Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Budu v The British Broadcasting Corporation

England and Wales High Court (Queen's Bench Division)
Mar 23, 2010
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The Plaintiff initiated libel proceedings against Company A concerning three articles published on Company A's website archive and a search engine snippet generated by a third-party search engine when the Plaintiff's name was searched. The articles, originally published nearly six years prior to the claim, concerned the withdrawal of a job offer by a police force due to the Plaintiff's immigration status. The claim was confined to publications after May 2008, reflecting the one-year limitation period for libel. Company A applied to strike out the claim and/or for summary judgment, challenging the meanings pleaded, publication, identification, and damages, asserting that the claim was an abuse of process. The articles were archived shortly after initial publication and accessible only via search. Company A attached legal notices to the articles after proceedings were served. No defense has yet been filed. The Plaintiff’s case on publication is limited to those who accessed the articles via searches using his name after May 2008, with the first article only accessible through the second and third articles.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the first article, when read alone or in context with the second and third articles, is capable of bearing the defamatory meanings attributed by the Plaintiff.
  2. Whether the second and third articles are capable of bearing the "security risk" defamatory meaning.
  3. Whether Company A is liable for the search engine snippet as a republication of defamatory material.
  4. Whether the residual defamatory meanings, if any, are true and if the claim should be struck out as an abuse of process.
  5. Whether the delay in bringing the claim and other procedural factors justify striking out the claim as an abuse of process.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The Plaintiff contends the articles and the search engine snippet defame him by implying he was an illegal immigrant who knowingly applied for a police job without lawful status and concealed this from authorities.
  • The Plaintiff argues Company A is liable for the search engine snippet as a republication of defamatory content.
  • The Plaintiff claims continuing publication of the articles online is damaging his employment prospects, justifying aggravated damages and injunctive relief.

