Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Hunter v Moss

England and Wales Court of Appeal (Civil Division)
Dec 21, 1993
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal arises from an order made by the learned Deputy Judge of the High Court in the Chancery Division following a trial held in October 1992. The dispute concerns whether the Defendant/Appellant declared himself trustee for the Plaintiff of 5% of the issued share capital (fifty shares out of one thousand) of a company referred to as MEL. The learned judge found that the Defendant held these shares on an express oral trust for the Plaintiff and awarded the Plaintiff a monetary sum equivalent to 5% of the consideration received by the Defendant upon the sale of MEL’s entire share capital to Company B, amounting to £112,723.70 including interest.

The Defendant challenged the finding that he had declared a trust, contending insufficient certainty of the trust property due to lack of identification of the specific shares. Additionally, the Defendant disputed the calculation of the compensation awarded. The learned judge rejected the Defendant’s application to withdraw the order based on a point of law not argued at trial.

Historically, MEL was incorporated in 1962 and traded as a wholesaler of industrial electrical equipment. By 1983, the Defendant held 490 shares, his father 410 shares, and his mother 100 shares. The Plaintiff began employment at MEL in 1984 and was appointed finance director in 1985. Fifty shares were sold to the managing director, Mr Sood, in 1984. After the death of the Defendant’s father in 1985, the Defendant acquired the father’s shares. In June 1986, the Defendant intended to give the Plaintiff fifty shares to place him on equal footing with Mr Sood, but concerns about tax consequences and a proposed sale of MEL to Company B complicated the transfer. A trust was declared orally in early September 1986 to facilitate the sale without adverse tax effects. The sale to Company B was completed in late September 1986. Dividends and rights issues followed, with the Defendant paying the Plaintiff net dividends on the assumed shareholding. The parties later fell out, and the Plaintiff issued proceedings in July 1990.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Defendant made a valid and immediate declaration of trust over fifty shares of MEL in favour of the Plaintiff.
  2. Whether there was sufficient certainty as to the trust property, given the lack of identification of the specific shares out of the total issued shares.
  3. Whether the calculation of the Plaintiff's entitlement to compensation was correct, specifically whether the Plaintiff was entitled to shares only or a proportionate share of both cash and shares received by the Defendant upon the sale of MEL.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The Defendant challenged the finding of a trust, arguing that the oral declaration lacked sufficient certainty as to the specific shares to constitute valid trust property.
  • He contended that there was no immediate declaration of trust, and the Defendant merely held the shares until a solution to tax problems was found.
  • The Defendant argued that the calculation of compensation should be based solely on fifty shares (equivalent to 187,500 shares in Company B) rather than a proportion of both cash and shares received by him.
  • Reliance was placed on precedents emphasizing the necessity of certainty of subject matter and the invalidity of trusts over unappropriated or mixed assets.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The Plaintiff relied on the learned judge’s factual findings preferring his evidence, asserting that the Defendant declared an immediate trust over fifty shares.
  • It was submitted that the trust property was sufficiently certain as all shares were of one class in one company, and the Defendant held more than fifty shares personally.
  • The Plaintiff argued that the equitable interest translated into a proportionate entitlement to the consideration received by the Defendant upon the sale to Company B, including both cash and shares.
  • The Plaintiff accepted the calculation method proposed by the Defendant’s counsel at trial and agreed to the monetary compensation awarded, subject to minor adjustments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Knight v Knight (1840) 3 Beav 148 Established the "three certainties" required for the creation of a valid trust, including certainty of subject matter. The court applied the principle that certainty of subject matter is essential and found that the shares in MEL were sufficiently certain as trust property.
Milroy v Lord (1852) 4 De G F & J 264 Clarified that a settlor must do everything necessary to transfer property or declare a trust effectively; oral trusts over personalty are recognized. The court held that an oral declaration of trust over shares was valid and that no imperfect transfer was involved.
In re Rose (1952) 1 Ch 499 Confirmed that a valid transfer of shares can occur before registration, completing the gift. Supported the view that identification of specific shares is not necessary when all shares are of one class and the settlor holds more than the shares declared in trust.
Re London Wine Company Shippers Limited (1986) PCC 121 Held that lack of appropriation and identification of goods in a bulk prevents passing of legal title and invalidates trust claims. The court distinguished this case, noting that it concerned chattels and bulk appropriation, unlike the present case involving shares and a declaration of trust.
Mac-Jordan Construction Ltd v Brookmount Erostin Ltd (1991) 56 BLR 1 Addressed the concept that no fiduciary relationship attaches to unappropriated portions of a mixed fund; equitable charge may be the only remedy. The court rejected the application of this principle, holding that a beneficial proprietary interest in shares can be created by declaration of trust, distinct from an equitable charge.
In re Diplock (1948) 1 Ch 465 Discussed limits of common law and the role of equity in perfecting equitable rights such as charges. Referenced to clarify the distinction between equitable charges and trusts, supporting the court’s finding that an equitable proprietary interest existed.
In re Clifford (1912) 1 Ch 29 Confirmed validity of testamentary bequests of shares without specific identification of individual shares. Used to support the proposition that identification of specific shares is not necessary for certainty of subject matter.
In re Cheadle (1900) 2 Ch 620 Similar principle to In re Clifford regarding testamentary gifts of shares. Supported the court’s conclusion on certainty of subject matter.
In re Earl of Lucan 45 Ch 470 Held that equitable charges given by way of gift to volunteers do not grant priority over creditors and cannot be specifically enforced. Distinguished from the present case, which involves a trust conferring a beneficial proprietary interest rather than a mere equitable charge.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court began by affirming the learned judge’s factual findings that the Defendant declared himself trustee of fifty shares in MEL for the Plaintiff in early September 1986. The court emphasized the preference given to the Plaintiff’s evidence and rejected the Defendant’s contention that the trust was not immediate or sufficiently certain. The court explained that the trust declaration was intended to have immediate effect to facilitate the sale of MEL to Company B, notwithstanding unresolved tax issues.

Regarding certainty of subject matter, the court applied the established “three certainties” test, focusing on certainty of the trust property. It found that all shares were of one class in one company, and the Defendant held more than fifty shares personally, rendering the trust property sufficiently certain. The court distinguished cases involving unappropriated bulk goods or mixed funds, such as Re London Wine and Mac-Jordan, as inapplicable to the present circumstances involving shares and a declaration of trust.

On the calculation of compensation, the court accepted the methodology proposed by the Defendant’s counsel at trial, which was also agreed by the Plaintiff’s counsel. This approach treated the Plaintiff’s equitable interest as 5% of the total consideration received by the Defendant, comprising both cash and shares following the sale to Company B, rather than solely a proportion of shares. The court noted minor mathematical adjustments, including a credit for an overpayment of dividends, but otherwise upheld the award.

The court further held that the consent of both parties to the calculation method effectively settled the issue, removing grounds for interference with the learned judge’s award.

Holding and Implications

The court DISMISSED THE APPEAL WITH COSTS, affirming the learned Deputy Judge’s findings and order. The declaration of trust over fifty shares of MEL in favour of the Plaintiff was upheld as valid and immediate. The Plaintiff was entitled to compensation representing 5% of the consideration received by the Defendant upon the sale of MEL, including both cash and shares, subject to minor adjustments for overpayment of dividends and interest calculation.

The decision directly resolves the parties’ dispute regarding the existence of the trust and the appropriate remedy. No new precedent was established beyond the application of established principles concerning certainty of trust property and valuation of equitable interests in share sales.