Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

CBS Songs Ltd v Amstrad Consumer Electronics Plc

United Kingdom House of Lords
May 12, 1988
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The Appellants, a consortium of recording companies acting through an industry representative body, sought to restrict the Respondents, manufacturers and retailers of domestic audio equipment, from marketing and advertising twin-deck cassette recorders that allow high-speed (“double-speed”) tape-to-tape copying. The Appellants contended that such machines would inevitably be used by “home copiers” to duplicate sound recordings in which copyright subsists.

In 1984 the Respondents issued proceedings for a declaration that their activities were lawful. The Appellants counter-claimed for an injunction and damages. At first instance Judge [Last Name] rejected the Respondents’ claim and accepted the Appellants’ contention that infringement was authorised. The Court of Appeal reversed that decision, holding that no authorisation occurred and striking out the Appellants’ action. The present judgment is the determination of the Appellants’ further appeal to the House of Lords, which unanimously affirmed the Court of Appeal and dismissed the appeal with costs.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether selling or advertising copying-capable audio equipment amounts to authorising infringement of copyright under section 1(1) of the Copyright Act 1956.
  2. Whether the Respondents are liable as joint tortfeasors with purchasers who use the equipment to make infringing copies.
  3. Whether, apart from statute, the Respondents incur liability at common law for (a) procuring or inciting infringement, (b) inciting the commission of a criminal offence, or (c) negligence.
  4. Whether a commercial record becomes a “plate” for the purposes of the criminal offence under section 21(3) of the Copyright Act 1956, so that advertising the machines incites that offence.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The Respondents, by supplying the machines and highlighting the high-speed dubbing feature, “authorised” purchasers to copy protected recordings, thereby infringing the Appellants’ exclusive statutory right.
  • Sale and promotion of the machines constituted participation in, or procurement of, purchasers’ infringements, rendering the Respondents joint tortfeasors.
  • The advertising encouraged criminal conduct within section 21(3) of the 1956 Act and therefore amounted to the tort of inciting unlawful acts.
  • Even if no liability arose under statute, the Respondents owed a common-law duty not to facilitate or encourage copyright infringement; breach of that duty sounded in negligence.
  • As remedies, the Appellants sought (i) an injunction prohibiting sale of any copying facility, or alternatively any high-speed facility; (ii) failing that, an injunction restraining promotional claims and compelling prominent copyright warnings.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The Copyright Act confers no monopoly over the manufacture or sale of equipment capable of lawful and unlawful uses; selling a machine does not grant the purchaser legal permission to infringe.
  • Authorisation requires a grant or purported grant of the right to copy. The Respondents granted no such right and specifically included a disclaimer referring purchasers to copyright law.
  • No common design existed between seller and user; therefore joint-tortfeasor liability could not arise.
  • The concept of “plate” in section 21(3) was confined to master media, not to ordinary commercial records, so no criminal offence (and thus no incitement) was engaged.
  • There is no recognised duty of care to prevent third-party infringements, and extending negligence that far would usurp the legislative domain.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Monckton v. Pathe Freres Pathephone Ltd. [1914] 1 K.B. 395 Sale of a record can constitute authorisation where performance is inevitable. Distinguished; Respondents’ machines had lawful as well as unlawful uses, so no inevitable infringement.
Evans v. Hulton (1924) 131 L.T. 534 Transfer of rights for the purpose of infringing publication amounts to authorisation. Distinguished on same basis; no rights were granted to copy.
Falcon v. Famous Players Film Co. [1926] 2 K.B. 474 Hiring a film for exhibition authorises performance. Used to illustrate that authorisation involves a grant or licence, absent here.
Moorhouse v. University of New South Wales [1976] R.P.C. 151 Control over photocopiers in a library can amount to authorisation if reasonable steps to prevent infringement are omitted. Held inapplicable; Respondents lacked control over machines after sale.
CBS Inc. v. Ames Records & Tapes Ltd. [1982] Ch. 91 Distinction between facilitating and authorising infringement. Approved; Respondents merely facilitated potential infringement.
RCA Corp. v. John Fairfax & Sons Ltd. [1982] R.P.C. 91 Authorisation requires control or near-inevitable infringing use. Cited to support finding of no authorisation.
Townsend v. Haworth (1875) 48 L.J.Ch. 770n Selling materials, even knowing intended infringement, is not itself infringement without participation. Applied; sale of recorders alone insufficient.
Innes v. Short & Beal (1898) 15 R.P.C. 449 Selling materials and instructions to infringe may create liability. Distinguished; Respondents gave no instructions to infringe.
Dunlop Pneumatic Tyre Co. v. Moseley (1903–1904) 21 R.P.C. 53, 274 Supplying a component with alternative lawful uses does not infringe. Analogy drawn in Respondents’ favour.
The Koursk [1924] P. 140 Joint tortfeasorship requires a common design. Used to deny joint-tortfeasor status to Respondents.
Rotocrop International Ltd. v. Gembourne Ltd. [1982] F.S.R. 241 Supplying a kit with assembly instructions that inevitably infringes creates joint liability. Distinguished; infringement here was neither inevitable nor instructed.
Belegging… Lavender v. Witten [1979] F.S.R. 59 Facilitation differs from procurement; liability arises only with procurement. Relied on to show Respondents merely facilitated.
Lumley v. Gye (1853) 2 E.&B. 216 Procuring breach of a legal right is actionable. Court found no procurement of specific infringements.
Invicta Plastics Ltd. v. Clare [1976] R.T.R. 251 Incitement to commit a criminal offence can itself be criminal. Held irrelevant; no underlying offence established.
Macmillan & Co. v. Cooper (1923) L.R. 51 Ind. App. 109 Moral characterisation of copyright infringement as theft. Noted but held unable to expand statutory rights.
Anns v. Merton L.B.C. [1978] A.C. 728 & subsequent negligence authorities Modern development of negligence duty concepts. Cited to reject extending negligence to manufacturers of lawful equipment.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

1. Statutory framework. The Copyright Act 1956 gives copyright owners an exclusive right to reproduce works or to authorise reproduction. It says nothing about the design or sale of equipment capable of copying.

2. Authorisation. Drawing on the authorities above, the House held that “authorise” means to grant or purport to grant the right to do the infringing act. Selling a machine that is capable of copying does not confer such a right; the purchaser decides whether or not to copy. The Respondents’ advertising, though “deplorable” in tone, explicitly referred users to the Copyright Act and did not purport to give permission.

3. Joint tortfeasorship. Liability as a joint tortfeasor requires a common design. Once sold, the Respondents had no control over, or shared purpose with, end-users. Therefore no joint infringement arose.

4. Common-law procurement or incitement. Procurement requires specific persuasion of an identified infringer. Mass-market advertising of a multipurpose product falls short. Section 21(3) (“plate”) was construed narrowly; a commercial record is not a “plate”, so no criminal offence and hence no civil liability for incitement existed.

5. Negligence. Extending a duty of care to require manufacturers to prevent possible infringements by purchasers would be an unwarranted expansion of negligence law and contrary to the statutory scheme.

6. Policy observations. The House acknowledged the recording industry’s legitimate concern about widespread “home taping” but emphasised that any restriction on equipment design or sales must come from Parliament, not the courts.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL DISMISSED; ORDER OF THE COURT OF APPEAL AFFIRMED.

The Respondents are not liable for authorising or procuring copyright infringement through the sale and advertisement of their cassette recorders, and the Appellants must pay the Respondents’ costs. The decision confirms that liability for “authorisation” demands a grant of permission or control, not mere facilitation, and underscores that any solution to the problem of private copying lies with legislative, not judicial, intervention.