Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Schmidt & Anor v Secretary of State for Home Affairs

England and Wales Court of Appeal (Civil Division)
Dec 19, 1968
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

At an establishment known as the Hubbard College of Scientology located near East Grinstead, owned by an American corporation, the Church of Scientology of California, there were 234 students, approximately 100 of whom were aliens, including two citizens of the United States. These two aliens (the Plaintiffs) brought an action against the Home Secretary on behalf of themselves and 50 other alien students. They claimed they were initially permitted to enter the country to study at the College for a limited time, but after their permits expired, the Home Secretary refused to extend their stay. The Plaintiffs contended that the refusal was invalid as it was made for an unauthorized purpose and without fairness. The Home Secretary applied to strike out the action as disclosing no reasonable cause or as an abuse of process, and the Judge granted the strike-out. The Plaintiffs appealed to the Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Home Secretary acted unlawfully in refusing to extend the Plaintiffs’ permits for study at the Hubbard College of Scientology.
  2. Whether the Home Secretary unlawfully fettered his discretion by laying down a general policy excluding Scientology establishments from recognition.
  3. Whether the Home Secretary failed to observe the principles of natural justice by refusing an extension without a hearing.
  4. Whether there was any unfairness in the refusal process.
  5. Whether the statement of claim disclosed a reasonable cause of action or should be struck out.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The Home Secretary refused to extend the permits for an unauthorized purpose, namely to express disapproval of a religious sect, rather than for any legitimate immigration reason.
  • The Home Secretary unlawfully fettered his discretion by adopting a blanket policy against Scientology establishments.
  • The Plaintiffs were entitled to a hearing before the refusal of their permit extensions, in accordance with natural justice.
  • The refusal was unfair and arbitrary, lacking proper procedural safeguards.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The Home Secretary acted within his lawful powers and for a legitimate purpose, namely the public good and interests of the country.
  • It is lawful and proper for the Home Secretary to lay down general policies and give guidance to immigration officers.
  • Aliens have no inherent right to enter or remain in the country; thus, no duty arises to provide a hearing before refusal of an extension.
  • The Home Secretary’s conduct was fair, as the Plaintiffs were granted a reasonable time to make arrangements for departure and could make representations.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Regina v. Governor of Brixton Prison, ex parte Soblen (1963 2 Q.B. 243) Validity of ministerial acts depends on purpose; acts done for unauthorized purposes are unlawful. The Court accepted this principle and found no evidence that the Home Secretary acted for an unauthorized purpose.
Rex v. Port of London Authority (1919 1 Q.B. 184) A tribunal may adopt a general policy and announce it if it remains open to exceptions. The Court held the Home Secretary lawfully adopted a policy excluding Scientology establishments as recognised educational institutions.
Rex v. Leman Street Police Station Inspector, ex parte Venicoff (1920 3 K.B. 72) Home Secretary is not bound to hear representations before deportation orders. Supported the position that aliens have no right to a hearing before refusal of stay extension.
Ridge v. Baldwin (1964 AC 40) Administrative bodies may be bound to give affected persons a chance to make representations depending on rights or legitimate expectations. The Court considered but distinguished this case, finding aliens have no right or legitimate expectation to remain beyond permitted time.
Re H.K. (1967 2 Q.B. 617) Where a right or legitimate expectation exists, fairness requires an opportunity to satisfy authorities. Distinguished on facts; aliens with limited permits have no such rights or expectations.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by affirming the legal principle that the Home Secretary’s acts must be done for authorized purposes. The Home Secretary’s stated purpose, as expressed in a House of Commons statement, was to protect the public good by curbing the growth of Scientology, which was regarded as socially harmful. The Court found no evidence that the Home Secretary acted with an ulterior motive or for an unauthorized purpose. The power to refuse or limit alien entry or stay is broad and includes consideration of public interest beyond narrowly defined categories suggested by the Appellant.

Regarding the adoption of policy, the Court held that the Home Secretary can lawfully establish and announce general policies to guide immigration officers, provided discretion remains to consider exceptional cases. The exclusion of the Hubbard College of Scientology from recognized educational establishments was a lawful exercise of this power.

On natural justice, the Court distinguished aliens from citizens, emphasizing that aliens have no inherent right to enter or remain in the country. Therefore, the Home Secretary is not obliged to provide a hearing before refusing an extension of stay. The Court noted that while fairness might require a hearing if a permit were revoked before its expiry, no such right or legitimate expectation exists once the permitted time has expired. The Home Secretary’s conduct was found to be fair, as extensions were granted temporarily to allow arrangements for departure, and representations could still be made.

The Court concluded that the statement of claim disclosed no reasonable cause of action and was properly struck out. However, one Lord Justice dissented on the appropriateness of summary striking out, indicating some points might succeed at trial, particularly regarding the Home Secretary’s stated reasons.

Holding and Implications

The Court’s final decision was to DISMISS THE APPEAL, thereby upholding the strike-out of the Plaintiffs’ claim.

The direct effect of this decision is that the Home Secretary’s refusal to extend the Plaintiffs’ permits to remain in the country for study at the Hubbard College of Scientology stands as lawful and valid. The ruling confirms the broad discretionary powers of the Home Secretary regarding alien entry and stay, including the ability to refuse extensions without providing reasons or hearings, absent a legitimate right or expectation to remain. The Court did not establish any new precedent but reaffirmed existing principles governing immigration control and administrative discretion.