Appellee's Arguments

  • Company A submits the first article, when read in context with the second and third articles, does not bear the defamatory meanings alleged due to a significant diluting effect.
  • The second and third articles do not bear the "security risk" meaning; the issues related solely to immigration status, not security risk.
  • Company A denies liability for the search engine snippet, as it is an automated extract that distorts the original meaning and does not constitute republication.
  • The residual defamatory meanings alleged are unarguably true on the agreed facts.
  • The claim should be struck out as an abuse of process due to delay, prejudice to Company A’s ability to defend, speculative damage claims, and the attachment of legal notices mitigating any sting.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Loutchansky v Times Newspapers [2001] EWCA Civ 1805 Attachment of notices to archived online articles mitigates sting of defamatory content. The court accepted the attachment of legal notices to the articles as appropriate and mitigating.
Metropolitan International Schools Ltd v Designtechnica Corporation [2009] EWHC 1765 (QB) Search engine operators are not publishers of snippets generated automatically. Applied to hold that the search engine snippet was not attributable to Company A as a republication.
Chase v News Group Newspapers [2002] EWCA Civ 1772 Levels of defamatory meaning (guilt and reasonable suspicion). Used to analyze the meanings attributed to the articles and their levels of seriousness.
Gillick v BBC [1996] EMLR 267 Approach to determining meaning of words in defamation. Guided the court’s assessment of whether words were capable of bearing the pleaded meanings.
Jeynes v News Magazine Ltd [2008] EWCA Civ 130 Hypothetical reader standard for assessing meaning. Applied to consider how a reasonable reader would understand the articles.
Jameel v Wall Street Journal Europe [2004] EMLR 6 High threshold for excluding meanings; importance of context and imprecision of language. Informed the court’s generous approach to possible meanings of the articles.
McManus v Beckham [2002] 1 WLR 2982 Liability for republication and causation of damage. Used to analyze Company A’s liability for the search engine snippet as republication.
Slipper v BBC [1991] 1 QB 283 Liability for repetition of defamatory sting through related publications. Referenced to support principles on liability for partial republications.
Loutchansky v Times Newspapers [2001] EWCA Civ 1805 (referred again) Internet publication rule and limitation period for libel claims. Guided the court on limitation and continuing publication issues.
Times Newspapers Ltd v United Kingdom [2009] EMLR 14 (ECtHR) Balancing freedom of expression with protection of reputation in internet archive publications. Supported the court’s approach to limitation, prejudice, and attachment of notices in archived publications.
Bruce v Odhams Press Ltd [1936] 1 KB 697 Requirement to plead extrinsic facts to establish identification in defamation. Applied to require the Plaintiff to plead facts known to readers to establish reference to him.
Fullam v Newcastle Chronicle [1977] 1 WLR 655 Pleading of identification in defamation claims. Supported the requirement for pleading identifying facts.
Mosley and anor v Focus Magazin Verlag Gmbh (CA) 29 June 2001 (unreported) Pleading and proof of identification. Referenced for pleading requirements on identification.
Charleston v News Group Newspapers Limited [1995] 2 AC 65 Meaning to be read with context, especially for internet publications. Applied analogously to consider the snippet and underlying articles as a single publication.
Tarpley, Clerk v Blabey (1836) 2 Bingham New Cases 437 Authority on partial publication and authorization of libel. Referenced in arguments on republication liability.
Ward v Weeks (1830) 7 Bing 211 Historical principles on liability for repeated publications. Discussed in the context of causation and liability for republication.
Parkins v Scott (1862) 1 H & C 153 Distinction in repeat publication liability depending on actionability. Referenced in analysis of causation and liability.
Speight v Gosnay (1891) 60 LJQB 231 Categories of reliance on repeat publication. Referenced in discussion of repeat publication rules.
Rahman v Arearose Ltd [2001] QB 351 Legal causation and responsibility for damage caused by third parties. Applied to clarify liability for damage from republication by third parties.
Flood v Times Newspapers Ltd [2010] EMLR 8 Qualified privilege and public interest in defamation cases. Referenced regarding the defense of qualified privilege and evidential issues arising from delay.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court undertook a detailed analysis of the accessibility and context of the three articles, concluding that the first article was only accessible post-2008 through the second and third articles and never read in isolation by a reasonable reader. The Plaintiff's pleaded meanings for the first article, both originally and as amended, were found to be incapable of bearing the defamatory meanings alleged when read in context, due to the diluting effect of the second and third articles, which contained detailed denials and supportive statements favoring the Plaintiff. The "security risk" meaning attributed to the second and third articles, and by extension the search engine snippet, was rejected as perverse and unsupported by the text, which focused solely on immigration status rather than security risk.

On the issue of liability for the search engine snippet, the court relied on established authority that automated snippets generated by search engines without human intervention do not constitute republication by the original publisher. The snippet extracted a distorted, out-of-context fragment incapable of bearing the defamatory meaning alleged, thus negating Company A’s liability for it.

The court found the residual defamatory meaning capable of being borne by the first article, when read in context, to be unarguably true on the agreed facts, specifically that the Plaintiff lacked lawful status at the time of his job application and failed to disclose this to the police. The court considered the Plaintiff’s delay in bringing the claim, the prejudice caused to Company A’s ability to defend, including loss of contemporaneous evidence, and the speculative nature of the Plaintiff’s damage claims. It noted the attachment of Loutchansky notices to the articles, which informed readers of the Plaintiff’s updated immigration status, further mitigating any defamatory sting.

Balancing the competing rights under Articles 6, 8, and 10 of the European Convention on Human Rights, and applying relevant case law on limitation and internet publication, the court concluded that permitting the claim to proceed would constitute an abuse of process and a disproportionate interference with Company A’s freedom of expression.

Holding and Implications

The court STRUCK OUT the Plaintiff’s claim in its entirety.

The direct effect of this decision is that the Plaintiff’s libel action against Company A concerning the archived articles and the search engine snippet will not proceed to trial. The court found no realistic prospect of success on the pleaded defamatory meanings, held the residual meaning to be true, and determined that the delay and other factors rendered the claim an abuse of process. No new precedent was established; the decision applies established principles concerning internet publication, limitation, meaning in defamation, and liability for automated search engine snippets.