Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Ocular Sciences Ltd v Aspect Vision Care Ltd (No.2)

England and Wales High Court (Patents Court)
Nov 11, 1996
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This judgment concerns two consolidated actions before the High Court of Justice, Chancery Division, Patents Court, involving two groups of parties: the Plaintiffs and the Defendants. The first action, referred to as the breach of confidence action, involves claims of breach of confidence, breach of contracts, breach of fiduciary duty, copyright infringement, design right infringement, and conspiracy. The Plaintiffs seek wide-ranging relief including injunctions and constructive trusts. The Defendants have denied these claims and counterclaimed for sums due under a patent licence agreement and a contract of employment. The second action involves some of the Defendants suing one of the Plaintiffs for patent infringement, which led to counterclaims including revocation of the patent and a defence under the Patents Act 1977.

The dispute centers on the breakdown of the personal and working relationship between the chief executive officer of the second Plaintiff and two of the Defendants. The litigation relates to the design, manufacture, and sale of soft contact lenses, specifically involving proprietary technology, processes, equipment, and patents.

The history of the dispute includes the formation and development of companies involved in contact lens manufacturing and distribution, agreements and mergers between these companies, and the subsequent deterioration of their business relationship. Key agreements include a Share Exchange Agreement, a Patent Licence Agreement (PLA), a Purchase and Supply Agreement (PSA), consultancy agreements, and employment contracts. The dispute arose over the use, licensing, and alleged misuse of confidential information, patent rights, and contractual obligations, including the establishment by certain Defendants of an independent manufacturing facility in competition with the Plaintiffs.

The trial involved extensive factual evidence, including witness testimony from key individuals such as the chief executive officer of the second Plaintiff, senior officers of the companies involved, and the Defendants. The court made detailed findings on the credibility of witnesses, the nature of the technology, business dealings, and contractual relationships.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Defendants breached obligations of confidence, contracts, and fiduciary duties owed to the Plaintiffs.
  2. Whether the Defendants infringed the Plaintiffs' copyrights and design rights.
  3. Whether the Defendants committed patent infringement and whether the patent in suit is valid.
  4. The scope and effect of the 1992 agreements, including the Patent Licence Agreement and Purchase and Supply Agreement.
  5. The existence and scope of any conspiracy to injure the Plaintiffs by unlawful means.
  6. The appropriate remedies and relief, including injunctions, delivery up, constructive trusts, and damages.
  7. The validity and effect of the Defendants' counterclaims, including unpaid royalties and breach of contract claims.

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiffs' Arguments

  • The Defendants breached confidence by using confidential information, including detailed lens designs, manufacturing equipment drawings, software, and processes, to establish a competing manufacturing facility.
  • The Defendants infringed copyrights in software programs and manufacturing drawings.
  • The Defendants breached fiduciary duties, particularly those of Mr. Anthony Galley, by prioritizing interests of the competing company and failing to act in the Plaintiffs' best interests.
  • The Defendants engaged in conspiracy to injure the Plaintiffs by unlawful means, including secret planning and use of confidential information.
  • The Defendants wrongfully solicited employees and induced them to leave the Plaintiffs’ company.
  • The Defendants’ patent licence to the competing company was not at fair market value, constituting a breach and repudiation of the licence.
  • The Plaintiffs seek injunctions, delivery up of confidential materials, constructive trusts over assets, and financial remedies.

