers were of no intrinsic value and merely identified customers qualified to buy.
    • Regarded the cash payment of 1 s 6 d as the ordinary retail selling price; hence the notice complied with section 8 and the Respondents were shielded from liability.

The majority considered it irrelevant that some individual transactions might not directly benefit Company B; the statutory scheme required royalties to reflect the whole economic value transferred. They emphasised that allowing barter-type consideration to be ignored would undermine the Act’s purpose of protecting copyright owners’ financial interests.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL ALLOWED.

By a majority of three to two, the House of Lords reinstated the first-instance injunction, holding that the Respondents had infringed copyright. The wrappers were part of the consideration; because the statutory notice excluded that element, the Respondents could not rely on the section 8 compulsory licence.

Implications: The decision confirms that non-monetary elements forming part of the consideration must be included in calculating the “ordinary retail selling price” for section 8 purposes. Promotional schemes that couple cash with other items of value (even if those items serve mainly advertising functions) will fall outside the statutory licence unless the full value is reflected in the notice and royalty. The ruling thereby limits the scope for using marketing promotions to circumvent copyright royalties.