- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Davies v Global Strategies Group Hong Kong Ltd & Anor
Factual and Procedural Background
The case concerns the death of the deceased, who died on 24 June 2004 after being shot through the windscreen of a vehicle on the outskirts of Mosul, Iraq, while engaged in a security operation known as Operation Northstar. The deceased was employed by the first defendant, a Hong Kong subsidiary of a British company, both part of the Global Strategies Group, contracted by the United States Government to provide defence and security services. The claimant, the deceased's widow, brought the claim on her own behalf and on behalf of their son.
The claim was pleaded in negligence and breach of statutory duty, though reliance on statutory regulations was not pursued at trial due to territorial limitations. The defendants accepted, for trial purposes, that the deceased was their employee but denied negligence. The principal complaints were that the defendants should have fitted bullet resistant windscreens, provided armoured vehicles, or equipped the deceased’s body armour with a collar. It was common ground that a bullet resistant windscreen would have prevented the fatal injury.
The trial involved witness evidence including from the claimant, the defendants’ project manager (who declined to give evidence at trial but whose inquest testimony was admitted), and expert witnesses from both sides. The defendants called senior management witnesses as well. Issues of adverse inference for non-attendance of certain witnesses and poor disclosure of documents were addressed but ultimately no adverse inference was drawn against the defendants for witness absence or document non-disclosure.
The background evidence detailed the operational context in Northern Iraq, the deteriorating security situation, and the nature of the vehicles and tactics employed by the defendants. The deceased was in command of a half platoon escorting convoys using soft skinned Toyota vehicles with doors removed for tactical reasons. The fatal shooting occurred during an ambush involving small arms fire. The defendants had considered but not implemented bullet resistant windscreens, citing unavailability and practical difficulties.
The case proceeded to expert evidence on the adequacy of the defendants’ precautions and the causative effect of alleged breaches of duty. The court also considered the doctrine of volenti non fit injuria and addressed issues of quantum, though liability was dismissed before full quantum determination.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the defendants breached their duty of care to the deceased by failing to provide armoured vehicles or bullet resistant windscreens.
- Whether the defendants breached their duty by failing to provide body armour with a collar.
- Whether the defendants or their project manager were negligent in failing to abort the mission as events unfolded.
- Whether the deceased voluntarily accepted any breach of duty (volenti non fit injuria).
- Whether any breach of duty was causative of the deceased’s death.
Arguments of the Parties
Claimant's Arguments
- The defendants were negligent in failing to equip vehicles with bullet resistant windscreens or armoured vehicles despite the increasing threat.
- The deceased should have been provided with body armour fitted with a collar to protect the neck area.
- The mission should have been called off as the security situation worsened.
- Adverse inferences should be drawn against the defendants for failing to call key witnesses and for poor disclosure of documents.
Defendants' Arguments
- The use of soft skinned vehicles without bullet resistant windscreens was reasonable and consistent with accepted military doctrine and operational tactics.
- Bullet resistant windscreens were not reasonably available or practicable to fit in Northern Iraq at the time.
- The deceased’s body armour collar issue was speculative and collars providing sufficient protection were not shown to be available.
- The mission was properly managed and there was no negligence in continuing it.
- The absence of certain witnesses was due to valid reasons and no adverse inference should be drawn.
- The claimant had not established causation for any alleged breach of duty.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Mulcahy v. Ministry of Defence [1996] QB 732 | Combat immunity in the context of military operations. | Defendants raised but did not pursue combat immunity as a defence at trial. |
| Wisniewski v Central Manchester Health Authority [1998] PIQR 324 | Principles governing adverse inferences from absence or silence of witnesses. | The court considered but declined to draw adverse inferences against defendants for witness absence except in limited respects. |
| R v IRC Ex parte Coombs & Co [1991] 2 A.C. 283 | Guidance on drawing adverse inferences from absence of evidence. | Referenced in Wisniewski and applied to assess whether adverse inferences were appropriate. |
| General Cleaning Contractors Ltd v. Christmas [1953] 180 | Scope of employer's duty of care in hazardous operations. | Applied to define the duty of care owed by defendants to the deceased in a hazardous operational context. |
| Brown v Corus (UK) Limited [2004] EWCA Civ 337 | Allocation of evidential burden once claimant shows exposure to risk. | Applied to hold that defendants bore an evidential burden to explain failure to reduce risk (collar provision). |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court began by establishing the duty of care owed by the defendants to the deceased, emphasizing the reasonableness standard in a hazardous environment. It accepted that the defendants owed a duty to provide a reasonably safe system of work, including reasonable protection.
The court reviewed the factual background and evidence concerning the security situation in Iraq, the nature of the vehicles, and the tactics employed. It found that the use of soft skinned vehicles with doors removed was a reasonable tactical choice to maximize manoeuvrability and rapid response capability.
Regarding armoured vehicles, the court accepted expert evidence that such vehicles were not readily available in early 2004 and that the defendants' decision to use light, manoeuvrable vehicles was consistent with accepted military doctrine. The claimant’s expert’s suggestion that military armoured vehicles should have been used was found impracticable and unsupported by evidence of availability.
On bullet resistant windscreens, the court found that the defendants considered and explored their availability and practicability through inquiries with the vehicle maintenance organisation. The evidence indicated that such windscreens could not reasonably have been fitted before the deceased’s death. The claimant’s expert’s late internet-based assertion of availability was considered unreliable and lacking foundation.
On body armour collars, the court found no evidence that collars providing sufficient ballistic protection were available to the defendants, though it accepted that the defendants breached their duty by failing to provide any collar. However, causation was not established because the fatal bullet passed through an area not protected by a collar, and any protective effect was speculative.
The court rejected the claimant’s argument that the mission should have been aborted, accepting that the operational commander on the ground was best placed to judge immediate risk and that the mission continuation was reasonable.
The court declined to draw adverse inferences against the defendants for failure to call certain witnesses or for incomplete documentation, finding reasonable explanations for absences and acknowledging the challenging operational context and poor record-keeping.
Applying the principle from Brown v Corus, the court found an evidential burden on the defendants to explain failure to reduce risk by providing collars, which was not discharged. However, causation was lacking. The court therefore concluded no causative breach of duty was established.
The defendants’ alternative defence of volenti non fit injuria was considered academic due to the absence of causative breach but rejected on the merits as the deceased could not be taken to have consented to any breach of duty.
Holding and Implications
The court’s final decision was to DISMISS the claim for damages due to lack of causative breach of duty by the defendants.
The direct effect of this decision is that the defendants are not liable for the deceased’s death. No new legal precedent was established; the judgment applies established principles of employer duty of care, causation, and evidential burdens in the context of hazardous military-style operations overseas.
Alert