- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Football Association Premier League Ltd & Ors v QC Leisure & Ors
Factual and Procedural Background
These three actions concern the use of foreign decoder cards in the UK to access foreign transmissions of live Premier League football matches. The claimants allege that dealing in and use of such cards in the UK infringes their rights under section 298 of the Copyright Designs and Patents Act 1988 ("the CDPA") and copyrights in various artistic, musical works, films, and sound recordings embodied in the Premier League match coverage.
The Premier League is the leading professional football league competition in England, operated by the first claimant ("FAPL"), which is owned by the 20 Premier League clubs. FAPL organizes the filming and licensing of broadcasting rights to live matches, which are territorially exclusive and granted in three-year terms. The evidence relates to seasons 2004/5, 2005/6, and 2006/7, but relief is sought for future seasons as well.
Sub-licensees in Greece, the Middle East, and North Africa broadcast live satellite transmissions. The second claimant ("NetMed") and third claimant (collectively "NOVA") operate in Greece, broadcasting on SuperSport channels via NOVA satellite decoder cards. In the Middle East and North Africa, Arab Media Corporation ("AMC") and its subsidiaries Arab Radio and Television Network ("ART") and Jordan Media City ("JMC") were involved, with ART decoder cards enabling reception.
In the UK, the exclusive licensee for live broadcasts is BSkyB Ltd ("Sky"). The claimants assert that territorial licensing is justifiable but threatened by the use of foreign decoder cards in the UK, which undermine exclusivity and revenue streams.
The claimants brought three test cases: two against suppliers of equipment and decoder cards enabling reception of non-Sky satellite channels (NOVA and ART), and one against licensees or operators of four pubs that showed live Premier League matches broadcast on ART channels.
The defendants in the first action are QC Leisure and Mr Richardson, who supply NOVA and ART decoder cards. The second action defendants are AV Station PLC ("AV") and Mr Chamberlain, supplying NOVA cards only. The third ("Madden") action relates to four pubs where ART decoder cards were used to screen matches, with various individual defendants as licensees or managers.
The claimants allege infringement of rights under section 298 of the CDPA by trading or possessing decoder cards designed to access protected services without authorization, and copyright infringement by copying, displaying, performing, and communicating works to the public. The defendants contend the cards are lawfully issued by the broadcasters and the case concerns lawful cross-border trade within the European single market, challenging territorial restrictions.
The parties identified numerous legal and factual issues, including the scope and meaning of Directive 98/84/EC ("Conditional Access Directive"), authorization of decoder cards, subsistence and ownership of copyright works, the activities of the Madden defendants, acts of infringement (copying, communication, public performance), and related Community law questions including free movement and competition law.
Legal Issues Presented
- What is the correct interpretation of the expression "illicit device" under Directive 98/84/EC, and does it include decoder cards lawfully issued by service providers but used outside authorized territories?
- Does FAPL have a cause of action under Directive 98/84/EC and UK law in respect of decoder cards issued to NOVA and ART?
- Are the defendants' dealings in or possession of NOVA and ART decoder cards for commercial purposes unlawful under section 298 of the CDPA and Directive 98/84/EC?
- Did NOVA or ART authorize the circulation and use of their decoder cards outside their licensed territories?
- Do the claimants have subsisting copyright and title in the various film, artistic, sound recording, and musical works embodied in the broadcasts?
- Were copies of substantial parts of the copyright works made in decoder boxes or on television screens, and do any statutory exceptions apply?
- Does communication to the public or public performance of the works occur in the pubs, and is it infringing?
- Does Directive 93/83/EEC ("Satellite and Copyright Directive") provide a defense to the copyright claims?
- Are the claimants' territorial restrictions on decoder cards and broadcasts compatible with EC free movement provisions (Articles 28-30 and 49) and competition law (Article 81)?
- Should the court make a reference to the Court of Justice of the European Communities on issues of Community law?
- Are QC Leisure, AV Station PLC, and individual directors personally liable for infringement?
- Is there a basis for awarding additional damages for flagrancy under section 97(2) of the CDPA?
