- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
R Griggs Group Ltd & Ors v Evans & Ors
Factual and Procedural Background
A client, referred to as Griggs, commissioned an advertising agency to design a new combined logo merging two existing logos, "Dr Martens" and "AirWair," for use on Dr Martens footwear. The agency engaged a freelance designer, Mr Ross Evans, to create the logo in 1988. The issue arose over the ownership of the copyright in the combined logo, as Mr Evans, the legal owner of the copyright by virtue of being the author and not an employee, assigned the copyright to a third party, Raben Footwear Pty Limited, an Australian footwear company hostile to Griggs. Griggs claim to be the beneficial owners of the copyright and seek a declaration and formal assignment of the copyright to them. The dispute concerns the distinction between legal and equitable ownership of copyright in commissioned works, particularly logos, and the scope of implied terms in the contract between the parties.
Legal Issues Presented
- Who owns the copyright in a logo created by a freelance designer commissioned by a client, when nothing has been expressly agreed about copyright ownership?
- Whether the client (Griggs) is the beneficial owner of the copyright in the combined logo despite the legal title initially vesting in the freelance designer (Mr Evans).
- Whether there was an accord and satisfaction between Griggs and Mr Evans concerning the assignment of copyright prior to Mr Evans assigning it to Raben.
- Whether the client’s rights in the logo should be limited to a licence or extend to full ownership of the copyright.
Arguments of the Parties
Defendants' Arguments
- The copyright in the combined logo belongs initially to Mr Evans, the freelance designer, as he was not an employee of the agency or client.
- Mr Evans assigned the copyright to Raben Footwear Pty Limited, who are the current legal owners.
- The assignment from the advertising agency to Griggs is ineffective because the agency did not own the copyright.
- Mr Evans contends he was only commissioned to create point of sale material for the UK market and was not informed that the logo would be used globally on footwear, limiting the scope of any licence to Griggs.
Claimants' (Griggs') Arguments
- Griggs claim to be the beneficial owners of the copyright under equitable principles despite Mr Evans holding the legal title.
- It was obvious and "went without saying" that the client would need full rights to use and exclude others from using the logo, not merely a limited licence.
- They contend Mr Evans agreed to assign the copyright to them for a sum of money and legal costs in early May 2002, but this accord and satisfaction was not established.
- The commercial value of the logo arises from its use by Griggs on a large scale, not from the skill or labour of Mr Evans alone.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Robin Ray v. Classic FM plc [1998] FSR 622 | Equitable ownership of copyright in commissioned works and principles of implied terms in contracts. | Used to articulate the framework for determining whether the client or contractor owns the equitable interest in copyright. |
| Massine v de Basil [1936-45] MCC 233 | Implied term of assignment of copyright in commissioned works even if not employment contracts. | Supports that clients generally acquire beneficial copyright ownership by implication to give business efficacy. |
| Liverpool City Council v. Irwin [1977] AC 239 | Principles governing implication of contractual terms. | Guides the court’s approach to implying terms necessary to give business efficacy. |
| Philips Electronique v. BSB [1995] EMLR 472 | Conditions for implying terms in contracts. | Reinforces the strict criteria for implying terms, including necessity and obviousness. |
| Nichols Advanced Vehicle Systems Inc v. Rees [1979] RPC 127 | Necessity for assignment of copyright when client needs full rights including enforcement against third parties. | Applied to show why a mere licence is insufficient for logos intended for broad commercial exploitation. |
| Stovin-Bradford v. Volpoint Properties Ltd [1971] 1 Ch 1007 | Scope of licence granted in commissioned works related to the price paid and purpose contemplated. | Used to illustrate how limited payments may restrict the extent of implied licences. |
| Blair v. Osborne & Tompkins [1971] 21 QB 78 | Extent of implied licence correlated with full payment for the commissioned work. | Supports that full fees imply broader rights to use commissioned work. |
| Beck v. Montana Construction Pty [1964-5] NSWR 229 | Implied permission or licence to use commissioned material for contemplated purposes. | Affirmed the principle that engagement for reward implies consent to use material as agreed. |
| Meikle v. Maufe [1941] 3 All ER 144 | Limitations on implied licences not extending to new, unexpected profitable uses. | Clarifies that implied licences are confined to uses within the parties' contemplation at contract formation. |
| Exxon Corp v. Exxon Insurance Consultants International Ltd [1982] Ch 119 | No copyright in mere words or names. | Supports the distinction between copyright in stylised drawings versus words or phrases themselves. |
| Francis Day & Hunter Ltd v. Twentieth Century Fox Corpn [1940] AC 112 | No copyright in simple phrases lacking sufficient skill or labour. | Supports that copyright protects original drawings, not plain words or phrases. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court began by distinguishing between legal and equitable ownership of copyright. Under Section 11 of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988, the legal owner of copyright in a work created by a freelance designer is the designer himself, not the client. However, equitable ownership may belong to the client if an express or implied term of the contract provides for it.
The court reviewed established principles on implying terms into contracts, emphasizing strict criteria such as necessity, obviousness, and business efficacy, as set out in Liverpool City Council v. Irwin and related authorities.
Applying these principles, the court found that it was so obvious as to "go without saying" that the client intended to acquire full beneficial ownership of the copyright in the logo, not merely a licence limited to point of sale material in the UK. The client paid a fixed hourly rate to the designer without negotiating for a higher fee that might reflect broader rights, but the court did not find this to limit the implied ownership rights of the client.
The court rejected the argument that the client’s rights should be limited to an exclusive licence, noting that an exclusive licence is effectively similar to ownership but has practical disadvantages and is less appropriate in the context of a fixed fee commission.
Regarding the alleged accord and satisfaction between the client and the designer in 2002, the court found no binding agreement had been reached, as the parties had not agreed on the terms of the assignment, and the designer subsequently assigned the copyright to a third party.
Because the third party was not a purchaser for value without notice of the equitable interest, the court held that the equitable ownership remained with the client, entitling them to the copyright and a formal assignment.
Holding and Implications
The court held in favour of the Claimants (Griggs), declaring that they are the beneficial owners of the copyright in the combined logo and ordering that the copyright be formally assigned to them.
Implications: This decision confirms that in the absence of express agreement to the contrary, a client commissioning a logo from a freelance designer is the beneficial owner of the copyright by implication of contract, particularly where the logo is intended for broad commercial use. It underscores the importance of clarifying copyright ownership in commissioning contracts and demonstrates that equitable ownership can override legal title in such contexts. No new precedent was set beyond the application of established principles.
Alert