- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Pissaridou v Rosser
Factual and Procedural Background
This case concerns a reference to determine the open market value of the freehold interest in a barn, outbuildings, and land at a farm property pursuant to an application under section 222(4) of the Inheritance Tax Act 1984. The application followed a Notice of Determination under section 221 of the same Act relating to the deemed disposal of the subject property for inheritance tax purposes on the death of the deceased on 6 June 2001. The open market value was assessed at £80,000, which was disputed by the respondent taxpayer who contended that the property had no additional value beyond the agricultural value, agreed at £40,000. The reference was heard under the Simplified Procedure of the Lands Tribunal Rules 1996.
The deceased and her late husband had farmed the property since 1932, purchasing the freehold in 1958. In 1989, most of the land was transferred to the respondent taxpayer and her husband, who farmed it alongside their own property. The farmhouse, barn, outbuildings, and approximately 2 acres of land were retained by the deceased couple, with the buildings used by the respondent and her husband in their farming activities. The deceased died in June 2001, the valuation date for this determination. The farmhouse and grounds' value was agreed, leaving the barn, outbuildings, and 2 acres of land as the subject of dispute.
Prior proceedings included a determination by the Special Commissioner that the barn and 2 acres were eligible for agricultural relief under section 116 of the 1984 Act, while the farmhouse was not. The valuation dispute centered on whether the barn's open market value exceeded its agricultural value due to potential residential conversion.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether there was a realistic likelihood of obtaining planning permission for the conversion of the barn to a single residential unit at the valuation date.
- Whether the open market value of the barn and land exceeded its agricultural value based on this likelihood.
Arguments of the Parties
Applicant's Arguments
- The valuation basis under section 160 of the 1984 Act is the price a willing purchaser would pay a willing seller in the open market at the date of death, regardless of any intention to sell.
- Although no planning permission had been sought or obtained, the open market value should reflect the possibility that permission would be granted if applied for, as supported by precedent in Prosser v Commissioners of Inland Revenue.
- The barn was agricultural property at the date of death, valued at £40,000, but the disputed issue was whether the open market value was higher due to potential residential development.
- The District Valuer, with extensive local experience, concluded that the barn's value with planning permission would be £120,000, and the agreed figure of £80,000 represented a deduction for risk and time involved in obtaining permission.
- Investigations, including oral enquiries at the planning office, indicated no objection in principle to conversion under the relevant local planning policies (Unitary Development Plan 1996, policy H8).
- The barn and surrounding area met the planning criteria for conversion, including architectural merit, structural soundness, and minimal adverse effects on traffic, wildlife, and agricultural interests.
- Evidence of a nearby barn conversion granted planning permission supported the likelihood of success.
- The hypothetical vendor and purchaser would consider potential residential use in valuing the property, even if permission had not yet been obtained.
Respondent Taxpayer's Arguments
- The respondent initially did not contest the £80,000 valuation but later withdrew agreement after realizing tax implications.
- Enquiries with the local planning authority indicated that planning permission for residential conversion would be unlikely, citing policy H8 and poor site access.
- A planning assistant provided a written opinion stating the barn was in open countryside within a protected area and that conversion would be contrary to planning policies.
- The barn was maintained, in active agricultural use, not obsolete or redundant, and provided important wildlife habitat.
- The District Valuer failed to adequately research planning conditions and restrictions before valuing the property.
- The property’s access was poor and potentially hazardous, further diminishing the likelihood of permission.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Lynall v Inland Revenue Commissioners (1972) AC 680 | Definition of open market value as price a hypothetical willing purchaser would pay a willing vendor on the date of death. | Confirmed that valuation is hypothetical and based on open market assumptions at valuation date. |
| Prosser v Commissioners of Inland Revenue (2000, unreported, Lands Tribunal ref DET/1/2000) | Valuation may reflect a chance (e.g., 50%) of obtaining planning permission, affecting market value. | Supported applicant’s approach to apply a risk-adjusted value reflecting potential for residential conversion. |
| Inland Revenue Commissioners v Gray [1994] STC 60 | Hypothetical vendor and purchaser behave as reasonable commercial parties in the open market with full inquiries; open market is real and competitive. | Supported the approach that valuation includes consideration of potential alternative uses and market demand. |
| Inland Revenue Commissioners v Crossman [1937] AC 26 | Clarification of the hypothetical willing buyer and seller concept in valuation at date of death. | Referenced in defining the valuation framework and confirming the hypothetical nature of the transaction. |
| Rosser v Inland Revenue Commissioners [2003] IRC STC (SCD) 311 | Determination of eligibility for agricultural relief on barn and land for inheritance tax purposes. | Established that the barn and two acres qualified for agricultural relief, framing the valuation dispute. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court focused on the sole issue of whether there was a realistic prospect of obtaining planning permission for residential conversion of the barn at the valuation date. The court accepted the statutory framework under the Inheritance Tax Act 1984, particularly section 160, which defines market value as the price a property might reasonably fetch in the open market without assuming any reduction for sale of the whole property at once.
The court found that the applicant's valuer had taken an appropriate approach by considering the potential for planning permission and adjusting the value to reflect risk and time involved. The oral enquiry at the planning office and the valuer’s local knowledge were deemed sufficient to support the conclusion that the property complied with the relevant planning policy criteria in force at the valuation date.
The court noted that the respondent’s evidence regarding planning objections was based on a later policy version and that some factual assertions (e.g., Site of Special Scientific Interest) were incorrect. The court found that the property was in a fringe urban area with precedent for barn conversions nearby, supporting the likelihood of permission.
The court was persuaded that the hypothetical vendor and purchaser would value the property reflecting the potential for residential use, even though no application had been made by the valuation date. The risk-adjusted figure of £80,000 was accepted as appropriate.
Holding and Implications
The court DETERMINED that the open market value of the freehold interest in the subject property as at 6 June 2001 was £80,000.
The decision confirms that for inheritance tax valuation purposes, the potential for obtaining planning permission for an alternative use can be factored into the open market value, subject to a realistic prospect of success. The ruling resolves the dispute between agricultural and open market values for the property but does not establish new legal precedent beyond applying established principles. No order for costs was made due to the use of the Simplified Procedure and absence of exceptional circumstances.
Alert