- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Kimathi & Ors v Foreign and Commonwealth Office
Factual and Procedural Background
This opinion concerns the Defendant's application to exclude certain witness statements and hearsay evidence in a group litigation order involving over 40,000 claimants. The litigation arises from allegations of mistreatment during a historical emergency period in Kenya. The Defendant seeks to exclude: (i) witness statements by historians prepared for previous related litigation, (ii) corroborative witness statements by claimants on the Group Register, and (iii) hearsay statements including extracts from a historian's book and statements by deceased claimants. The Court was asked to determine the admissibility of these categories of evidence and whether to permit cross-examination of hearsay statement makers who may still be alive. The proceedings are part of a broader test case process with 25 test claimants selected to address generic and specific issues.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the witness statements by historians prepared for previous litigation are admissible evidence in the current proceedings.
- Whether corroborative witness statements by additional claimants on the Group Register should be admitted as relevant and probative evidence.
- Whether hearsay statements, including extracts from a historian's book and statements by deceased claimants, should be admitted.
- Whether the Defendant should be permitted to cross-examine the makers of hearsay statements who are or may be alive.
- How the Court should exercise its case management powers under CPR Rule 32.1 and related provisions to exclude or admit evidence in the interests of justice and proportionality.
Arguments of the Parties
Defendant's Arguments
- The historians' witness statements are not admissible factual evidence but amount to historical commentary or opinion, which is inadmissible.
- The historians' statements were prepared for previous litigation and were not accepted as evidence of fact at trial in that litigation.
- The corroborative claimant witness statements do not provide direct evidence of the offences alleged in the test cases and lack sufficient similarity in perpetrators, location, or timing.
- The hearsay statements lack probative value, involve multiple hearsay, were made long after the events, and the Defendant cannot effectively cross-examine the makers.
- Admitting the additional evidence would cause disproportionate burden, increase costs, lengthen the trial, and potentially cause prejudice.
- The Defendant seeks permission to cross-examine hearsay statement makers who are alive but objects to the adequacy of steps taken to locate them.
Claimants' Arguments
- The historians' evidence provides factual context and assists the Court in understanding the documentation and drawing inferences about government knowledge and responsibility.
- The historians are not giving opinion evidence but factual evidence based on examination of historical records.
- The corroborative witness statements support the evidence of the test claimants and provide similar fact evidence relevant to generic issues such as document destruction and systemic mistreatment.
- The hearsay statements, while imperfect, are proportionate and reasonable efforts have been made to identify witnesses for cross-examination where possible.
- The historians' evidence facilitates the presentation of complex documentary evidence and helps the Court navigate the vast materials.
- The Claimants are prepared to call historians for cross-examination if required and to excise any inadmissible opinion evidence.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| [2011] EWHC 1913 (QB) & [2012] EWHC 2678 (QB) (Mutua litigation) | Admissibility and role of historians' evidence in related proceedings | Confirmed historians' statements were not accepted as admissible evidence of fact at trial but treated as akin to academic articles; relevant to assessing admissibility in current case. |
| CPR 32.12 | Use of witness statements from previous proceedings | Applied to determine whether historians' statements were "put in evidence at a hearing held in public," allowing their use under the rule. |
| CPR 32.8 and Practice Direction 32 | Formal requirements for witness statements | Rejected Defendant's objection on form, allowing statements from previous proceedings to be used with minor formal adjustments. |
| CPR 32.4 | Definition of a witness statement | Considered in relation to historians' statements and their admissibility as factual evidence. |
| Rogers v Hoyle [2014] EWCA Civ 257 | Admissibility of expert evidence and accident reports | Used to analyze the nature of historians' evidence and the inadmissibility of opinion on disputed facts not requiring expertise. |
| Dombo Beheer v The Netherlands [1993] 18 EHRR 213 | Right to give evidence and fairness under Article 6 ECHR | Rejected by Court as irrelevant to admissibility of historians' factual evidence. |
| O'Brien v Chief Constable of South Wales Police [2005] 2 AC 534 | Admissibility and case management of similar fact evidence | Applied to assess admission of corroborative witness statements and factors for excluding evidence in exercise of case management powers. |
| JP Morgan Chase Bank and others v Springwell Navigation Corporation [2005] EWCA Civ 1602 | Limits on similar fact evidence | Referenced in relation to limiting similar fact evidence but not applied to exclude corroborative witness statements. |
| Laughton v Shalaby [2014] EWCA Civ 1450 | Probative value of similar fact evidence | Referenced to emphasize that extraneous evidence must be similar fact to be probative. |
| Great Future International v Sealand Housing Corporation [2002] EWCA Civ 1183 | Use of case management powers to exclude evidence | Guided the Court's circumspect exercise of exclusion powers under CPR Rule 32.1. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court carefully considered the Defendant's applications to exclude various categories of evidence under the Civil Procedure Rules and relevant case law. Regarding the historians' witness statements, the Court found that although these statements were put in evidence at a public hearing in previous litigation, they were not accepted as admissible factual evidence at trial and largely amounted to historical commentary or opinion. The Court concluded that the historians do not provide relevant admissible factual evidence because they were not involved in the events and their opinions on documentary inferences are inadmissible. The Court also expressed concern about the potential for undue influence and confusion if such evidence were admitted. Consequently, the historians' evidence was excluded.
With respect to the corroborative witness statements from additional claimants on the Group Register, the Court acknowledged that these witnesses do not provide direct evidence of the offences in the test cases but may provide relevant similar fact evidence supporting generic issues such as detention conditions and forced labour. The Court found that some of this evidence could be highly probative, especially where it corroborates or supports test claimant evidence. Although the Defendant raised concerns about proportionality, burden, and fairness, the Court concluded that it would be unjust and disproportionate to exclude this evidence at this stage. The Court exercised its case management powers to admit this evidence subject to ongoing case management and future applications if circumstances change.
Regarding hearsay statements, including extracts from a historian's book and statements by deceased claimants, the Court noted the statutory provisions under the Civil Evidence Act 1995 and CPR allowing hearsay evidence but retaining discretion to exclude on grounds of fairness and proportionality. The Court found the hearsay evidence from deceased claimants on the Group Register admissible for similar reasons as the corroborative witnesses. However, the hearsay statements from the historian's book were found to have very limited probative value, involved multiple hearsay, were made long after the events, and lacked opportunity for cross-examination. The Court concluded that admitting this hearsay evidence would risk distorting the trial, causing prejudice and disproportionate burden, and therefore excluded it under its case management powers.
Finally, the Court granted the Defendant permission to cross-examine makers of hearsay statements who are alive but noted that the Defendant must take the initiative to call those witnesses. The Court emphasized that the Claimants are not required to call such witnesses or to expend disproportionate resources to trace them.
Holding and Implications
The Court DENIED the Defendant's application to exclude corroborative witness statements from additional claimants on the Group Register, allowing this evidence to be admitted as potentially probative similar fact evidence. The Court ALLOWED the Defendant's application to exclude the historians' witness statements and hearsay statements extracted from the historian's book, finding them inadmissible as factual evidence or disproportionate to admit.
The Defendant was granted permission to cross-examine makers of hearsay statements who are or may be alive, but the responsibility to call those witnesses lies with the Defendant. The Court's ruling preserves the integrity of the test case process and balances the need for comprehensive evidence with the overriding objective of just, proportionate, and fair case management. No new legal precedent was established; rather, the Court applied existing principles to complex evidential issues in large-scale group litigation.
Alert