Arguments of the Parties
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Murphy v Media Protection Services Ltd [2007] EWHC 3091 (Admin) | Interpretation of "programme included in a broadcasting service" under s.297 CDPA | Supported the view that FAPL's transmission constitutes a broadcasting service provided from the UK; addition of commentary and logos does not change identity of programme. |
| CBS Songs v Amstrad Consumer Electronics [1988] RPC 567 | Law of authorisation of copyright infringement | Distinguished from decoder cards; supply of decoder cards constitutes authorisation to use them for intended purpose. |
| Spelling Goldberg Productions v BPC Publishing Ltd [1981] RPC 283 | Whether single frames of film constitute infringement | Held individual frames do not infringe copyright; court applied this in assessing copying in decoder boxes. |
| Newspaper Licensing Agency v Marks & Spencer plc [2001] RPC 76 | Consideration of substantial part in copyright infringement | Discussed cumulative copying; court found successive transient copies not to constitute substantial part. |
| Australian Video Retailers Assn Ltd v Warner Home Video (2001) 53 IPR 242 | Temporary copying in RAM and its sufficiency for infringement | Supported view that transient copies in decoder RAM do not embody substantial part of work. |
| Bookmakers Afternoon Greyhound Services v Wilf Gilbert (Staffordshire) Ltd [1994] FSR 723 | Whether showing on television screens amounts to copying | Held that displaying copyrighted material on monitors may constitute reproduction in material form. |
| Betts v Wilmott (1871) LR 6 Ch 239 | Implied licence from sale of goods without restriction | Referenced in relation to whether sale of decoder cards without territorial restriction implies authorization for use. |
| Zino Davidoff v A&G Imports [2002] RPC 20 | Extent of consent required to exhaust trademark rights in parallel imports | Used to argue that consent to use must be unequivocal; court expressed sympathy but did not decide definitively. |
| MCA Records Inc v Charly Records Ltd [2002] FSR 26 | Liability of directors for company infringements | Applied to hold director personally liable where he was controlling mind and involved in infringing acts. |
| Musik-Vertrieb Membran GmbH v GEMA [1981] 2 CMLR 44 (CJEU) | Exhaustion of copyright and free movement of goods | Held that copyright owner cannot prevent importation of goods lawfully marketed in another Member State. |
| Coditel SA v Ciné Vog Films SA (Coditel I and II) [1980] ECR 81; [1982] ECR 3381 | Territorial licensing of performance rights and compatibility with EC law | Confirmed that exclusive territorial licenses for film exhibition do not infringe EC law per se; distinction from free movement of goods. |
| Glaxosmithkline v Commission T-168/01 [2006] ECR II-2969 (CFI) | Assessment of agreements limiting parallel trade under Article 81 EC | Held that limitation of parallel trade is not necessarily restrictive of competition without evidence of consumer harm. |
| Inco Europe v First Choice Distribution [2000] 1 WLR 586 (HL) | Principles for interpreting statutory provisions affecting rights | Emphasized caution in adding or omitting words in statute interpretation; applied in construing s.72 CDPA. |
| Sociedad General de Autores y Editores de España v Rafael Hoteles SA (Case C-306/05) [2007] Bus LR 521 (CJEU) | Communication to the public in hotels and copyright infringement | Held that distribution of broadcast signals via hotel television sets constitutes communication to the public under Directive 2001/29/EC. |
| Consten & Grundig v Commission (Joined Cases 56 & 58/64) [1966] ECR 299 | Absolute territorial protection and restriction of competition | Held that absolute territorial protection clauses constitute restrictions on competition contrary to Treaty. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court undertook a detailed analysis of the facts and applicable Community and UK law, focusing on the interpretation of Directive 98/84/EC (Conditional Access Directive), Directive 93/83/EEC (Satellite and Copyright Directive), Directive 2001/29/EC (Copyright and Information Society Directive), and relevant provisions of the CDPA.
On the key interpretive issue of the meaning of "illicit device," the court provisionally favored the defendants' view that the term applies to pirate decoder cards (unauthorized devices made without consent of the service provider) and does not extend to lawful decoder cards issued by the service provider but used outside the licensed territory. This interpretation aligns with the Directive's purpose to harmonize protection against commercial piracy without creating disproportionate barriers to the free movement of goods and services in the single market.
