- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Zang Tumb Tuum Records Ltd & Anor v Johnson
Factual and Procedural Background
The appellants, Company A (the recording company) and Company B (the publishing company), appealed an order made by Judge Whitford following a trial involving agreements with a pop group ("the Group") comprising five young men, including the Defendant as lead singer. The dispute concerned two agreements dated 1st September 1983 (recording agreement) and 11th May 1984 (publishing agreement), entered into between the companies and the Group members. The publishing agreement replaced a lost agreement originally made on the same date as the recording agreement.
The Group, relatively inexperienced and of modest means, was represented by a manager and assisted by a solicitor during negotiations. The recording company was newly formed, led by an experienced producer and an administrator, both directors and shareholders of the two companies. The agreements imposed significant obligations on the Group, including exclusive recording and publishing commitments, with the recording company having considerable discretion over production and release decisions.
The Group released two successful singles and a double album under the agreements, but disputes arose over high recording costs and the enforceability of the agreements, which the Defendant challenged as unreasonable restraints of trade. The appellants issued proceedings asserting the validity of the agreements and claiming the Defendant was bound to enter into a fresh recording agreement after leaving the Group under a specific clause.
The trial judge held both agreements unenforceable due to unreasonable restraint of trade and found a key clause void for uncertainty. An enquiry as to damages was ordered concerning alleged excessive recording costs for the second album. The appellants appealed these findings and the scope of the damages enquiry.
Legal Issues Presented
- What is the true construction of certain clauses in the recording and publishing agreements?
- Whether the recording agreement and/or the publishing agreement are unenforceable as unreasonable restraints of trade.
- Whether the Defendant waived any right to object to the agreements on grounds of unreasonable restraint of trade before purportedly exercising such rights.
- The basis for and scope of the enquiry as to damages awarded on the Defendant's counterclaim.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellants' Arguments
- The recording agreement's clause requiring the Defendant to enter a fresh agreement after leaving the Group is valid and enforceable.
- The long term of the recording agreement is justified by industry practice, including the need to recoup costs from unsuccessful records through successful ones and the benefits of successive recordings by an artist.
- The parties had, by conduct, effectively agreed to a shorter and less onerous recording schedule due to the rapid release of initial recordings.
- The damages enquiry order should be varied to reflect the judge's actual wording, which did not find breach but allowed an enquiry if damages were suffered.
Defendant's Arguments
- The recording and publishing agreements are void as unreasonable restraints of trade due to their one-sided, lengthy, and restrictive terms.
- The clause requiring a fresh agreement after leaving the Group is void for uncertainty and oppressive.
- The Defendant did not waive the right to challenge the agreements despite ongoing negotiations and recording activity.
- The judge found a breach of the implied term to keep recording costs reasonable and the damages enquiry should reflect this finding.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Schroeder Music Publishing Co. Ltd. v. Macaulay [1974] 1 WLR 1308 | Test of fairness in contracts restraining trade; whether restrictions are reasonably necessary and commensurate with benefits; reasonableness of restraint on livelihood. | The court applied the principles to determine that the recording and publishing agreements were unreasonable restraints of trade and thus unenforceable. |
| Lindsay Petroleum Company v. Hurd [1873] 5 A.C. 221 | Doctrine of laches and waiver in equity; delay and conduct affecting equitable remedies. | The court held that waiver or estoppel defenses must be based on equitable grounds considering all circumstances, and found no such waiver here. |
| Erlanger v. New Sombrero Phosphate Co. [1878] 3 A.C. 1218 | Equitable principles regarding delay and diligence in asserting rights; balance of justice in granting or withholding remedies. | Referenced to support the equitable approach to waiver and laches in the context of the agreements' enforceability. |
| John v. James (unreported, 29 Nov 1985) | Application of equitable principles in waiver and estoppel in contract disputes. | Used as persuasive authority supporting the court's approach to waiver and laches. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court undertook a detailed examination of the recording and publishing agreements, focusing on their terms, duration, and the extent of control and discretion granted to the recording company. The recording agreement imposed a potentially lengthy term—up to seven option periods after an initial short period—binding the Group members collectively and individually, while allowing the recording company sole discretion over key production and release decisions.
The court found these provisions excessively one-sided and oppressive, especially given the young and inexperienced nature of the Group members. The recording company’s ability to terminate at will contrasted sharply with the long-term binding obligations of the artists, amounting to an unreasonable restraint of trade under established legal principles, notably those in Schroeder Music Publishing Co. Ltd. v. Macaulay.
The publishing agreement similarly imposed restrictive obligations on the Defendant, preventing performance of his compositions without the publishing company’s consent, and was found to be unenforceable on the same grounds.
Regarding waiver, the court emphasized that any defense based on waiver, laches, or estoppel must be equitable, considering the conduct of the parties and whether it would be unjust or unconscionable to allow the Defendant to raise the restraint of trade argument. The court found no unequivocal representation or conduct amounting to waiver, noting ongoing negotiations and the absence of abandonment of the claim.
On the damages enquiry, the court acknowledged the judge’s finding that the recording costs for the second album were likely excessive but that a precise figure could not be determined from the evidence. Therefore, an enquiry was appropriate to assess any damages resulting from breach of the implied term to keep recording costs reasonable. The court varied the order to clarify that the enquiry is to determine damages, if any, resulting from any breach.
Holding and Implications
The court DISMISSED THE APPEAL, affirming the trial judge's decision that both the recording agreement and the publishing agreement are unenforceable as unreasonable restraints of trade.
The court also upheld the order for an enquiry into damages relating to excessive recording costs on the second album, subject to a variation clarifying the conditional nature of breach and damages.
As a direct consequence, the Defendant is not bound by the agreements' onerous terms, and the recording company remains accountable for proper accounting of royalties and recording costs. No new legal precedent was established beyond the application of existing principles to the facts.
Alert