Defendants' Arguments

  • The Defendants deny breach of confidence, arguing that much of the technology and information was not confidential or was part of their acquired skill and expertise.
  • The Defendants challenge the Plaintiffs’ claims to broad confidentiality and assert that many of the Plaintiffs’ claims were extravagant or unsupportable.
  • The Defendants deny copyright infringement except in limited respects and argue that some software and drawings are jointly owned or licensed.
  • The Defendants assert that the Plaintiffs’ claims of fiduciary breach and conflict of interest against Mr. Anthony Galley are unfounded and that he acted in the best interests of his company.
  • The Defendants deny the existence of any unlawful conspiracy or intent to injure the Plaintiffs.
  • The Defendants argue that any assistance given to the competing company was permitted by the patent licence and consultancy agreements when properly construed.
  • The Defendants contend that the Plaintiffs repudiated the patent licence agreement by withholding royalties and commencing litigation, thus invalidating claims of infringement.
  • The Defendants counterclaim for unpaid royalties and damages due to breaches by the Plaintiffs.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
John Zinc Co. Ltd. v. Wilkinson [1973] RPC 717 Requirement for particularity in pleadings for breach of confidence and allegations of grave misconduct. Emphasized the need for clear particulars to prevent harassment and ensure fair treatment of defendants.
Coco v. A.N. Clark Engineers [1969] RPC 41 Elements required for breach of confidence: confidential nature of information, obligation of confidence, and unauthorized use. Guided the court’s assessment of confidentiality and obligations in the case.
Faccenda Chicken Ltd v. Fowler [1987] Ch 117 Distinction between trivial information, employee’s acquired skill and confidential information. Helped the court distinguish protectable information from general skill and knowledge.
Lancashire Fires Ltd v. SA Lyons & Co Ltd [1996] FSR 629 Review of Faccenda and principles on employee skill versus confidential information. Supported the court’s nuanced approach to confidentiality and employee rights.
Attorney General v. Guardian Newspapers (No 2) [1990] 1 AC 109 (Spycatcher case) Principles on confidentiality, public domain, and injunctions preventing profit from breach of confidence. Informed the court’s approach to injunctions and the limits of confidentiality after disclosure.
Rookes v Barnard [1964] AC 1129 Elements and types of conspiracy to injure by unlawful means. Clarified requirements for proving conspiracy, including intent to injure.
Baroness Wenlock v River Dee Co. [1883] 36 Ch D 675 Effect of unanimous shareholder assent as binding as a resolution. Considered by parties in relation to shareholder direction of directors.
Re Duomatic Ltd [1969] 2 Ch 365 Unanimous shareholder assent without meeting is effective as a resolution. Discussed in context of shareholder control and director duties.
Woodar Investment Development Ltd v. Wimpy Construction Ltd [1980] 1 WLR 277 Principles on repudiation and intention to abandon contract. Applied in assessing whether patent licence was repudiated.
Saltman Engineering Co Ltd v Campbell Engineering Co Ltd (1948) 65 RPC 203 Confidential information must have quality of confidence and be more than public knowledge. Supported the court’s analysis of confidentiality in lens designs.
Von Heyden v. Neustadt (1880) 14 Ch D 230 Importation of products made abroad using patented process may constitute infringement. Referenced in analogy to use of confidential information in derived products.
LAC Minerals Ltd v. International Corona Resources Services Ltd (1989) 61 DLR (4th) 14 Appropriateness of constructive trust as remedy for breach of fiduciary duty or confidence. Informed the court’s exercise of discretion on constructive trust relief.
Armstrong v. Sheppard & Short Ltd [1959] 2 QB 384 Discretion to refuse injunction where plaintiff misleads court or wrongdoer. Supported the court’s consideration of conduct in granting relief.
Re Smith and Fawcett Ltd [1942] Ch 304 Directors’ duty to act bona fide in interests of the company, not for collateral purposes. Guided the court’s assessment of director duties and conduct.
Charterbridge v Lloyds Bank [1970] Ch 62 Directors’ duty to act in interests of their company, not to sacrifice it for group interests. Applied in evaluating director conduct and shareholder influence.
Aberdeen Railway Co v Blaikie Bros [1854] 23 LT (OS) 315 Fiduciary must avoid conflicts of interest. Referenced in relation to alleged divided loyalties of a director.
Boulting v Association of Cinematograph, Television and Allied Technicians [1963] 2 QB 606 Rule against conflict of duty and interest may be relaxed with full informed consent. Considered in relation to director’s duties and conflicting roles.
Boston Deep Sea Fishing & Ice Co v. Ansell (1888) 39 Ch D 339 Valid grounds for dismissal may be relied on even if unknown at time of dismissal. Applied in assessing justification for dismissal of managing director.
Prince Albert v Strange (1849) 1 Mac & G 25 Equity will prevent use of title arising from breach of confidence or contract. Invoked in arguments on injunctive relief for misuse of confidential information.
Union Carbide v Naturin [1987] FSR 538 Possible equitable claims against third parties in possession of products made using confidential information. Discussed in relation to injunctions against use of derived products.
Stevenson Jordan Harrison Ltd v MacDonald & Evans (1951) 68 RPC 190 Principles on equitable relief and injunctions in cases of breach of confidence. Referenced in relation to relief against misuse of confidential information.
Netupsky v. Dominion Bridge Co Ltd (1969) 43 Fox's Canadian Patent Cases 14 Equitable considerations in ordering delivery up of infringing copies. Considered in relation to delivery up of confidential information and drawings.
Saltman Engineering Co Ltd v Campbell Engineering Co Ltd (1948) 65 RPC 203 Confidential information must have the necessary quality of confidence. Applied to lens design confidentiality.
Gramophone Co. v. Magazine Holder Co. (1911) 28 RPC 221 Validity of patents and related issues may be considered even if parties do not pursue them. Supported the court’s jurisdiction to consider patent validity.
Von Heyden v Neustadt (1880) 14 Ch D 230 Importation of products made abroad using patented process may infringe UK patent. Referenced in patent infringement discussion.
Wilderman v F.W. Berk & Co Ltd (1924) 42 RPC 79 Extent of patent rights in imported products made using patented processes. Guided court’s approach to patent infringement by importation.
Leary v. Leary [1987] 1 All ER 261 Costs management in litigation. Referenced in relation to costs orders.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court conducted a detailed and meticulous analysis of the factual background, technological context, contractual arrangements, and conduct of the parties. The court found significant unreliability and dishonesty in the evidence of the Plaintiffs' chief executive officer and finance officer, particularly in their testimony concerning material facts and documents. Conversely, the court found the Defendants' witnesses, especially the Galleys, to be largely credible and truthful, albeit with some admitted omissions and selective disclosures motivated by commercial realities and fear of oppressive litigation.