The court considered whether FAPL is a provider of a protected service under Directive 98/84/EC. It provisionally concluded that FAPL does provide a television broadcasting service, transmitting encrypted programmes intended for reception by the public, and would have a cause of action in respect of pirate decoder cards that give unauthorized access to its service.
Regarding the possession of illicit devices for commercial purposes, the court provisionally accepted that possession by traders or business users is covered by the Directive, distinguishing it from private possession.
The court rejected factual defenses that NOVA or ART authorized the sale or use of their decoder cards outside licensed territories, finding no consent or acquiescence on the evidence.
On copyright issues, the court found subsistence and title to copyright in most claimed works except for one film (IMG Match Film) which was not identified in evidence. It analyzed the nature of copying in decoder boxes and on television screens, concluding that transient copies of very short duration do not constitute copying of a substantial part of the works, and thus do not infringe copyright.
The court considered statutory defenses under section 28A CDPA implementing Article 5(1) of Directive 2001/29/EC, which exempts transient or incidental copies integral to technological processes. It provisionally found that transient copies in decoders and on screens have no independent economic significance and are covered by this exception.
On the allegation of communication to the public by pubs showing matches, the court provisionally held that the publicans do not themselves communicate to the public within the meaning of Directive 2001/29/EC, as they merely receive and display the broadcasts without retransmission.
In relation to public performance or playing of works (notably the Anthem), the court found that the defense under section 72 CDPA (free public showing or playing of broadcasts) applies to broadcasts, films, and sound recordings but does not extend to embedded musical works. Thus, the defense fails in respect of the musical work embodied in the Anthem.
The court discussed Directive 93/83/EEC, concluding provisionally that it does not provide a defense to copyright infringement claims as it harmonizes the place of communication (the country of transmission) but does not confer rights to receive, copy, or perform works.
Regarding free movement of goods and services under Articles 28-30 and 49 EC, the court acknowledged that lawful decoder cards placed on the market in one Member State should not be restricted in their circulation or use in other Member States absent specific legal justification, referencing the principle of exhaustion and relevant ECJ case law.
The defendants’ Article 81 EC (competition law) defense targeted the export restrictions in license agreements that prevent decoder cards from being used outside licensed territories. The court found the export restriction restricts trade and competition between Member States, but noted the claimants rely on exclusive territorial licenses which may be lawful under EC law. The court emphasized that the issue is complex, that the defendants had not provided detailed economic evidence, and that the question of whether the export restriction infringes Article 81 requires further authoritative guidance.
The court considered the law on authorization of infringement, concluding that the supply of decoder cards by QC Leisure and AV Station PLC constitutes authorization of any infringing acts by their customers, including the Madden defendants.
On personal liability, the court found Mr Richardson personally liable as QC Leisure is his trading name, and Mr Chamberlain personally liable due to his control over AV. It did not find sufficient evidence to hold Mr Raval personally liable for acts of SR Leisure.
On the issue of flagrancy and additional damages, the court found no evidence that the defendants knowingly infringed rights and rejected the claim for additional damages.
The court concluded that the case raises serious and fundamental questions of Community law concerning the cross-border broadcasting of encrypted television programmes, the interpretation of relevant Directives, and the compatibility of territorial licensing restrictions with EC law. It considered that these issues should be referred to the Court of Justice of the European Communities for authoritative determination.
Holding and Implications
The court decided to make a reference to the Court of Justice of the European Communities under Article 234 EC to seek authoritative rulings on the interpretation of key Community law issues raised by the claims under Directive 98/84/EC and related copyright infringement claims.
The direct effect of this decision is to delay final resolution of the claims until the Court of Justice provides guidance on the interpretation of "illicit device," the scope of protected services, the application of copyright and competition law in the context of cross-border broadcasting, and the legality of territorial licensing restrictions.
No new precedent is established by this first instance decision on the substantive claims, as the court expressed provisional views but recognized the complexity and importance of the issues require guidance from the highest European court.
Alert