- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Liffe Administration and Management v Pinkava & Anor
Factual and Procedural Background
The appellant, referred to as Plaintiff, was employed by the respondent, Company A, as a manager in its Interest Rate Product Management Team starting 21st July 2001. In July 2004, Plaintiff devised a system and related inventions enabling the trading of certain financial instruments on an electronic exchange, which had not previously been traded in this manner. Plaintiff was promoted to senior manager in September 2004. In January 2005, Plaintiff was informed that he, not Company A, was entitled to the inventions. Plaintiff filed four US patent applications related to these inventions in April 2005. Plaintiff's employment with Company A ended in July 2005.
Company A initiated proceedings in July 2005 claiming entitlement to the confidential information and patent applications concerning the system. Plaintiff filed a counter-application seeking recognition as the owner of the inventions. Both actions, including Plaintiff's company as a party, were heard by Judge K over ten days in early 2006. The judge concluded that the inventions were not made in the course of Plaintiff's normal duties but were made in the course of duties specifically assigned to him, with circumstances such that an invention might reasonably be expected to result. Consequently, Company A was declared owner of the inventions. Plaintiff appealed this decision with permission, disputing the findings concerning the assigned duties and reasonable expectation, while Company A contested the finding on normal duties.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the inventions were made in the course of Plaintiff's normal duties as an employee of Company A.
- Whether the inventions were made in the course of duties specifically assigned to Plaintiff outside his normal duties.
- Whether the circumstances were such that an invention might reasonably be expected to result from the carrying out of those duties.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The judge was correct in concluding the inventions were not made in the course of Plaintiff's normal duties.
- The judge erred in concluding the inventions were made in the course of duties specifically assigned to Plaintiff.
- The judge erred in concluding that the circumstances were such that an invention might reasonably be expected to result from the carrying out of those duties.
Respondent's Arguments
- The judge was correct in concluding the inventions were made in the course of duties specifically assigned to Plaintiff.
- The judge erred in concluding the inventions were not made in the course of Plaintiff's normal duties.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| British Reinforced Concrete Engineering Co Ltd v Lind (1917) 34 RPC 101 | Determination of ownership based on contract terms and circumstances of invention; invention made pursuant to specific tasks assigned to employee belongs to employer. | Used to illustrate that employment terms and particular assignment circumstances determine ownership; supported the conclusion that specifically assigned duties can confer ownership to employer. |
| Re Charles Selz's Application (1953) 71 RPC 158 | Invention ownership depends on whether invention was made in course of employer’s business or duties. | Referenced to contrast cases where invention was held to belong to employee as it was outside employer’s business scope. |
| Patchett v Stirling Engineering Co. Ltd (1955) 72 RPC 50 | Common law principle that inventions made in the course of employment belong to employer unless employee has recognized beneficial interest. | Confirmed the trustee relationship of employee holding invention rights for employer when made in course of employment. |
| Harris' Patent [1985] RPC 19 | Interpretation of "normal duties" and "reasonable expectation" under s.39 Patents Act 1977. | Guided the court’s interpretation of statutory criteria for ownership, emphasizing the objective test of whether invention might reasonably be expected from duties. |
| Greater Glasgow Health Board's Application [1996] RPC 207 | Assessment of employee's normal duties considering contract and actual work performed. | Supported the approach of examining both contractual terms and real duties to define normal duties under s.39. |
| Electrolux v Hudson [1977] FSR 312 | Contractual terms that unreasonably restrain trade (e.g., overbroad assignment clauses) may be invalid. | Referenced to explain limits on contractual terms affecting employee invention rights and support statutory provisions preventing contracting out. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court began by interpreting the statutory framework under s.39 of the Patents Act 1977, which governs ownership of employee inventions. It emphasized that ownership depends on whether the invention was made in the course of the employee's normal duties or duties specifically assigned to him, and whether it was reasonably expected that an invention might result from those duties.
The court reviewed the factual matrix, including Plaintiff's employment contract, job descriptions, and evolving responsibilities. It found that by July 2004, the design of exchange tradable credit derivatives had become part of Plaintiff's normal duties, extending beyond the initial contractual scope. This conclusion considered the evolving nature of duties, performance appraisals, and the ongoing project assigned in December 2003.
The court rejected Plaintiff’s argument that "normal duties" should be narrowly construed as only day-to-day or primary duties, affirming the ordinary meaning of "normal" and recognizing that duties may evolve over time. It also upheld the judge’s conclusion that the expression "business as usual" used in instructions did not limit the scope of Plaintiff’s duties.
On the issue of reasonable expectation, the court held that the statutory test is objective but applied to the circumstances of the particular employee and his duties. It accepted that Plaintiff's inventive abilities were a relevant circumstance insofar as they affected the expectation that an invention might reasonably result from his duties. The court rejected the notion that the invention must be precisely the one expected or that the employee must have been explicitly asked to develop that specific invention.
The court further examined relevant case law and statutory provisions, concluding that the statutory scheme was intended to be broadly consistent with the common law principles but with enhancements, including statutory compensation rights and invalidation of contracting out provisions that diminish employee rights.
Accordingly, the court found that the inventions were made in the course of Plaintiff's normal duties, or alternatively, his specifically assigned duties, and that it was reasonably to be expected that inventions might result from those duties. The court therefore upheld the ownership of the inventions by Company A.
Holding and Implications
The appeal is dismissed.
The court held that the inventions made by Plaintiff belong to Company A under s.39(1)(a) of the Patents Act 1977, on the basis that they were made in the course of Plaintiff’s normal duties or, alternatively, duties specifically assigned to him, and that it was reasonably to be expected that an invention might result from the carrying out of those duties.
This decision confirms the application of s.39 to inventions made by employees whose duties include innovation and development of new products, recognizing that duties may evolve over time and that reasonable expectation is an objective test applied in context. The ruling does not establish new precedent beyond reaffirming the statutory framework and its interpretation consistent with earlier case law. The direct effect is that Company A retains ownership of the inventions in dispute, while Plaintiff may be entitled to statutory compensation under the Patents Act.
Alert