The court distinguished between confidential information and information constituting skill and expertise, emphasizing that an employee is entitled to use acquired skill and knowledge unless restrained by a reasonable covenant. Many of the Plaintiffs' claims to confidentiality were found to be overly broad, extravagant, or unsupported, including claims relating to standard operating procedures, hardware designs largely copied from prior art, and polymer formulations common in the industry.

On breach of confidence, the court found limited breaches where the Defendants used pre-September 1992 drawings and the Lens Design Program for initial insert designs, but rejected broader claims of misuse of confidential information. The court concluded that the Defendants’ establishment of an independent manufacturing facility was a reasonable commercial response to threats by the Plaintiffs to cut off supplies and impose inflated prices, and that the Defendants acted in good faith without intent to harm the Plaintiffs.

Regarding injunctive relief, the court exercised its discretion to refuse injunctions restraining continued use of confidential information, considering the minimal technical significance of the information, the disproportionate harm to the Defendants, and the Plaintiffs’ conduct in the litigation. However, the court granted injunctions restraining disclosure of confidential information to preserve its confidentiality.

On copyright infringement, the court found infringement of certain software programs and pre-1989 drawings but limited relief due to statutory provisions allowing licences of right and the availability of replacement parts. The court ordered injunctions and delivery up in respect of infringed software but declined delivery up for drawings due to practical considerations.

The court rejected the Plaintiffs’ design right claims on grounds of lack of copying and that the designs were commonplace or excluded by statutory interface provisions. The court found no breach of fiduciary duty by Mr. Anthony Galley, noting that directors owe duties to their company and are not bound to follow informal shareholder directions, especially where the company is a separate legal entity. The court found no intent or act of solicitation by the Galleys or Mr. Anthony Galley, viewing the Solent Hotel meeting as motivated by commercial realities and loyalty to the company.

The court held that the Plaintiffs repudiated the patent licence agreement by withholding royalties and commencing litigation, and that the licence remains valid and subsisting. The court found the patent valid and not obvious, acknowledging the inventive contribution of the piston-like mould design over prior art.

Overall, the court emphasized the necessity of particularity in pleadings, the equitable principles guiding relief, the importance of good faith and honesty in litigation, and the balance between protecting confidential information and avoiding oppressive outcomes.

Holding and Implications

DISMISSED IN PART AND GRANTED IN PART

The court ruled that the Plaintiffs succeeded only on narrow claims of breach of confidence and copyright infringement but failed on major claims including broad confidentiality assertions, design right infringement, breach of fiduciary duty, conspiracy, and patent invalidity. The Plaintiffs’ attempts to close down the Defendants’ competing business were unsuccessful.

The court refused injunctions restraining continued use of confidential information due to disproportionate harm and conduct of the Plaintiffs but granted injunctions restraining disclosure to preserve confidentiality. Delivery up was ordered in limited respects. The Defendants’ counterclaims succeeded in part, including entitlement to unpaid royalties and damages for breach of contract. The patent licence remains valid, and the patent is upheld as non-obvious.

The decision underscores the importance of precise pleadings, good faith conduct in litigation, and a balanced approach to protecting intellectual property rights without unduly harming competition or business viability. No new precedent was established beyond the application of established legal principles in the complex factual context of the contact lens industry dispute.