- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
HE v Hospital NHS Trust & Anor
Factual and Procedural Background
On 2 May 2003, an urgent application was heard in the Family Division involving a father seeking to save the life of his unconscious adult daughter, who suffered from severe medical complications related to congenital heart disease and bacterial endocarditis. The daughter, initially raised Muslim but later brought up as a Jehovah's Witness by her mother, had signed an Advance Medical Directive in 2001 refusing blood transfusions on religious grounds. She was admitted to a London Teaching Hospital in critical condition, where doctors indicated that blood transfusion might slow or reverse her deterioration, but the hospital refrained from administering blood products due to the Advance Directive and family opposition. The father contended that his daughter had renounced her Jehovah's Witness faith and would consent to blood transfusion if conscious. Due to the urgency, the court heard the matter ex parte with the Official Solicitor acting as litigation friend for the daughter. After reviewing evidence and legal authorities, the court made an order permitting treatment in the daughter’s best interests, including blood transfusion, pending formal proceedings.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Advance Medical Directive refusing blood transfusions remained valid and applicable given the daughter’s alleged change of faith and circumstances.
- The legal effect and validity of a clause in the Advance Directive purporting to make it irrevocable unless revoked in writing.
- The burden and standard of proof required to establish the continuing validity and applicability of an advance directive.
- The extent to which a previously competent adult patient may revoke or vary an advance directive, including orally or by conduct.
- The appropriate course of action for medical professionals when there is doubt about the validity of an advance directive in a life-threatening emergency.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments (Father)
- The daughter had rejected her Jehovah's Witness faith since December 2002 and reverted to Islam as a condition of her impending marriage.
- She ceased attending Jehovah's Witness meetings and services from early 2003, indicating a change in religious belief.
- The Advance Directive and hospital notes predated this change of faith and should no longer be relied upon.
- The daughter made no mention of the Advance Directive during a prior hospital admission when conscious.
- Reported statements by the daughter, including expressing a wish not to die, support the contention that she would now consent to blood transfusion.
- He requested the court to order the hospital to provide all necessary treatment, including blood transfusion, to preserve her life.
Respondent's Position (Hospital and Official Solicitor)
- The hospital relied on the Advance Directive and oral instructions refusing blood transfusions based on the daughter’s expressed religious beliefs at the time.
- The Official Solicitor, acting as litigation friend, did not oppose the court granting relief to permit treatment.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| In re T (Adult: Refusal of Treatment) [1993] Fam 95 | Establishes that a competent adult’s advance refusal of treatment is binding if clearly established and applicable; discusses burden of proof and societal interest in preserving life. | Used to confirm the need for clear and convincing evidence on validity and continuing applicability of an advance directive and that doubts are resolved in favor of preserving life. |
| Airedale NHS Trust v Bland [1993] AC 789 | Affirms the principle of self-determination requiring respect for a competent adult’s refusal of treatment even if it results in death; prior refusals must be carefully scrutinized for continuing applicability. | Supported the principle that prior refusals remain binding unless there is clear reason to doubt their validity or applicability. |
| In re C (Adult: Refusal of Treatment) [1994] 1 WLR 290 | This authority was cited as part of the established body of law on adult refusal of treatment. | Referenced as part of the legal framework governing advance directives and consent. |
| Re MB (Medical Treatment) [1997] 2 FLR 426 | Addresses consent and capacity issues in medical treatment decisions. | Used to support principles regarding capacity and consent. |
| St George's Healthcare NHS Trust v S [1999] Fam 26 | Concerns capacity and refusal of medical treatment by adults. | Referenced as part of the established legal principles regarding refusal of treatment. |
| Re AK (Medical Treatment: Consent) [2001] 1 FLR 129 | Confirms the binding nature of a competent adult’s refusal of treatment and the conditions under which emergency treatment without consent may be provided. | Informed the court’s view on the necessity to ensure advance directives reflect current wishes and the lawfulness of treatment in emergencies. |
| Re B (Consent to Treatment: Capacity) [2002] 1 FLR 1090 | Deals with capacity and consent issues in medical treatment. | Supported the court’s analysis of capacity and consent. |
| In re H (Minors) (Sexual Abuse: Standard of Proof) [1996] AC 563 | Discusses the standard of proof required in sensitive cases. | Applied to support the requirement for clear and convincing evidence in cases involving life and death decisions. |
| Re Dellow's Will Trusts [1964] 1 WLR 451 | Addresses standards of proof. | Used by analogy to emphasize the need for careful scrutiny of evidence in serious matters. |
| Cordell v Second Clanfield Properties Ltd [1969] 2 Ch 9 | Referenced regarding evidential burdens. | Referred to in a note concerning evidential burdens in the case. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court acknowledged the absolute right of a competent adult to refuse medical treatment, including life-saving treatment, and that such advance directives remain binding when the patient becomes incompetent. However, the court emphasized that the continuing validity and applicability of an advance directive is a question of fact subject to clear and convincing proof, especially where life is at stake.
The court found that an advance directive is inherently revocable and that any clause purporting to make it irrevocable, such as requiring revocation only in writing, is contrary to public policy and therefore void. The court reasoned that a patient who changes their mind must be able to revoke an advance directive orally or by conduct without formalities.
Applying these principles, the court considered the father's evidence that the daughter had abandoned her Jehovah's Witness faith, reverted to Islam, ceased attending religious meetings, and expressed a desire to live, thereby casting significant doubt on the continuing validity of the Advance Directive. Given these doubts and the absence of clear and convincing proof that the directive remained valid, the court resolved the doubt in favor of preserving life.
Consequently, the court declared that the daughter lacked capacity to decide on treatment and authorized the hospital to administer blood transfusions and other necessary treatment in her best interests despite the Advance Directive.
The court also expressed concern that the hospital had not proactively sought court guidance despite the life-threatening situation and urged medical professionals to seek judicial assistance promptly in such cases.
Holding and Implications
The court declared that the second defendant (the daughter) lacked capacity to decide whether or not to accept medical treatment and that it was lawful and in her best interests for the first defendant (the hospital) and medical staff to administer any necessary treatment, including blood transfusions, notwithstanding the existence of the advance directives.
The direct effect of this decision was to permit life-saving treatment to proceed immediately. The court’s analysis clarified that advance directives are inherently revocable and that any attempt to make them irrevocable or to impose formal conditions on revocation is void as contrary to public policy. This ruling reinforces the principle that doubts as to the validity of an advance directive must be resolved in favor of preserving life, emphasizing the need for clear and convincing evidence to sustain such directives in changed circumstances. The decision also underscores the duty of medical authorities to seek judicial declarations in cases of doubt to protect both patients and healthcare providers.
Alert