- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Twentieth Century Fox Film Corporation & Anor v Newzbin Ltd
Factual and Procedural Background
This case concerns an action for copyright infringement arising from the operation of a website called Newzbin, which indexes content on the Usenet system. The claimants are established film makers and distributors alleging that Newzbin facilitates piracy by locating, categorising, and enabling users to acquire unlawful copies of films. The defendant operates Newzbin and contends that the site is a content-agnostic search engine for Usenet, merely providing hyperlinks without participating in infringement.
The trial involved a change of legal representation for the defendant after evidence was closed, with new counsel instructed and the trial resuming thereafter. The court examined the nature of Usenet and Newzbin's structure, focusing particularly on whether Newzbin makes infringing copies available.
Usenet is an electronic bulletin board system supporting text and binary content, with binary files split into many parts posted across numerous messages. Newzbin indexes these messages into three main indices (RAW, Condensed, and Newzbin indices) and provides a facility (NZB files) enabling premium members to download and assemble entire binary works, including films.
Newzbin operates a membership system with basic (free) and premium (paid) levels, with premium members able to download files. The site categorises content extensively, especially films, and employs a large team of editors who prepare detailed reports on indexed content. Despite disclaimers and terms prohibiting unlawful activity, the court found these to be superficial and inconsistent with the site's operation.
Evidence showed the vast majority of films indexed are commercial and likely protected by copyright. The defendant was aware of infringing activity on Newzbin and had received notices from rights holders but took no effective action to prevent infringement or remove infringing content.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the defendant has infringed the claimants' copyrights by authorising acts of infringement by its members.
- Whether the defendant has procured, encouraged, or engaged in a common design with its members to infringe copyright.
- Whether the defendant has communicated the claimants' copyright works to the public.
- Whether the defendant, as a service provider with actual knowledge of infringement, is subject to an injunction under section 97A of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988.
Arguments of the Parties
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| C.B.S. Songs Ltd and ors v Amstrad Consumer Electronics Plc [1988] 1 A.C. 1013 | Definition and scope of "authorisation" in copyright infringement; mere facilitation does not constitute authorisation. | Used to establish that authorisation means granting or purporting to grant the right to infringe; mere enablement or assistance is insufficient. |
| Monckton v. Pathe Freres Pathephone Ltd. [1914] 1 K.B. 395 | Authorisation requires the grant of a right to infringe. | Referenced to explain the meaning of authorisation in copyright law. |
| Evans v. Hulton (1924) 131 L.T. 534 | Authorisation can be implied from the object of the sale or transaction. | Used to illustrate circumstances where authorisation is inferred. |
| Falcon v. Famous Players Film Co. [1926] 2 K.B. 474 | Authorisation of infringing acts through performance rights. | Used to explain that authorisation involves sanctioning infringing acts. |
| Moorhouse v. University of New South Wales [1976] R.P.C. 151 | Control and omission to take steps to prevent infringement can amount to authorisation. | Referenced to consider control and knowledge in authorisation. |
| C.B.S. Inc. v. Ames Records & Tapes Ltd. [1982] Ch. 91 | Distinction between enabling and authorising infringement. | Used to reject liability based on mere supply or assistance. |
| RCA Corporation v. John Fairfax & Sons Ltd. [1982] R.P.C. 91 | Scope of authorisation and control over infringing acts. | Considered in assessing the extent of control required for authorisation. |
| Cooper v Universal Music Australia Pty Ltd [2006] FCAFC 187 | Authorisation of infringement by website operator with knowledge and active facilitation. | Applied by analogy to find defendant liable for authorising infringement via website structure and conduct. |
| Roadshow Films Pty Ltd v iiNet Ltd (No3) [2010] FCA 24 | ISP liability for subscriber infringement; no authorisation absent control or sanction. | Distinguished on facts; defendant here exercised more control and active involvement. |
| Unilever plc v Gillette (UK) Ltd [1989] RPC 583 | Common design liability requires concerted action or agreement. | Used to explain elements of joint tortfeasance and common design. |
| Credit Lyonnais Bank Nederland NV v Export Credits Guarantee Dept [1998] 1 Lloyd's Rep 19 | Joint tortfeasor liability requires conspiracy, procurement or inducement. | Applied to assess whether defendant's conduct amounted to joint infringement. |
| Sabaf SpA v MFI Furniture Centres Ltd [2002] EWCA Civ 976, [2003] RPC 264 | Extent of involvement required for joint tortfeasor liability. | Used to clarify that mere supply is insufficient without making the infringing act one's own. |
| L'Oréal v eBay [2009] EWHC 1094, [2009] RPC 21 | Liability for facilitation of infringement requires more than knowledge and profit motive. | Referenced to underscore limits of liability for intermediaries. |
| Case C-306/05 Sociedad General de Autores y Editores de España (SGAE) v Rafael Hoteles SA [2006] ECR I-11519 | Broad interpretation of "communication to the public" under Directive 2001/29/EC; intervention to provide access constitutes communication. | Applied to conclude defendant made works available to public through active intervention and benefit. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court began by examining the nature of Usenet and the structure and operation of Newzbin, accepting expert evidence on how Newzbin indexes and facilitates access to binary content, particularly films. It found that Newzbin's sophisticated indexing system and NZB file facility significantly ease the process of obtaining infringing copies, which would otherwise be onerous and time-consuming.
The court rejected the defendant's claim of content agnosticism, finding that Newzbin actively focuses on binary content, especially films, and encourages editors to report on films, including infringing copies. The defendant's disclaimers and restrictions were held to be superficial and inconsistent with the site's actual operation.
The court found overwhelming evidence that the vast majority of films indexed are commercial and likely protected by copyright, and that the defendant was well aware of infringement occurring through Newzbin. Despite knowledge and notice from rights holders, the defendant took no effective steps to prevent or remove infringing content or editors.
Applying established legal principles, the court determined that the defendant had authorised infringement by granting premium members access and facilities to make infringing copies, procured and engaged in a common design with members to infringe by actively facilitating and encouraging infringement, and communicated the claimants' works to the public through active intervention and benefit from the service.
Regarding the claim for an injunction under section 97A, the court held that the defendant is a service provider with actual knowledge of infringement, but the injunction's scope should be limited to the claimants' repertoire of films to provide effective relief without overbroad restrictions.
Holding and Implications
HOLDING: The defendant is liable for copyright infringement on three grounds: authorisation of infringement by its members; procurement and participation in a common design to infringe with its members; and communication of the claimants' copyrighted films to the public.
IMPLICATIONS: The court concluded that the defendant's conduct constituted deliberate and knowing facilitation of infringement, justifying an injunction to restrain further infringement relating to the claimants' repertoire of films. The decision underscores the liability of intermediaries who actively facilitate copyright infringement and have actual knowledge of such infringement. No new precedent was established beyond the application of existing principles to the facts.
Alert