Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Mars UK Ltd v Teknowledge Ltd

England and Wales High Court (Patents Court)
Jun 11, 1999
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The Plaintiff, a leading designer and manufacturer of coin receiving and changing mechanisms, developed electronic coin discriminators that use sensors and algorithms to identify genuine coins and reject invalid discs ("slugs"). Earlier models used PROM memory chips, which were not reprogrammable, requiring physical replacement to update coin data. The Plaintiff designed a newer model, the Cashflow, employing reprogrammable EEPROM chips, accessible only via a proprietary encrypted communication protocol to prevent unauthorized reprogramming and fraud.

The Defendant, a small company skilled in coin discriminator technology and an approved agent for other industry leaders, reverse engineered the Cashflow discriminator's EEPROM to enable reprogramming ("re-calibration") without the Plaintiff's authorization. This activity prompted litigation by the Plaintiff alleging copyright infringement, database rights infringement, breach of confidence, and infringement under s.296 of the Copyright Designs and Patents Act 1988.

During proceedings, the Plaintiff narrowed its claims, focusing on copyright and database right infringements conceded by the Defendant, subject to a common law defence of repair derived from the House of Lords decision in British Leyland v Armstrong. The Plaintiff abandoned its s.296 claim and no longer contested the quality of the Defendant’s re-calibration work. The court was tasked with deciding the availability of the common law defence, whether the Defendant’s reverse engineering constituted breach of confidence, and whether any common law defence extended to breach of confidence.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether there is a common law defence to the conceded claims of copyright infringement and misuse of data related to the Defendant’s reverse engineering and reprogramming activities.
  2. Whether the Defendant’s reverse engineering activities amount to a breach of confidence in law.
  3. Whether any common law defence applicable to copyright and database rights also applies to breach of confidence claims.

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiff's Arguments

  • The Plaintiff argued that its copyright, database rights, and related intellectual property in the coin set data, discrimination algorithms, and communication protocols were infringed by the Defendant’s reproduction and use of these elements in developing and operating reprogramming software.
  • The Plaintiff contended that the common law "spare parts" defence established in British Leyland v Armstrong did not apply to computer programs or database rights, particularly after legislative changes embodied in the Copyright Designs and Patents Act 1988 and subsequent Community Directives.
  • It was argued that the encrypted information in the Cashflow discriminator should be treated as confidential, imposing a duty of confidence on the Defendant upon reverse engineering and decryption.
  • The Plaintiff maintained that the Defendant’s conduct breached confidence and that no common law defence excused this breach.

Defendant's Arguments

  • The Defendant admitted to infringing copyright and database rights but relied on a common law defence akin to the "right to repair" recognized in British Leyland v Armstrong, asserting entitlement to assess and analyze the Cashflow mechanisms despite the Plaintiff’s encryption.
  • The Defendant argued that the encryption did not impose a legal obligation of confidence because the machines were lawfully purchased and available on the open market, and the information was discoverable through reverse engineering.
  • It was contended that the breach of confidence claim was legally unsustainable, as the circumstances did not import an obligation of confidence.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
British Leyland v Armstrong [1986] AC 577 Established a common law "spare parts" defence to copyright infringement based on public policy to prevent control of aftermarket spares by manufacturers. The court examined whether this defence applied to computer programs and database rights and concluded it did not extend to the Defendant’s re-calibration activities.
Canon v Green Cartridge [1997] AC 728 Clarified and limited the British Leyland defence, holding it should not be extended beyond its original scope, especially not to consumables. The court relied on Lord Hoffmann’s analysis to reject extension of the defence to the Defendant’s activities involving software and database rights.
Coco v Clark [1969] RPC 41 Set out the three elements of breach of confidence: information must have quality of confidence, imparted in circumstances importing obligation, and unauthorized use causing detriment. The court applied this test and found the encrypted information did not possess the necessary quality of confidence due to lawful purchase and accessibility via reverse engineering.
AG v Guardian (Spycatcher) [1990] 1 AC 109 Confirmed the principle that a duty of confidence arises when confidential information is received with notice or agreement of confidentiality. The court distinguished the case, holding that no such notice or agreement existed here, and that the Defendant’s acquisition of information was lawful and not surreptitious.
Terrapin v Builders Supply [1960] RPC 128 Recognized the "springboard" doctrine in breach of confidence to prevent unfair commercial advantage from misuse of confidential information. The court acknowledged this principle but found it inapplicable because the Defendant obtained information through legitimate reverse engineering, not illegitimate appropriation.
Alfa Laval v Wincanton [1990] FSR 583 Recognized the owner’s right to dismantle a machine to discover how it works. The court cited this to support that lawful owners can reverse engineer their machines without incurring breach of confidence.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court began by analyzing the scope of the common law "spare parts" defence as articulated in British Leyland and refined in Canon. It noted that legislative developments, including the Copyright Designs and Patents Act 1988 and relevant European Directives, established comprehensive statutory regimes governing computer programs and database rights without providing for a repair or update exception. The court emphasized that it was not for judges to create exceptions contrary to explicit statutory schemes and community law.

Applying this reasoning, the court concluded that the common law defence did not survive or apply to the Defendant’s activities involving computer programs and database rights embodied in the Cashflow discriminator. Even if it did, the court found that the Defendant’s re-calibration went beyond any permissible repair analogy because altering the machine to accept new coins was not akin to repair but a modification involving the Plaintiff’s intellectual property.

On breach of confidence, the court applied the established three-part test from Coco v Clark. It found that the encrypted information lacked the necessary quality of confidence because the Cashflow discriminator was lawfully sold on the open market, and the information was accessible through reverse engineering by anyone with the requisite skill. The court rejected the Plaintiff’s contention that encryption alone imposed a duty of confidence, reasoning that mere difficulty or deliberate obstacles do not create confidentiality obligations absent a contractual or relational context.

The court distinguished this case from those involving surreptitious acquisition of information or unauthorized disclosure and held that the Defendant’s lawful acquisition and use of information did not breach confidence. Consequently, the court found no basis for extending any common law defence to breach of confidence claims.

Holding and Implications

The court’s final decision was as follows:

The Defendant infringed the Plaintiff’s copyright and database rights through its reverse engineering and reprogramming activities, and no common law defence of repair or spare parts applies to excuse this infringement.

The Defendant’s reverse engineering and decryption of encrypted information in the Cashflow discriminator did not constitute a breach of confidence as a matter of law.

The common law defence applicable to copyright infringement does not extend to breach of confidence claims in this context.

The direct effect of this ruling is that the Defendant is liable for copyright and database rights infringement but not for breach of confidence. The court emphasized that the statutory framework governs the rights and defences related to software and database protection, limiting judicially created exceptions. No new precedent was established beyond the application of existing principles to the facts.