- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Poll v. Lord Advocate
Factual and Procedural Background
An alien, the master of a steam trawler registered in a foreign country, sought an interdict to prevent certain officials of the Fishery Board and the Lord Advocate from interfering with the landing of fish caught by trawling outside territorial waters but within a prohibited line at a Scottish port. The officials acted under the authority of the Secretary for Scotland, who was part of Her Majesty's Government. The Plaintiff challenged this administrative act, contending that the interference was unlawful. The Lord Ordinary refused the note of suspension on 5th November 1897, leading to this legal opinion regarding the entitlement of an alien to question acts of the Sovereign and the application of relevant fishery legislation.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether an alien is entitled to obtain an interdict in the courts of this country to prevent officials, acting under the authority of the Crown, from interfering with the landing of fish caught by trawling outside territorial waters.
- Whether acts of the Secretary for Scotland, as a minister of the Crown, can be questioned by an alien in respect of alleged violations of international or municipal law.
- The interpretation and applicability of the Herring Fishery (Scotland) Act 1889, section 8, regarding the landing of fish caught in contravention of the Act by British subjects and foreigners.
- Whether international law or municipal statutes confer on foreigners a right enforceable by action to land fish caught by trawling outside territorial waters in Scotland.
Arguments of the Parties
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Musgrove v. Chun Tlong Toy [1891] A.C. 272 | Establishment that an alien has no enforceable right to enter the territory of another country. | Supported the court's conclusion that an alien cannot sue the Crown or its servants for acts done in the national interest. |
| Puffendorf, iii., 3, 9; Blackstone's Commentaries, i, p. 338; Vattel, ii, 7, 94–100; Hansard, vol. xxxiv, p. 1065 (Lord Eldon), and 1069 (Lord Ellenborough) | Authoritative writings and parliamentary records affirming the sovereignty of states to exclude aliens and that aliens have no right of entry enforceable by law. | Used to reinforce the principle that international law does not grant aliens enforceable rights to enter or fish in another state's territory. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court held that an alien is not entitled to question in domestic courts an administrative act of the Sovereign, even if such an act violates international or municipal law. The act in question—preventing the landing of fish caught by trawling in a prohibited area—was authorized by the Secretary for Scotland as a member of Her Majesty's Government, and thus constituted an act of State. The court emphasized the absolute nature of sovereign power in matters concerning the national interest and the exclusion of foreigners from suing the Crown or its servants for such acts.
Regarding international law, the court noted that no alien has a right enforceable by action to enter the territory of another country; such matters are governed by diplomacy or war, not municipal courts. The court also rejected the argument that the Fisheries Acts or the International Convention of 1883 granted foreigners a right to land fish caught by trawling outside territorial waters. Although statutory prohibitions on trawling outside territorial waters may not apply to foreigners, this did not imply permission to land fish in Scotland. The Herring Fishery (Scotland) Act 1889, section 8, explicitly prohibits landing or selling fish caught in contravention of the Act, applying equally to foreigners and British subjects.
Consequently, the court found the Plaintiff's case untenable on all grounds and sustained the respondents' plea-in-law, refusing the interdict sought.
Holding and Implications
The court's final decision was to REFUSE THE NOTE OF SUSPENSION and dismiss the Plaintiff's claim.
The direct effect is that an alien cannot obtain judicial relief in the courts of this country against acts of the Crown done in the national interest, even if these acts allegedly violate international or municipal law. The decision reinforces the principle of sovereign immunity in such contexts and clarifies the scope of the Herring Fishery (Scotland) Act 1889 in prohibiting the landing of fish caught in contravention of the Act by any person, regardless of nationality. No new legal precedent beyond these principles was established.
Alert