Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Leicester City Council & Anor v McConnell

United Kingdom Employment Appeal Tribunal
Oct 14, 1998
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This opinion concerns an appeal brought by Company A and an individual identified as Director of Education (the Appellants), challenging a decision by an Employment Tribunal that upheld a complaint of direct racial discrimination made by the Plaintiff against Company A. The Tribunal's decision, including extended reasons, was issued following a hearing held over three days. The Appellants contend that the Tribunal erred in its comparison approach regarding the alleged discriminatory treatment in the appointment process for a specific post within Company A.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Employment Tribunal erred in failing to compare the Plaintiff's treatment with that of an actual or hypothetical comparator of a different race or ethnic origin.
  2. Whether the Tribunal incorrectly asked if the Plaintiff was treated less favourably than she should have been under Company A's selection procedure, rather than applying the proper comparator test for direct racial discrimination.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The Tribunal failed to apply the correct comparator test by not comparing the Plaintiff's treatment to that of a person of a different race or ethnic origin.
  • The Tribunal focused incorrectly on whether the Plaintiff was treated less favourably than she should have been under the selection procedure, rather than on racial discrimination principles.
  • The appeal raises arguable points, supported by precedent from the Court of Appeal, and thus should proceed to a full hearing.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Martins v Marks & Spencer PLC [1998] IRLR 326 Clarification on the correct comparator test in direct racial discrimination claims. The Court found the appeal arguable in light of this precedent and ordered that the appeal proceed to a full hearing.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed the appeal on the basis that the Employment Tribunal may have applied an incorrect legal test by focusing on the selection procedure rather than comparing the Plaintiff's treatment with that of a comparator of different race or ethnic origin, as required in direct racial discrimination claims. Recognizing the significance of the Court of Appeal's decision in Martins v Marks & Spencer PLC, the court concluded that the appeal raised arguable points warranting a full hearing. The court therefore directed procedural steps to facilitate a comprehensive review of the issues.

Holding and Implications

The court ORDERED THAT the appeal proceed to a full hearing, scheduled for three hours under category B. The court declined to order Chairman's Notes of Evidence as requested by the Appellants. It further mandated the exchange of skeleton arguments at least 14 days before the hearing and required the parties to agree on a bundle of documentary evidence relevant to the appeal issues.

The direct effect of this decision is to allow the Appellants a full opportunity to argue their case on the alleged error in the Tribunal's application of the comparator test. The opinion does not establish new legal precedent but follows existing case law to ensure proper legal standards are applied in discrimination claims.