- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Merlet & Anor v Mothercare Public Ltd
Factual and Procedural Background
The first Plaintiff, a designer with a focus on children's clothing, created a baby cape called the "Raincosy," featuring a hood and drawstrings to provide a cocoon shape, with attachments for a baby carrier known as the "Kangourou." The second Plaintiff, a UK company, manufactures and sells clothes designed by the first Plaintiff. The Defendant is a significant retailer of baby and young children's products.
The Plaintiffs sued the Defendant for copyright infringement, alleging that the Defendant copied the "Raincosy" design in producing a competing product called the "Garry Cape." The Defendant had obtained a production model of the "Raincosy" and instructed a seamstress to sample and measure it, leading to the creation of their own product.
Initially, the Plaintiffs relied on two alleged "artistic works" for their claim: a prototype garment and two drawings (cutting plans) of the "Raincosy." The trial judge found against the Plaintiffs on both sources, and the Plaintiffs accepted that the prototype garment was not a "work of artistic craftsmanship" under the Copyright Act 1956.
The drawings, created by the first Plaintiff, consisted of cutting plans showing the shapes and dimensions of the garment's components. The first drawing was made in early July 1980, and a second, more detailed drawing of the hood was made later. These drawings were used by a manufacturer to produce the production model of the "Raincosy," which was subsequently copied by the Defendant.
The trial judge initially found that the manufacturer used the Plaintiffs' cutting plan but later expressed doubt about the significance of the drawings in the production process. This appeal challenges that conclusion.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the drawings (cutting plans) created by the Plaintiffs qualify as original artistic works protected by copyright under the Copyright Act 1956.
- Whether the Defendant infringed the Plaintiffs' copyright by copying the "Raincosy," specifically in relation to the drawings.
- Whether the statutory defence under section 9(8) of the Copyright Act 1956 applies, exempting the Defendant from infringement liability.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellants' Arguments
- The drawings P2 and P7 are original artistic works deserving copyright protection.
- The Defendant's product reproduced a substantial part of these drawings, constituting copyright infringement.
- The non-expert observer would recognize the Defendant's product as a reproduction of the drawings, negating the applicability of the statutory defence under section 9(8).
- The non-expert should be allowed to consider associated contemporary drawings (such as P7) when assessing reproduction under section 9(8).
Respondent's Arguments
- The originality in the cutting plan (P2) resides only in the layout of panels, not in the shape or dimensions of the panels themselves.
- The Defendant did not copy a substantial part of the drawings because it created its own cutting plan using measurements obtained from the Plaintiffs' product.
- The statutory defence under section 9(8) applies because the Defendant's product would not appear to a non-expert as a reproduction of the two-dimensional drawings.
- The non-expert observer would view the drawing as an intermediate step in manufacturing, not as a representation of the final product.
- The non-expert should not consider the later drawing (P7) when assessing reproduction under section 9(8) because it is not contemporary with P2 and there is no reference to it on P2.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| British Northrop Ltd. v. Texteam Blackburn Ltd. & Anr. [1974] RPC 57 | Originality in copyright: copyright protects the form of expression, not ideas; drawings must originate with the author and not be copied. | The court adopted the principle that simplicity does not exclude copyright, and found the Plaintiffs' drawings to be original artistic works. |
| University of London Press Ltd. v. University Tutorial Press Ltd. [1916] 2 Ch 601 | Originality requires the expression to originate with the author, not copied from another work. | Supported the finding that the Plaintiffs' drawings were original and protected. |
| Ladbrooke (Football) Ltd. v. William Hill (Football) Ltd. [1964] 1 WLR 273 | Substantial part of a work is judged by quality, not quantity; unoriginal parts of a work are not protected. | The court applied this to assess whether the Defendant copied a substantial part of the drawings, concluding the shape and dimensions were sufficiently original. |
| L.B. (Plastics) Ltd. v. Swish Products Ltd. [1979] 1 RPC 551 | Section 9(8) defence: conversion from two-dimensional to three-dimensional form infringes copyright only if the object appears to a non-expert as a reproduction of the artistic work. | The court used this precedent to interpret the statutory defence and the test of lay recognition in the current case. |
| Solar Thomson Engineering Co. Ltd. v. Barton [1977] RFC 537 | Interpretation of drawings: non-expert observer may interpret a drawing in light of contemporary associated drawings. | The court rejected its application here because the associated drawing was not contemporary and no reference existed on the original drawing. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court began by affirming that the Plaintiffs' drawings (P2 and P7) are original artistic works protected under the Copyright Act 1956. The court emphasized that copyright protects the expression of ideas, not the ideas themselves, and that the drawings involved sufficient skill and labour to qualify for protection.
Regarding infringement, the court acknowledged that the Defendant copied the Plaintiffs' production model but did not use the Plaintiffs' cutting plan, instead creating its own. However, since the production model was made using the Plaintiffs' drawings, the Defendant's product embodied a substantial part of the Plaintiffs' drawings, particularly the shape and size of the garment panels.
The court distinguished the limited use of the second drawing (P7), finding that it did not constitute a substantial part of the infringement.
The court then considered the statutory defence under section 9(8), which protects a defendant from infringement if the three-dimensional object does not appear to a non-expert as a reproduction of the two-dimensional drawing. The court concluded that the non-expert observer would not recognize the Defendant's product as a reproduction of the first drawing (P2) alone, especially since the later drawing (P7) was not contemporaneous and was not referenced on P2.
Consequently, the court held that the statutory defence applies, exempting the Defendant from liability for infringement.
Holding and Implications
The court's final decision was to DISMISS THE APPEAL.
The direct effect of this decision is that the Defendant is not liable for copyright infringement under the facts presented, due to the statutory defence under section 9(8) of the Copyright Act 1956. No new precedent was established beyond the application of existing principles to the specific drawings and products involved. Costs were awarded against the Plaintiffs, and leave to appeal was refused.
Alert